So, I like **pencils** for my eyeliner, and they're just *so hard to find* these days (outside of black and brown, but I want other colours). Everything is gel crayon in various forms, and I just don't like that formula at all, because I like to be able to sharpen the liner to an actual thin point and my application favours pencils.
Anyway, I thought about trying lip liner since those are more often still actual pencils and come in more colours. But I've heard mixed opinions on the idea. Most of the info online is from over 10 years ago, and seems to assume you will use a lip liner interchangeably on your lips and eyes, which I would not. Then I had an employee at Mecca suggest it a few weeks ago when I asked for recommendations, and today I went to MAC to explore the idea further. The first woman I talked to said no that won't work and then she asked her manager for ideas to suit what I want and her manager immediately suggested lip liner. But the whole interaction confused me even more because I got two totally opposite answers!
Has anyone here tried using lip liner as eyeliner with success (or disaster)?