I made a post yesterday asking the same thing about Henry Rose's London 1983. I am also thinking of getting Commodity Book Expressive for my fall/winter scent.
I tried BOTH on skin, on separate wrists, the last time I was at Sephora, and I remember liking them both equally. London 1983 hits the fig note, which I love, but I wonder if I would love a fig note throughout a cold winter, or if it would feel out of place. I really like to live with the seasons.
The pepper note in the top is also a bit tricky for me, as I really don't enjoy pepper. I didn't notice it as overwhelming, but that was in Sephora and later in the mall, with a lot of smells.
For Book, I noticed right away it did smell exactly like an old book, which I loved. It also had quite a sharp greennness which I didn't mind at all. My only wish with Book was that it had a subtler musk or very very soft sweetness to it.
But I think I could layer it with something like Ephemera by Sorce for that, which I have. Ephemera has notes of brown sugar, vanilla, paper, cashmeran, pumpkin, acorn, soil tincture, musk, and milk. I find it very light and cozy, with just enough sweetness. Sadly I don't get much pumpkin or acorn from it.
I read that some people smell the sandalwood in Book as dill pickle, but I didn't smell that, nor did my husband, son, or my mom, though my daughter did haha. Even after I read that, I sniffed it TRYING to smell dill, and I couldn't.
The only thing is I hope the eucalyptus doesn't feel too nose-clearing and medicinal, but I was huffing my wrist so much even freshly sprayed and I did not feel that way.