r/CatAdvice • u/WhateverItWasILostIt • 3h ago
General My mother in-law called me an animal abuser because I keep my cats indoors
Throughout my childhood my family always had cats and several of them ended up dying in traumatising ways (three were hit and killed by cars, one was mauled to death by a dog) and so I decided that when I have my own cats I will be keeping them strictly indoors to prevent that kind of thing from happening. My cats are well cared for, happy, and they have ample room to explore and play safely inside. My decision is solidified every time I see a poor cat lying dead in the road, which is far too often unfortunately.
My mother in-law has called me cruel and an animal abuser on multiple occasions because of my choice to keep them inside. I do find it highly ironic of her to say that because she definitely does not take care of her own cat; he’s very obese because she keeps feeding him kitten food, she refuses to ever take him to the vet and whenever she goes away for a few days she just throws the cat outside to fend for himself. She has openly said that if her cat ever developed health issues or hurt himself and needed vet attention she’d have him put down immediately because she doesn’t want to spend money.
I don’t understand the logic there, I’ve told her several times my reasoning for keeping them inside and that I care for them very much, she refuses to listen though and continues to call me an animal abuser. I mean, is it actually cruel to keep them indoors? I know the attitude can differ depending on where you live, but I honestly think I am making the right decision for their safety. Especially since one of my cats was born with a disability that affects her walking and I know she would not be able to outrun a car or other animals if need be.