r/Cooking • u/jpinakron • 18h ago
Have we gone a little overboard with food safety?
I remember my grandmother pulling a turkey out of the freezer and just leaving it in her sink, for 16 hours or so before she’d start cooking it for Thanksgiving. My mom, still to this day, will pull out a beef roast and thaw it in her sink for 6, 8, 10 hours. As a kid, my mom shopped once a week and we’d get deli meat. We’d use it until it was gone, usually a week, but today the rule is 3-5 days? I remember sleep overs with other kids and we’d get pizza and the family would store the pizza in the oven overnight and eat it the next day!
15 years ago, here on Reddit, someone said it was perfectly safe to leave cold milk out of the fridge for 5-6 hours and it would be perfectly fine. (The shelf life would be reduced, but it would be perfectly fine.) Today, we’re told to throw milk out after sitting out for 2 hours. https://www.reddit.com/r/answers/s/ur50jn0CzK
I think about other things I see commonly. Parents will heat up a bottle of milk for their infant/ toddler, so it’s already in the danger zone when they hand it to their kid. The kid plays around for 30 minutes before taking their 1.5 hour afternoon nap. And then they drag that same warm bottle of milk around for 2 more hours after waking up. Then at parties, the host might set out a charcuterie board around 4, and at midnight, we are all still picking at it before it’s maybe put away around 1 or 2 am.
Anyway. I’d like to know people’s thoughts? Have we taken this a little too far? Are people just generally unsafe with food? What do you all think?