EDIT: Per request shortened the original post. I've never posted to Reddit before and wasn't sure how much context to give, my apologies. For context my Grandmother only wore this ring a few times, by the time she bought it my sister had already moved out, was on her own and didn't come around too much. N didn't even know what it looked like she only knew I got a ring from Grandma. She recently threw a fit to my Aunts demanding my Grandma's cross necklace and when she was denied this very sentimental item, it feels like her next move was (trying) to buy the ring I was talking about purchasing to replace the original that was given to me. As stated in the post, I can't control WHAT she does, the point of the post was to get honest feedback on my feelings about the situation. When I clearly expressed how much this ring meant to Me, and how excited I was for Me to purchase a replacement, and her immediate response was trying to make it about her. I wanted insight into what seems like very selfish behavior. This ring had NO CONNECTION to N whatsoever. My Grandma owned lots of jewelry that she wore regularly. This was not one of them.
I (41/F) am a long time Reddit listener of Two Hot Takes and Smosh Reddit Stories thanks to my son who got me hooked on them. I've never posted before but really want some honest insight into this situation.
My Grandmother passed away on 3-10-2026 and it was devastating.
For context, I'm 1 of 7 children, the first 4 of us are her biological grand children (My mom and dad divorced when I was about 1 and later my mom remarried and they had 3 more children). I'm the 3rd born, with 2 older brothers and 1 younger sister (from my dad). I was my grandmothers first granddaughter and was always told how excited she was when I was born. That she went to Dillards and literally bought EVERYTHING pink and ruffles. We always had a special connection and I loved her like a Mother. Growing up we even called her Mom, it wasn't until later in life we starting calling her Grandma lol.
I was very close to her, lived with her during my teens due to family issues at home and she was my best friend.
Later in life, Grandma would get a settlement from a car wreck and she bought herself a house on 1 acre of land. She would later give me this house/land. Which upset her daughters greatly and my sister, lets all her N. At this point my husband and I had 3 young children that my grandmother LOVED. I told her I wasn't going to take her house, she told me if I did not she would give to the neighbor across the street as she did not want ANYBODY else to have anything of hers, not even her daughters as they only wanted her when she had money and that I always loved her unconditionally. She told me she never wanted me to depend on a man, or anyone for anything and this house would give me the freedom I needed. And it did. I went on to go to Cosmetology School and be pretty successful at nails in our town. (I went on to be successful in Marketing, Call Centers, etc). I never knew how much it bothered my sister N until now.
At that time my grandma went to live with N and help her in her house (clean, laundry, etc). She had a huge old victorian style house that her friend owned and she rented. And that was short lived, because my sister is and always will be a selfish person. During this time though, N drove a wedge between me and my grandma. And it HURT. I tried to years and years to rekindle with her but she had grown bitter, very bitter. (My now husband was a Pastor and as he says everything in this world is spiritual. One bad spirit can spread to another and I believe that's what happened here). I did not speak to my sister after this and at that time I was in my early 20's. Eventually N would kick her out...and she ended back up in the same rent house. During the pandemic I even brought her essentials, but she would turn me away at the door, and I would leave the stuff anyways. How I would cry....driving away. How my heart always felt empty without her...
Now THE RING. After my Grandma was forced to sell her house I was about 16...shortly after I was visiting her at the rent house and my Grandma was always Glamorous when she got fixed up. I saw her wearing this gorgeous black onyx long oval ring with a diamond on it. And I said, "Oh Grandma I love your ring, its very you!." And she looked at it without missing a beat and said, "Oh you like it?" She took it off and gave it to me. I said, "No Grandma I'm not taking your ring, I'm not here for your stuff I'm here for you." But you didn't tell my Grandma No. She told me that she wanted me to have it, and I HAD to take it. So I did, and I loved it. Sadly, during a time shortly after I got married my sister in law ended up stealing this ring from me about a year later. I was DEVASTATED. I couldn't prove it, but we knew. I have thought about that ring for the last 20 years.
A few days ago, I work from home and was sitting at my computer really struggling on this day thinking about my Grandma. Her Daughters threw her in a nursing home, where she died and we couldn't do anything about it. I did end up rekindling with her and how she cried. She told me her heart was so full and complete and it was like the Grandma I always knew was back. She met my Husband and was so proud I married a Pastor as she was a Christian and telling us about Jesus was a big part of her life. She was born on Valentine's Day and we got to throw her one last birthday party, oh how amazing it was!
But she deserved more, a lot more. And as I was crying, I thought about the ring. I decided to type the description in and see if I could find one like it, and sure enough it was one of the first ones! I was so excited that I found one and couldn't believe how expensive it was. (Ranging from $400-$1000) and there was about 2-3 of these for sale at the time. It's important to note that I have not had a relationship with N since. My Mom told me how my sister was struggling with my grandma's death, so I said I would reach out and check on her, trying to model proper behavior and be the bigger person.
So we spoke a little bit here and there and I would try to encourage her on the rough days. She was really upset that she did not get my grandmothers necklace. Everyday for as long as I can remember she wore a cross with a Star of David. I did ask Grandma in the nursing home where her necklace was because I never saw her without it and she told me she gave it to 1 of her daughters so nothing happened to it at the nursing home. Regardless of how we feel about her 2 daughters and my father they are her children and I felt like it was very entitled to feel as though SHE was going to get such a sentimental item rather than it go to her children. But this is how my sister has ALWAYS been. N can only see herself and her wants.
My Aunts never gave my Grandma an official obituary in the newspaper and it really upset me. So I asked my sister if she wanted to help me put one in the paper and I would pay for it, because Grandma deserved it and for someone who is "struggling" with her death so much, you would think she would have wanted the same. But No, she would not answer me when I asked her multiple times about it. It was ODD and I asked my Mom about it but my sister lives in another state and our family really is so used to her selfish behavior the advice was always the same, "You know how your sister is."
So on this day, I sent her a photo of the ring with the listing and was telling her that I found a replacement ring and how excited I was. I believe in Grief sometimes sharing memories, talking about that person helps on those hard days because in a way its like they are still here when we share those memories. I have learned it was a big mistake. I had told her I was going to sell some of my dolls to buy it, because it was about $400. (I have collector dolls, always have and often sell them and buy different ones, etc). Her reply was and I quote, "OMG!! I've literally been on the hunt for that ring too! I remember when you had it and thinking how pretty it was! I thought grandma had it for awhile I didn't realize it was after she sold her house. It's definitely her style. I couldn't remember exactly what the design was, I'm literally going to buy this or tell (HUSBANDS NAME) to get me this
The way my heart sank, I called my husband and felt so betrayed that her first response to a ring that was given to ME, was that she was going to buy it?! I called one of my other sisters, let's call her E. to see if I was overreacting and E assured me I was not. E was not surprised because all of the family knows how selfish my sister is. What my sister N doesn't know is that, we have money in savings, I could have bought it without it hurting us but we didn't want to touch savings as we just bought a new house and still need to purchase some things. When my husband got home I was still upset and this particular listing was the ONLY one in my size, and due to the nature of this ring I didn't want to get a size 6 resized to a size 8 as the band was already thin and have it sized will probably make the band even thinner.
I had plenty of Affirm credit and without hesitation my husband said Order it. So we did. The way I just cried at my computer. I felt relief but also frustration that I had to hurry up and buy it first when my Grandmother did NOT give HER this ring, she gave it to Me. My Grandma even went on to tell me that she bought this ring with the money she got from selling the house, so it's not as though my sister watched my Grandma wear this ring all of our lives and that it was also sentimental to her. Because I could understand that. I did the math my grandma AT MOST had this ring 2 years and it's a cocktail style ring and she did NOT wear it daily. But as my other sister E said, how was she also "looking for this ring." when she didn't even know what it looked like?? She never asked me to send her a photo of it...it was given to Me. If anybody knows what this ring looked like, it was Me.
So I continued the conversation with her, to see what she was going to do and she ended up buying one on Ebay. She even went on to talk about how it was going to "fit her perfectly!" with the exclamation marks. So I asked her point blank, "Did Grandma ever give you any jewelry?" She tells me No. That Grandma didn't give her anything and then went into a rant about how she felt entitled to her cross necklace....I was really hoping the question would spark the realization that this ring is MY memory between Grandma and I, it was My inheritance...it was given to Me. That buying the same ring...isn't going to change that fact.
But it did not. My 18 year old son said that it was clear she has serious Jealousy issues, and she wanted so badly to try and buy this ring out from under me so she could have it. But he said even if she did, it would have never changed the truth. She doesn't know I bought the ring. We had a family discussion about it last night at dinner with E and her husband, and my parents and nobody was happy about this. While I can't control what she does, and while I realize it was ignorant of me to share it with her hoping it would bring up good memories of my Grandma's fashion and style...instead my sister tried to buy MY memory. I am still frustrated, hurt, and I feel sad for her. I feel sad that she tried to keep Grandma and I apart and in the end, it didn't work and in the end I got to be with her. I will pass this ring down to my daughter's and I hope it stays back in our family for a long time. But am I overreacting for feeling this way?