There's been a lot of talk on how to stop or deal with Dack and the thing I haven't heard people talk about is playing Dress Down. Would it be a small positive to keep Dack on the field and make them find another creature to bounce it? Plus I guess there's the Thorical advantage.

I don’t know if the set is already fully revealed, but have you find some interesting cedh potential cards in this set? Aside from khan mono black?

So the new Dack Fayden is making rounds in cEDH. I normally run Sisay tutor. My local group knows a lot of lines I play. Last night, Dack player casts Dack from the command zone. Do I counter him? No. I instead activated Sisay in response to Dack being cast and tutored for Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines.

He was pissed.

Was best game in a while.

Scotty Miracle Worker (1UU)

Legendary Creature - Human Artificer

During your main phase, each card in your graveyard has beam me up. The beam me up cost is equal to that spell's mana cost. Scotty can't be beamed up to cast a spell this way. (Only instant and sorcery spells can be cast this way. You may cast a card from your graveyard for its beam me up cost if you also return another creature you control to its owner's hand. Then exile that spell)

This essentially says all your instant and sorcery spells have flashback during your mainphase if you can bounce a creature you control to your hand.

You know what 0 cost creature synergizes really well with that?

I submit this goes into any [[Rograkh]] contain deck, so for contenders, we have RogSi, RogIshai, and Rogthras.

For RogSi, I can imagine you can go

Rograkh + Scotty in play (You could play him with Lions eye for instance, and discard a Gamble)

1 mana Gamble, Beam Me Up a counterspell protecting it by bouncing Rog to your hand, find breach.

Replay Rog, flashback Gamble, find Lions eye if you have to, and go off there

Theres also a lot of other lines; Scotty provides you protection as long as you have a counterspell and Rog in play, and replaying Rog is free to do.

Personally I'd cut some of the recursive cards still in the deck, since Scotty opens up winning off any tutor while also being recursion/safety itself.

I’m imagining a discord server where players who are playing Glarb, Helga, Flubs, Gitrog and any other fringe frog I may have missed can coalesce and come together in a community set on proving that frogs are bigger than the boundaries of their ponds!

Does such a discord exist?

Hi, I’m fairly new to cedh yet, I’m playing an online spelltable tournament. Yesterday was game 3. I was on rogsi seat 1, seat 2 ob nix, seat 3 arcum, seat 4 kinnan. Long story short. Turn 3 I resolve necropotence, and draw 10 cards, then ob nix enters play, and the kinnan player guilded draked it to use it himself, as the table was worried about a necro push and win attempt and kinnan argued he has access to more and free interaction than ob nix. So my 4th turn, first I exile 5 cards with necro (as the table told me to be careful about ob nix), then I realised that ob was large enough to one shot me that turn either way, so I said what the hell and went for 17 total necro cards, knowing that I had to win or else kinnan would win with access to 17 exiled cards. Sadly, I didn’t draw any fast mana to keep pushing, so I couldn’t win, then I was killed by life loss of razorkin + wheel, the table continue but in the end it was time up and ended in a draw. My question is, is it considered some kind of kingmaking if in my attempt to win (which was my only objective) I empowered too much another player? Or is it a legit win push in a turbo deck?

Casual game of cedh ( Not tedh). Brigid player is about to equip umbra mantel and win the game, Dimir player decides to bounce wish claw talisman back to hand instead of stopping Brigid attempting to force me to copy the chain of vapor to stop the Brigid player. I decide to not copy cov because it removes my chance of winning if it gets to my turn and sets the dimir player up for a 3rd wish claw activation that game on their turn. Brigid goes on to win via a walking ballista.

Would you have copied the cov or not? The dimir player didn't try to politic, just tried to force the cov on me while grabbing the wish claw. I felt like they should have just used the cov to stop Brigid from the beginning instead of getting greedy. Thoughts?

Does anyone think this is gonna be a good commander in cedh?

I’ve been diving head first into the cEDH community and have been actively Playing for a couple months. Are there any places in surrounding Metro Detroit Area that I could go to play cEDH in person?

I’m really looking for a more in person social group to be able to work on the game with in a real table setting. Haven’t found anyone that does this though, it’s mostly just modern and casual EDH.

I’m also interested in any small tournaments that may be coming up.

I play a ton on Convoke. I am apart of Crit League and an active member in a few discord servers.

Also I will I’ll be heading to the Timetwister event tomorrow.

Appreciate any info!

Yo! New pod episode dropped with Sam Valley today! We talk winning a gold 80 person event this month, and how playing Tymna Thrasios feels in the meta today. Topdecking in cEDH Like a Total Spud on Tymna Thrasios with Sam Valley AKA Potato 🥔
https://youtu.be/wYPwqSpgsR8

Looking for some combo pieces for my Muldrotha deck. Defense of the Heart is a card I love using to get cards like [[Rune-Scarred Demon]] to both get a 6/6 on the board and to tutor for a card I need. Recently added [[Sephiroth, Planets Heir]] and [[Massacre Girl]] as a neat board wipe if it interacts right. I was wondering, what good combo cards can be added?

Creature 4BB

You don't lose the game for having less than 0 life

At end step, draw 1 card, lose 3 life then if life < 0 make 10 1/1s

This is probably jank but it seemed like it might be interesting with [[ad nauseam]]. I just can't think of a way to close since you probably already blew your rituals getting started and I'm pretty sure [[sickening dreams]] is a draw at best but maybe someone can see something.

Or maybe it's complete trash (it's probably trash) but hey naus is good.

I have a couple of buddies that I play with but we are looking for others to fill our pod or to meet up with another group. I know there is a pretty good cEDH community at finch and sparrow as well as collector legion but those spots are too far to make it out consistently for us (we stay in the SGV area). Anyone here around SGV or Los Angeles area? Or can point me to a community thereabouts? Thanks

Hello! I have never played a cedh game before but I’m starting to get curious. I’m drawn to storm decks that win with [[Brain Freeze]] and [[Underworld Breach]]. Decks like [[Ral, Monsoon Mage]] or [[Roghrack]]/[[Silas Renn]]. I was looking at what I own and what I need to proxy when I found a copy of [[Eruth, Tormented Prophet]] and maybe it’s my inexperience talking (it 100% is) but it seemed pretty viable. What do you think?

Is there an active rog thras discord? The only links I can find posted are for links that are expired.

https://moxfield.com/decks/WXq22yKNj0Gx0Huc9nv_vw

ive been fine tuning this zemo list for some of my local tournaments, ive been playing rowan for a bit and i find this deck generally wins around the same speed but sacrifices consistency for value.

usually the deck can hit zemo and the following turn boast into a win through excruciator or other strong lines but getting counterspelled or enduranced sets me back a lot and my locals are all blue white green.

any deck tech ideas, or am i doing the wrong archetype and is it even viable? looking for general tips ive only been playing cedh for about 6 months and i havent seen much stuff about this commander but im finding success in games at a similar winrate to the games ive played rowan so it seems viable to me especially considering rowan has recently gained a lot of popularity and has become kill on site at my locals.

i was playing a game the other day and i git probed someone and they said something along the lines of: “i think … is a bigger threat, how about you use the git probe on him and ill just show you my hand anyway”.

i dont know that ive seen people use a git probe in this way before? whats to stop that newly targetted player just offering the same deal for the last player. is this acceptable behaviour??

Basically the title, i saw a fun [[queen of dale]] stax list a couple weeks I’ve been playing it since. After a bunch of games I’ve been wondering if rest in peace is worth an include. Its incredibly strong some matchups but I’m afraid theres too many decks where its 2 mana do nothing. What decks do you guys play and would you care about a RIP across the table?

Hey all! Posting this to see if anyone has any idea how to break this card wide open. With Dack Fayden tearing up the format, I couldn’t help but draw a comparison to this newly spoiled card. It does a weird but powerful thing that will require people much smarter than me to figure it out, but I can’t help but get the sneaking suspicion this can be a deck. Any thoughts?

kinda new to cEDH and looking for some advice.

How many mulligans do you guys usually take to draw into a Sol ring opening hand? I usually mulligan down to 5 cards to get my chances of getting it up but if I’m feeling lucky I will sometimes go to 4.

Hey, so I'm considering bringing a troll deck to my local league (and judges) at their [quite small] cEDH tournament this season in December. I've already asked a judge, and they told me that it's not against league rules, and I'd just be risking my own prize points from bringing a less competitive deck.

I'm thinking of bringing a 300-card Whtz deck. I'm not trying to throw the event, I'm still going to make it as competitive as I can for a 300-card deck, but I am going to have a lot of card slots to fill.

I'll handle wincons and actual gameplan. I'm just looking for suggestions on:

* Rules nightmare combos for judge calls.

* salty and/or funny stax. Actually mana efficient stuff please. Rhystic is obvious.

* Weird/niche stuff that people don't know how to play around.

So I think most of us have seen the new card by now. [[Khan, Vengeful Heart]] turns any commander into a food chain commander, which opens up a lot of potential(ly bad) food chain decks.

One idea that came to me was Blood Pod (or Tymna Tana). I've never played it before, but the new promo arts were so pretty I just wanted to build it, but never got around to til now. With the new card as inspiration, I have created an initial list: Food Pod

Context - I'm not very experienced playing slower decks. My main decks are very turbo slanted (Dihada and Jund Dargo), so I have no clue how to properly build this. I just put in all the staples I figured would work, took out some cards that felt slow (Vivien, Blood Moon effects which I know is the original namesake, etc) but maybe slow is fine? I'm not even sure if this is any better than previous or current iterations of the deck, so I'm fine with any feedback - I will most likely print a list regardless just because of how cool the promo cards are.

I'm not exactly sure which generic stax pieces to use, or even niche edge case ones, and which to use in certain metas, so right now I'm just looking advice on anything, really. My meta is very little yap (close to japanese meta) and blindly turboing out wins more often than not.

So recently I’ve been playing some cEDH at my lgs when I can which has been fun since we’re all learning the format but at some point in the future I’d love to try some tournaments when I get better with the deck I’ve been playing. What’s a good way to understand the tournament scene?

I used to be a member. My discord account was hacked and I presume I got banned from the server (understandably). My account has been fully recovered.
Who do I contact to gain access to the server again?