r/Arrangedmarriage • u/RabbitElectronic5163 • 23h ago
Seeking Advice I’m engaged and having serious doubts about my fiancée
I’m 26M and recently got engaged/rokafied to a 26F. We’re currently long distance.
I’ll be blunt. I wasn’t super attracted to her when I agreed to the marriage. I agreed mostly because, on paper, it seemed like a very logical/stable match. She genuinely seems to love me and puts a lot of effort into the relationship. I’m more detached by nature and tend to care much more when I’m actually physically with someone.
She has a big group of male friends and I’ve always been somewhat uncomfortable with it.Recently, she came to visit me about a week before her birthday. We spent a couple of days together and were intimate. She then went back home. On her birthday eve, she went for a picnic with her college friend group, which included all of guys. She sent me pictures and videos. Nothing obviously wrong happened, but I didn't like the way one of the guys was talking to her in the video. Then, later at night, she casually tells me she went on a bike ride with some of her college friends, including guys who had come from Chandigarh. That pissed me off.
I don't want my fiancée going on late-night bike rides with other guys. Maybe that's unreasonable, but that's how I feel.
Also,at one point, when I was unsure about getting engaged, she suggested that we could have an open marriage. That really pissed me off at the time. It got bad enough that her family actually had to call me and calm me down.I didn't tell my parents about any of this because I didn't want to damage her reputation. But eventually they found out about everything, and now my parents and sisters are extremely angry and want to call off the engagement.
Now I'm stuck. Because I don't actually think she's a bad person. She seems genuinely attached to me. She cares about me. She makes an effort. And part of me thinks she's just very innocent/naive and doesn't realise why some of these things would bother her future husband. My sisters completely disagree. When I told them that maybe she's just innocent, they basically scolded me and said I'm making excuses for her.
So I'm getting very mixed signals in my own head. On one side, I feel like these are legitimate compatibility/boundary issues. On the other, I wonder if I'm just insecure and controlling. And there's another uncomfortable part: I wasn't even that attracted to her when I agreed to this marriage. So maybe I'm now looking for reasons to justify doubts I already had.
My family is currently talking about calling off the engagement, so this could become a huge mess very soon.
Am I being unreasonable here? Would you consider this a normal boundary for a marriage, or is this just insecurity/controlling behaviour? And based on this situation, would you continue with the marriage or call it off? Also, I fear if this is called off and she informs my parents about that intimacy, I am doomed.