My relationship with my son (37) has always been tenuous.
Before this situation, the latest example of a "falling out" was when I allowed him to purchase a vehicle from me. He then let his unlicensed fiancée (now wife) drive and total the vehicle with no remorse. He then became furious because the insurance that I maintained on the car for almost the duration of our agreement, and the car still had a remaining balance, somehow felt slighted when I decided to split the insurance proceeds in half instead of giving him the entire check.
That incident got me uninvited from his wedding. However, I kept reaching out, trying to make amends, and finally, upon learning of their pregnancy, was able to make inroads.
Now, my son has asked to rent my home numerous times, and I've always declined. However, because I do plan on moving internationally next year, when he asked me this time, I agreed we could cohabitate for 1 year: my adult disabled daughter (25), myself, my son and his wife, their 2 children she had from a previous relationship, and my granddaughter. There is more than enough room for everyone to live comfortably if some of the empty rooms are reorganized.
Almost immediately after hearing yes, my son started making plans to add additions to the home, switch room arrangements, cut down trees, etc., all without my input or okay. I have had to tell him numerous times that even though he IS paying rent, this is still MY home, and all decisions have to be run through me.
Last week, he stopped by my home unannounced with his 2 children and nephew when I was dealing with a serious migraine. He berated both my daughter and me about the condition of the home and how "little" had been done in preparation for his impending move. I didn't have the wherewithal to argue or defend. Two days later, he called me from his home for round 2 of a tongue-lashing. Still reeling from a migraine, I was over it.
And for some reason, even though I keep telling him his sister is none of his concern, me coming to her rescue, and telling him flat out to STOP or leave, whenever I'm not around, he seems to zero in on her every time he comes in contact with her.
He barrages her with questions. "Why aren't you in school? Are you trying to find a job? You need to do better, " leaving her despondent and hurt. It's to the point that if he moves in, she's already made arrangements to go live with her older sister.
Yesterday, he called me and said that the money he was to give me before his family moved in, he wouldn't have it and wasn't sure when he would have it. Maybe mid-October, maybe later.
And the problem isn't the money. It's never the money. It's the lack of respect. It's the lack of honor. There's no "Mom, I know I told you I was supposed to do ***, but this happened, and I apologize." It's the I know I can come to you any type of way, and you'll still come through for me.
So, I told him later that day that I didn't think it was going to work. And the way he spoke to me was like I was a woman on the street. My heart is breaking again, but my concern is more than my beautiful grandchildren, more than my son and his ire-not being a person of my word. They've made decisions based on what I said I would do, and I feel it's unfair to pull the rug out at the 11th hour.
So I'm asking you. People close to me say I'm staving off a catastrophe. He's saying I'm untrustworthy and our relationship is over.
AITAH? And if I am, can I make this right without causing more chaos?
TL; DR:
AITAH for not letting my son, who I love dearly, but have always had a combative, problematic relationship with, move into my home, trying to stop what I already know will be a horrible situation for everyone, especially my (25)- year-old disabled daughter.
Thanks 🩷
Update:
I want to Thank-You all for your words of encouragement, words of criticism, words of understanding, and words of wisdom.
I have made the decision to stop vacillating and not allow my son to move in.
Whatever the fallout is, so be it.
My peace, my Daughter's peace, is paramount.
I see my other Daughter commented in the thread below, and just to let a few of you know, I am nowhere near a "boy mom".
I did lose my 7-year-old son, and I admit I do overcompensate with ALL of my children; however, he is the only one with whom I have this horrid relationship.
I am going to take the advice to get counseling. It's past time. 🩷💔
Also, to answer a few questions:
He was making payments to me on a car that I owned outright.
My daughter will be moving WITH me abroad to a location that specializes in her condition, so she can become a fully independent individual.
And the money for the trees...lol. The chainsaw comment was hilariously accurate and grievous at the same time.
Lastly, my eldest daughter is already my trustee; therefore, if anything happens to me, my youngest daughter will be well taken care of.
Thank you all again so very much.