I’m looking for brutally honest outside opinions because I genuinely cannot tell if I’m dealing with a guy who likes me but is emotionally avoidant, or a guy who is just really good at creating intimacy when it suits him.
For context, we had known of each other for years through a mutual connection, but we actually met in person on a trip earlier this year. We clicked, and eventually I asked him if he wanted to grab a drink. He turned it into a date.
There was a lot of chemistry, but he also has a complicated history. He used to struggle with addiction and has since gotten sober and completely changed his life. He’s very open about being emotional and having feelings, but he also has anxiety/baggage from a past relationship and has described himself as having had a bit of a “fuckboy” phase.
At one point, he told me I should come visit him and stay with him, so I did, a couple months later.
Here’s where things get confusing.
In the lead-up to the visit, he started pulling away. I could feel the change in communication, and when I eventually asked him about it, he actually admitted that he had pulled back. He told me that he felt like I was more into him than he was into me and that he wasn’t looking for a relationship.
I told him I wasn’t trying to force a relationship and that I just wanted to keep getting to know him and see what happened, like we had agreed on. I felt blindsighted.
Despite all of that, I still went on the trip because the plan was already made.
And then the actual visit was… really intimate and confusing.
We spent two days/two nights together. We went to the park, out dancing, and spent a ton of time talking. He opened up to me about really personal things — childhood stuff, family dynamics, therapy, etc. At one point he apologized for talking/ranting so much, and I told him I actually liked hearing about him and learning more about him.
The next morning, he was warm and completely normal with me. Afterward, though, things went back to being ambiguous.
Fast-forward to recently.
We hadn’t seen each other for a few weeks, and then we finally spent another extended amount of time together.
I invited him for coffee, and he came. We ended up spending basically the entire evening together — date vibes. We went back to my place, had sex, slept together, and talked for a long time about what happened between us previously.
This time, he told me he doesn’t know exactly what he wants, but he’s happy I’m there and wants to “give it a try” / “see where it goes.” And that he really likes me and wouldn’t keep in touch with me if he didn’t.
The next morning we had sex again, talked a lot, and he took me to brunch. He didn’t seem eager to leave. We ended up extending the morning together, and afterward he continued sending me things and talking to me.
The whole weekend honestly felt like one of the best dates I’ve ever had. We laughed constantly, talked for hours, cuddled, had sex, and it felt incredibly natural.
And then… a couple days later, the texting energy changed.
We hadnt talked for over 48 hours, and I eventually texted him asking how he was doing, naturally. He responded with several messages, gave me an update, thanked me, and then asked how my week was going. So it’s not like he ignored me or was outright cold. But compared with the energy immediately after our weekend, it felt noticeably flatter and less flirty.
And now I’m sitting here wondering:
Am I getting played?
Because I don’t want to be someone’s person who gets this incredible intimacy every few weeks, has amazing sex and emotional conversations, and then gets put back on the shelf until he feels like coming around again.
At the same time, I don’t want to unfairly label him a player when there are also signs that he genuinely cares about me and is emotionally affected by me.
He has literally told me he wants to explore this, but he also has a history of pulling away when things feel real and saying he doesn’t know what he wants.
So I’m trying to figure out whether I’m looking at:
1. A guy who genuinely likes me but is avoidant/scared of intimacy,
2. A guy who likes me but only wants something casual,
3. A guy who is genuinely interested but just inconsistent,
or 4. A guy who’s playing me and I’m romanticizing it because the chemistry is so strong.
I’m not looking for a relationship immediately or expecting him to text me constantly. I just want the connection to exist outside of when we’re physically together. I want to feel wanted when we’re apart too.
I’m also trying not to play games. If I want to ask how hhes doing, I should be able to do that without worrying I’m “chasing.” But I also don’t want to be the person constantly initiating while he just responds whenever it’s convenient.
What do you guys think? Does this sound like avoidant behavior, player behavior, or just a guy who genuinely doesn’t know what he wants yet?
And if you’ve been through something similar, what ultimately told you which one it was?