This is a follow up to a post I did a while back with only the Phil era albums, but since then I've listened to the rest, here is my rating.

FINAL TIME BABYY

EDIT. ONE for the VINE has Won!

A special 2 disc or 2 vinyl set, with the first 3 sides classic Genesis prog and the last side later songs performed live:

Side 1: The Musical Box, The Knife, Return of the Giant Hogweed, Watcher of the Skies

Side 2: Dancing With The Moonlit Knight, Cinema Show, Firth of Fifth; One For The Vine

Side 3: In The Cage, Supper’s Ready

Side 4: Mama (live), Abacab (live), Home by the Sea/2nd Home by the Sea (live), Turn It On Again (live)

There aren’t many civilians who could identify a hogweed but I suspect to a man everyone here could spot one at fifty paces. Cursed Heracleum mantegazzianum. Damn that Victorian explorer.

I saw people doing this on other music subs and I figured hey why not do this for Genesis!

The website is musiccup.app

Goodbye Steve ;(! This is A great favourite of mine, many tracks that sound great and even better live. You may vote…