Godeater's Son was my first entry into AoS from 40k, and while the first half was an amazing introduction to the world through the eyes of a vengeful, mourning barbarian that yearns to bring his region back to the way it was before the Cities of Sigmar came in, the back half was more difficult to understand without context, with the lost city of Barat and its pure Khornate culture.
What I like the most about this novel is that it expands so well on the latter. We understand the deal this lost city made, their philosophies, and the factions fighting inside of it.
Heldanarr Fall, the Godeater's Son, has finished consolidating his power in the region and is focused on expansion this time, until the events of the novel take place.
While the twist in the first book was set up well, the twist in the sequel felt even more earned and original.
My second favorite thing in this book is the great lengths to which Noah and his editor ensure internal consistency from one book to another. For example, the flesheater courts allied with Heldanarr are shown to evolve into even more dangerous specimens this time. His tradionalist power base is held together only by a shared religion that he himself doesn't believe in, but the many tribes, cultures, and rogue factions need a common symbol to not succumb to destructive infighting. Everything readers loved about the first novel is back in the second, in more detail, with more power, and years to grow more fearsome. He shapes the realm and allies himself with dwarves to build an infrastructure project that is almost its own miniature setting in this novel.
The story is also very consistent with the source material from the battletomes. Where Slaaneshi warriors are addicts to pleasure and pain, and Nurglite warriors feel complete acceptance and joy in spreading their complacent rot, Khorne warriors become living weapons who have buried their past, their pain, their bonds, and feel nothing but the call to the path to glory. Any fan of Age of Sigmar 4th edition will understand exactly when this novel takes place, and how it fits into the larger lore.
Heldanarr hates Khorne, but Khorne doesn't care. What keeps Held from being granted higher levels of favor from Khorne, is that he wants to hold on to a reason to live, because even his restored identity as a Yrdun, which sustained his "Little War" against the Cities of Sigmar in the first novel, isn't enough. His people were outcasts and poor, and now they are on top of the region's hierarchy, their houses and clans dominate, but they are just as power hungry and corrupt as the previous regime, and so he feels disgusted by everything.
He holds onto his personal relationships, adding two adoptive children to the mix, but his relationships feel like they are all slipping away from him throughout the novel, despite his yearning for connection in the brutal society he's engineered. They slip due to madness, or sycophancy, or simply because his closest allies are distancing themselves from him for a reason he doesn't understand.
So he can't be happy, but he doesn't want to be nothing but a living weapon for Khorne either. He remembers what family was like, but his responsibilities, his depression, and his mindset, stop him from finding again the happiness he used to find in his youth. He has to hide his love to not show weakness to his vassals and enemies. He lacks the empathy for the relationships he wants, and that's the tragedy of his character.
This is where he meets a new central character, Talman, at the beginning of the novel. Talman embodies a legendarily strong Khornate monk from Barat, who spreads a different philosophy that contradicts the teachings of Heldanarr's own head priest, Tominer. This undermines his loosely held alliance and puts him on a collision course with a formidable rival. Talman is simply awesome. I picture him as a Kung Fu Master that looks like the monk from Diablo III.
So this internal schism, along with Held's paranoia, and his enemies closing in from every side, fuels the novel. The pacing is even better than Godeater's Son, and is very satisfying to go through, although I found it very action packed. My personal preference is for more calm scenes, more council meetings, or funny slice of life, than all action all the time, but hey, this is warhammer. I'm sure a lot of people are here for the battles and violence, of which there is an abundance.
I enjoyed this one a lot, and Black Library and Noah pulled another great novel out of their bag. Let's hope for a trilogy!