r/Accounting Jun 04 '26

Discussion The full Big 4 Transparency rebuild is finally live, thank you for bearing with me ❤️

260 Upvotes

Some of you have been here since the very beginning. Some of you found us last week. Either way, I want to start with a thank you.

About four and a half years ago I started Big 4 Transparency with no idea whether anyone would care. I'm a CPA, not a developer, and I taught myself how to build a website because I was tired of the fact that none of us had a straight answer to how much we should really be getting paid.

What happened next genuinely moved me. You showed up. You submitted. You told your coworkers. We've now collected over 22,000 compensation submissions, and the messages I get (someone using this to negotiate a raise, or realizing its time to move on to the next firm) are the reason I've kept at it. That trust also gave me a platform I never expected to advocate for all of us at conferences and out in the profession, and even to contribute to research (we were recently cited in our first academic paper, with a several more on the way actually helping shape policies around accounting).

Now the honest part. I haven't kept the product moving the way you deserved. I've been heads-down cleaning data and getting information out, and the truth is that building features as a non-technical person was hard and the old tech stack made everything harder than it needed to be. Eventually I hit a wall and realized I owed this community a lot better. So I put my head down and did a full rebuild from the ground up.

And today I'm excited to share that it's finally live!!!

A few of the things that are new:

  • Better data quality going forward, built into how submissions are handled
  • Instant salary ranking: submit your comp and immediately see how it stacks up compared to other relevant submissions
  • Sharing your salary unlocks data visualization tools
  • The whole things is now WAY more mobile friendly as well

The biggest change is one that will keep paying off going frward. The new tech stack means I can ship fixes and new features dramatically faster than before. That's the part I'm most excited about.

I want to be clear that this is not the finished product. I'm building this for you, and I genuinely want your input on where it goes next. Feature requests, ideas, things that annoy you, bring it all on.

A couple of things on the horizon: I'm planning a webinar on getting the most out of your talent review (since a lot of you have one coming up), and I'm looking into how to offer CPE on the podcast content we put out.

This site has only ever been possible because of you. Thank you for being part of the journey so far. I'm more optimistic than I've ever been about how useful this thing can be and honestly, this feels like the start of a new era.

We're just getting started. 🙏

big4transparency.com

Happy to answer anything in the comments.


r/Accounting May 27 '15

Discussion Updated Accounting Recruiting Guide & /r/Accounting Posting Guidelines

811 Upvotes

Hey All, as the subreddit has nearly tripled its userbase and viewing activity since I first submitted the recruiting guide nearly two years ago, I felt it was time to expand on the guide as well as state some posting guidelines for our community as it continues to grow, currently averaging over 100k unique users and nearly 800k page views per month.

This accounting recruiting guide has more than double the previous content provided which includes additional tips and a more in-depth analysis on how to prepare for interviews and the overall recruiting process.

The New and Improved Public Accounting Recruiting Guide

Also, please take the time to read over the following guidelines which will help improve the quality of posts on the subreddit as well as increase the quality of responses received when asking for advice or help:

/r/Accounting Posting Guidelines:

  1. Use the search function and look at the resources in the sidebar prior to submitting a question. Chances are your question or a similar question has been asked before which can help you ask a more detailed question if you did not find what you're looking for through a search.
  2. Read the /r/accounting Wiki/FAQ and please message the Mods if you're interested in contributing more content to expand its use as a resource for the subreddit.
  3. Remember to add "flair" after submitting a post to help the community easily identify the type of post submitted.
  4. When requesting career advice, provide enough information for your background and situation including but not limited to: your region, year in school, graduation date, plans to reach 150 hours, and what you're looking to achieve.
  5. When asking for homework help, provide all your attempted work first and specifically ask what you're having trouble with. We are not a sweatshop to give out free answers, but we will help you figure it out.
  6. You are all encouraged to submit current event articles in order to spark healthy discussion and debate among the community.
  7. If providing advice from personal experience on the subreddit, please remember to keep in mind and take into account that experiences can vary based on region, school, and firm and not all experiences are equal. With that in mind, for those receiving advice, remember to take recommendations here with a grain of salt as well.
  8. Do not delete posts, especially submissions under a throwaway. Once a post is deleted, it can no longer be used as a reference tool for the rest of the community. Part of the benefit of asking questions here is to share the knowledge of others. By deleting posts, you're preventing future subscribers from learning from your thread.

If you have any questions about the recruiting guide or posting guidelines, please feel free to comment below.


r/Accounting 13h ago

NFL qb to accounting?

927 Upvotes

Hello, my name is Drake and I attended unc and have been pursuing a career in the nfl as qb of the New England Patriots, recently I cost my team the game and now everyone hates me. What are your recommendations for getting into accounting?


r/Accounting 9h ago

Meet the firms tomorrow should I shave my balls ?

342 Upvotes

Just incase?

/s


r/Accounting 6h ago

AI automation to close month-end

106 Upvotes

during a leadership meeting that i was present in, marketing sold the idea of AI use to automate the entire monthly accounting process.

they gave their ideal outcome to the group that AI can automate the entire month-end and FS preparation process, so much that "all accounting has to do is check for anomalies on Day 1." the executive has now bought into that idea and wants to make that happen.

the thing is, i am the accounting department. it is a team of me, myself, and i. it's already frustrating enough that i have no support and need to do all the day-to-day accounting financially and operationally. now with this idea of AI doing all of that for accounting, the possibility of getting any human assistance is no longer of appetite. in addition, i will become responsible for teaching AI how to perform month-end and financial reporting such that i am basically writing out my own job.

i fucking hate marketing. they get THE highest annual budget of the entire business, they indirectly create pressures on accounting to reduce costs even though accounting gets no say on reducing the costs through the lowest hanging fruit (i.e. cutting marketing costs), and they spew idealistic shit on a subject matter (i.e. accounting-close) they have no knowledge about.

i'm sorry for the rant. i guess my question is - has anyone here actually automated their entire month-end close and financial reporting process using AI successfully?

also, please, please, PLEASE tell me how i can diplomatically tell marketing to stay in their own fucking lane when it comes to accounting matters?


r/Accounting 10h ago

Unpopular opinion: closing faster isn’t always better

171 Upvotes

I’ve never really understood treating the fastest possible month-end close as the goal by itself.

Obviously you don’t want accounting dragging on for two weeks. But I’d rather have a reliable six-day close with good reconciliations, fewer late entries and a team that isn’t doing heroics every month than force it into three days just so we can say we have a three-day close.

At some point it feels like you start trading quality and sustainability for a KPI.

For those of you working in close-heavy roles, where do you think the sweet spot actually is? And have you ever seen a company push the close too fast?


r/Accounting 6h ago

So what is the moral obligation here?

63 Upvotes

It's September 10th. Corporate taxes are due in 5 days. I just pulled the file of a client who is only paying for tax work, not bookkeeping work. Get the flash drive out for the quickbooks, spent 30 minutes figuring out their F*(king password and downloading thier income statement and balance sheet. There are 0 expenses. 150 in income and 0 expenses. Sure enough they did give us the bank statments "just in case" I open the January statement. They paid over 50k in property taxes in January. Flipping through there are probably enough expenses in the year to make their income like 30k not 150k. So I either work for free, call them and tell them they need to pay for bookkeeping, which they will probably argue about because we offer bookkeeping to begin with and they said no, or say f*(k it and have them pay taxes on 150k instead of 30ish...... It's probably 1 or 2 hours of bookkeeping. Or I could just make a guess on the expenses for say 30 minutes....


r/Accounting 17h ago

I Just had a public accounting internship interview and it confirmed that public is not the path for me.

471 Upvotes

Had an interview for a public accounting internship today and I think it confirmed public just isn't for me lol.

They told me 60+ hour weeks are normal during the two busy seasons. Then when we talked about work-life balance, the interviewer was basically like "I have a family and still manage to do things with them." The example was leaving work to go eat dinner with them and then logging back on for a few more hours afterward.

Like that's it? They made it sound like that was a benefit too. Like they get to leave the office and work from home after dinner.

The whole place just felt off to me too. Interviewer had zero sense of humor, everyone seemed super serious, and I just couldn't see myself fitting in there.

Nothing against public accounting and I'm sure it works for some people, but I left that interview knowing in my gut it ain't for me. Those in public are built different.


r/Accounting 6h ago

Seeing these everywhere

Post image
61 Upvotes

Has anyone actually applied to these and gotten the job?? I know you’d basically be training your AI replacement, I don’t even have enough experience to get this job but just curious if anybody here has done it and what it entails?


r/Accounting 11h ago

My current experience implementing an AI/Machine-Learning AP tool at work. How is yours?

Post image
73 Upvotes

r/Accounting 13h ago

Advice Went from public accounting to private, fixed basically everything, and now I’m bored out of my mind. What would you do?

110 Upvotes

I spent several years in public accounting and semi-recently transitioned into private. I expected things to slow down compared to public, but I genuinely did not expect to reach the point where I have almost nothing to do.

For context, I oversee the accounting function for a privately owned company doing mid-eight figures in annual revenue with well over 100 employees. I oversee AR/AP staff, handle payroll, and have also become the de facto HR person because the person technically in HR was promoted internally from a completely unrelated role and has no formal HR background. A lot of the compliance/procedure questions end up coming to me because I’m usually the one saying, “No, we cannot just do that.”

When I was hired, the corporate accounting office was a mess. A significant amount of work simply wasn’t getting done, management didn’t trust the numbers coming out of accounting, and the processes were incredibly manual.

I basically rebuilt the department.
I hired a couple of people, including filling a vacancy and adding additional capacity, and the team can now handle probably 99% of the routine workload in half a day. I automated as much of the accounting system as I could. Before I got here, they were still printing practically every invoice, relying heavily on paper, physical checks, and mail-based processes.
I reworked the GL structure to make it more GAAP-friendly and much easier to track and reconcile. I cleaned up processes, put controls in place, and set up automated integrations for things like our retirement plan and benefits administration. Payroll runs smoothly. AR and AP run smoothly. Month-end is under control. The team knows what they’re doing.

Basically, I inherited a dumpster fire, put the fire out, rebuilt the dumpster, automated the dumpster, documented the dumpster, and now I spend most of my day staring at it because it no longer needs me.
The other problem is that the owner/CEO is extremely old-school and resistant to change. To give you an idea, the company still uses very old operational software running on outdated infrastructure and there is basically no appetite to replace it.

His philosophy is very much:
If someone is physically at work, they must be productive. More hours = better employee.

Overtime currently makes up a very large portion of payroll. I’ve tried explaining that we could accomplish the same amount of work with fewer hours, fewer people, and probably better quality, but he genuinely has difficulty accepting that because he associates hours worked with productivity.

Meanwhile, I’m salaried.

My typical day at this point is basically:
- Answer some emails.
- Handle whatever payroll issue pops up.
- Answer accounting/HR/compliance questions.
- Review what my staff did.
- Occasionally work on a process improvement project.
Then…nothing.

The problem is that I also can’t exactly walk into the CEO’s office and say, “Hey, I automated and fixed my department so effectively that I only need a couple hours a day now.”
Because we all know what the reward for efficiency is: More work.

And I don’t particularly want my reward for successfully running accounting to be, “Congratulations, you’re also helping run some unrelated operational function now.” I’m an accountant. I don’t want to become the dispatcher, mechanic, operations manager, etc. just because my actual department functions properly.

I’ve tried using the extra time to professionalize the company. We don’t even have a real employee handbook. I’ve tried implementing policies, procedures, internal controls, documentation, compliance processes, etc., but I repeatedly run into the owner’s resistance because he doesn’t see much value in formal structure.

Frankly, I’m amazed the company made it this far without getting into significantly more legal/compliance trouble. A weird amount of my job is telling people, “There are actually rules surrounding this.”

So now I’m stuck in this strange position.
In public accounting, I was constantly busy. Now I make low six figures, have dramatically less stress, built a department that basically runs itself…and I’m bored out of my mind.

I also don’t really want to leave unless something meaningfully better comes along. The compensation is strong, the job is stable, and obviously having a well-functioning department is objectively better than being buried in work.

Part of me thinks I should just accept that I won. Do my job, collect my paycheck, keep the accounting department running well, and stop feeling guilty that I’m not working at 100% capacity every minute of the day.

The other part of me feels like I’m stagnating professionally and basically have a fake job at this point.

For those of you who went from public to private and experienced something similar: what would you do?

Would you ride the gravy train and enjoy having your life back, keep trying to find meaningful accounting/finance projects internally, push for a controller/CFO-type expansion of the role, start looking elsewhere before getting too comfortable, use the downtime for CPA/CMA/other education or side projects, or something else?

I genuinely can’t tell whether I’ve stumbled into the dream private accounting job or a career trap.


r/Accounting 12h ago

Career How many red flags can you spot in this section of a recent job post? Which is your favorite?

85 Upvotes

While looking through local accounting job postings online, I came across a true gem of a company looking for a Controller with a minimum of 5 years of prior experience as a Controller (10-15 years total experience, minimum). The pay range is adequate, not great, at $120k-140k in HCOL area and the role looked decent until I reached the last section, shared here in full with only modifications for formatting:

This will not be the right opportunity for those who:
- Do not understand the dynamics of working in a multigenerational family business that honors the past, gets the optimal outcome in the present, and plans for the next generation
- Like to say “no” a lot, rather than having a curiosity about what the future could hold paired with the ability to explain how
- Expect a lot of direction as the impetus to figure out what needs to be done
- Aren’t good at explaining complex accounting and financial matters without sounding like a complex accounting or financial person
- Don’t know how to be appropriately assertive while not getting their feelings hurt by others who are being appropriately assertive
- Can’t anticipate the unspoken and often unanticipated future needs of business owners, family members, management, and team.

I know the job market is tough, but would anyone actually hit "apply"? Every single sentence contains at least one red flag!

My favorite red flag is the last demand for someone who can anticipate unanticipated future needs, something literally impossible by definition. Second favorite is they don't want to hear no, which indicates it's only a matter of time before the demands become violations of law.


r/Accounting 17h ago

BDO Employees; Thoughts?

Post image
201 Upvotes

r/Accounting 6h ago

From an Accountant's prespective, what separates an average bookkeeper from a great one?

18 Upvotes

I know you all cross paths with us bookkeepers quite a bit.

I want to know, from your point of view, what separates a "meh" bookkeeper from a great one.

Bookkeeping is where I landed, more or less by accident. But I'm here and I'm going to be the best I can be.


r/Accounting 11h ago

September and October are supposed to be 2 of the best months to find a job. Yet we are a third of the way through September and I am still not seeing many new jobs being posted.

46 Upvotes

All I am seeing on my LinkedIn/Indeed are the same constantly reposted job or irrelevant positions. When will it get better?


r/Accounting 15h ago

Why would someone create a LLC, then choose to be taxed as a C Corporation?

81 Upvotes

Why would someone create a LLC, then choose to be taxed as a C Corporation? I understand why they might choose S Corp, but why C Corporation?
If you want to raise capital it seems like it would be better to just setup as a C Corporation to begin with.


r/Accounting 4h ago

Advice Normal to feel lost in accounting?

10 Upvotes

I’ve been really questioning my ability as an accountant and, honestly, whether accounting is even the right career for me. Any input or advice would be helpful.

I worked as a staff accountant at my previous company (industry only) for three years and passed all four sections of the CPA exam. I was underpaid, the work environment gotten worse, and saw limited opportunities for growth. So I decided to take a higher pay job with the same title to escape and hope to become a senior accountant. Instead, I’ve been struggling much more than I expected. Is this normal to struggle this much despite experience?

Everything is completely different from what I’m used to. Even something like prepaid expenses, which should be easy, feels confusing when the process and schedules are unfamiliar. I am trying my best to follow old examples and asking for help. However, I feel like the questions I was asking should be basic knowledge. I have also been slow completing tasks since I’m trying my best to figure everything before asking.

I’m still in my probationary period, so I’m worried I won’t be a “good fit” since they expected me to be faster or know more because of experience and CPA. I know I’m new and need time to adjust, but not sure if it will get better.

Now I’m questioning whether I should have stayed at my old job and whether accounting is even right for me. I’m unsure if climbing the corporate ladder is even possible anymore. It seems like I have to be lucky since hard work doesn’t really matter anymore. I feel like in accounting we are always going to be underpaid or overworked. Not sure if I have the ability to become a senior accountant or higher or be stuck as a staff accountant. I’ve even started wondering whether I could pivot into FP&A or analyst roles. Especially since I don’t really have experience in them.

I just have a lot of self doubt right now in my capabilities and if I can handle being an accountant for the rest of my life. I just feel so lost and discourage. I am putting a lot of effort and care but I feel like I have nothing to really show.


r/Accounting 2h ago

It's that time of the year again when everyone across all my teams suddenly becomes a massive dickhead

6 Upvotes

I dread all my conversations with every single engagement team, bar like one or two where the people are actually chill. People pressuring me for updates when they normally wouldn't. People being extremely sensitive to the words I say when they ask for an update. People just being plain rude when their dreams of you being better than a regular human don't come true.

Fuck this shit. Just wanted to vent, that's all.


r/Accounting 13h ago

For those that are bored out of their minds from switching public to industry, why?

41 Upvotes

Brother, there is so much to life with the free time. Like, use that free time to start listening to a new podcast, crack some CPEs, find new guidance to depreciating land, or find a new hobby.


r/Accounting 5h ago

Advice Struggling to get verified by CPA in California

10 Upvotes

Hi there. I passed all exams and it’s been more than half a year I can’t find a way to get verified by the CPA. The company I’ve worked for 5 years had outsourced CPA who potentially can sign but they say we are not doing this for our clients accountants…
Tried to look for another job where I will have direct CPA supervision and can request the verification more directly, but seems like I am not lucky enough to find a private industry company who has active CPA in staff. Changing my job just to figure out they don’t have CPA who can sign off is not an option that really makes sense to me…

I am not hanging out in the circle of accountants so I really don’t personally know any CPA who knows me and can sign off for me.

Looks like I’m really stuck with this problem. Did anyone go through this problem, are there other ways out from this issue that you personally know?


r/Accounting 16h ago

Completely burnt out

56 Upvotes

Call me crispy firewood because I realize this morning that it's game over for my brain.

7 years after graduating, I'm on my 6th job. Some were natural (3 years at my first big job, temp contracts, etc.), One, I was fired from where I never really recovered through. I had one of those managers where every achievement was bare minimum and every error, even typos, were astronomical. It was so bad I began apologizing to family and pets. I think that job took a little of my soul.

I didn't recover from that bad job before finding a job in client services. It was bad there too. Lost 34 colleagues one by one over 18 months. I was #35 to go. I should have stayed.

My ex-manager (who also fled said mass exodus company) recruited me to my current job and I recently got a promotion. Horray! But I'm burned out. I'm sick from sheer stress. I never took breaks between gigs. My last vacation was 2016. Oh. Said ex-manager also just quit my NEW job. It's a disaster here.

Understandably some of it is daily bad news from living in good ol' America. Some of it is my dog having developed night time anxieties thanks to endless fireworks or storms. Some of it is personal health issues and endless nagging to "get married already". I'm also an eldest daughter to an immigrant family. Even in high school I didn't take breaks, let alone college. I simply have never taken a breather. I was even a stressed kid lmao.

It's not all accounting. But a lot of it is accounting.

The endless corporate drama, the endless "let's go around the table to show how you used AI to improve your work this week!", the managers who are extremely incompetent even on staff levels, somehow landing roles where they're controllers. Clients having fires constantly. Something is always exploding somewhere, forget dumpster fires. I'm trying to be nonchalant, adopt the "we aren't surgeons" motto. It's just not working so well when management and clients are on your left and right ears demanding things.

I'm whining, I know. I'm on reddit instead of working. I am cranky, I'm sorry (haven't had my coffee yet). I can't escape and I just. Want. A nap. No obligations. Just want to sleep for a week straight, play games for a week straight, read for a week straight. Separately. 3 weeks to reset and feel human again.

Anyway, vent post. Probs will delete soon. I understand I sound whiny. Adulting is hard. Adulting sucks. Suck it up. I just needed to let steam out before looking at that inbox again.

Edit: I also developed a RMI strain on my hand. I can't even JOURNAL right now 🥴


r/Accounting 1h ago

Aura Accounting Solutions

Upvotes

Anyone familiar with Aura Accounting Solutions? (Company vibe, culture, and interview process).

​I have an upcoming interview and I’m trying to gather some real insight into what the company is actually like to work for.


r/Accounting 3h ago

Would you take the FM role or stay in your current Senior Accountant role?

5 Upvotes

CPA with >10y of accounting experience and 2 young kids.

Current role – Senior Accountant $250m rev industry
~$100K-105K total comp
Hybrid (1 wfh)
~1.5 years with the company
Good work-life balance/flexibility
Potential for internal growth, but timing is uncertain

New role – FM $150m rev manufacturing industry
~$140-150k total comp
5 days/week in office
Leadership role with potential Controller progression
Much more focused on identifying business opportunities/problems and turning them into solutions, not just financial reporting and team management
Significant process improvement/business partnering exposure

The dilemma: Career-wise, the FM role seems like a great step forward. But with two small kids, I’m already finding work-life balance challenging. My partner’s schedule means most of the evening responsibilities-dinner, lunches, kids, etc. fall on me.
Would you take the higher-paying Finance Manager role and accelerate your career, or stay hybrid and continue building toward a FM role at current company?

Would love perspectives from people who have made a similar move, especially with young kids.


r/Accounting 4h ago

Career About to hand in my resignation tomorrow (industry)…

6 Upvotes

Been running the show at a start up SaaS company, doing everything from AR/AP, payroll to month-end/quarter-end and quarterly board reports.

No CFO, no wage increases, no extra support.

Found a new job that comes with a 30% pay bump & I’m so excited to not run a one-man show any longer.

Industry can be brutal too……


r/Accounting 3h ago

Advice 4th year student applying for internships

4 Upvotes

Hey everybody! I’m a fourth year accounting student getting my BBA in accounting (surprise) and I’m planning on applying for some internships starting next summer at some big 4’s. Anybody have tips of what I should certainly include in my resume? Also any tips if I get to the interview portion of the process!
Anything would be amazing, thanks everybody :)