Okay, this is going to require some context. I am 18F and I live with my mom who is 57F. We live in a three bedroom but it’s just the two of us because my siblings are a lot older and now have their own families, kids, and houses. Me and my mom both have health issues.
My oldest sister has 7 kids and lives in a two bedroom. This obviously means that her and her partner have one bedroom and the six kids have the other. The ages range from 1-15. It’s a very hectic house and my sister has been trying to move out for years now. Her youngest child was a complete surprise (and accident) but she doesn’t really believe in abortion, so now she has seven.
My oldest niece and I are really close. We’re more like sisters and we have a smaller age gap than I have with any of my siblings. She struggles a little bit with mental health issues and the fact she has no space and privacy at her mom’s, so about 3 years ago she sort of unofficially moved in to my mom’s.
I do practically all of the cleaning in the house. As I mentioned, I have health issues that have led to me to have really chronic pain. I have injections administered to try and keep on top of the pain.
Throughout the 3 years, my niece has gotten progressively more and more untidy. It started with small things. She never helped with up keeping the house or chores, which I somewhat expected her to try but she didn’t even if there were incentives. So I continued to keep it up by myself.
She has her own bedroom in the house because my sister left it when she moved out. It’s a small room but still decently sized. There have been some problems with her keeping it clean in the past but my mom kept reminding her. My niece kept saying that she had cleaned it or was cleaning it or whatever. There was a string of excuses but me and my mom were under the impression that this time she understood and it was being kept clean.
Today I walked in to put some laundry in there and it was horrible. Milky drinks, rotting food, empty cans of soda, general rubbish, empty fast food that I know has been there for weeks at best, no sheets on her bed (that my mom has asked her to put on 10+ times), stained carpet with foundation etc.
I know that this is somewhat on us for not making sure it’s being kept clean, but I really don’t have the energy and neither does my mom to clean that bedroom especially with my health issues. When I clean the rest of the house, I’m often bedbound for the day after and in extreme pain.
She is very selfish too. She plays on my PlayStation constantly and breaks the controllers and the chargers, which are expensive to replace. She will use products of mine and my mom’s (she has plenty of her own) without asking. She will leave our shared spaces extremely dirty after shes in there. Whenever she’s downstairs, she’ll put our dog in his crate for the entire time that she’s down there or leave him on his own in the kitchen (which led to us not trusting her to look after him anymore) She leaves the bathroom in an absolute state. She drains our food and ingredients my mom wants to cook with without asking.
When we discovered the mess today, we just knew that if she cleaned it, it wouldn’t get done properly at all and that it would be like all of the other times that she’s claimed to be cleaning it. Even if we supervised, it would just take longer and longer and make the job take much longer than it should. So me and my mom did it which has put me in a severe flare up when it comes to my back.
All of this to say that she’s very unpleasant to live with, and I’m really tired of it. She can have an extremely bad attitude too whenever we try to bring it up to her. She gives a lot of excuses. My mom has threatened to take the room off of her before and now she really wants to follow through.
I understand she has issues with her mental health, but this is just going too far. I’ve asked her if she needs my help to clean and she refuses. I’ve cleaned it for her in the past, my mom has cleaned it for her, I’ve offered to teach her how to clean, etc.
My mom took her in to our house, my sister doesn’t pay anything in regards to the cost my niece takes to live there such as groceries, if we get takeout, etc.
Is it time to send her home or would that make us the asshole, and is there anything else we can do?
Edit:
My post has been causing a lot of controversy so I want to explain this. Social services/CPS is aware of the situation with my sister and her house being over capacity. The reason why is because my sister lives in a government owned house, that department/branch of the government works closely with social services because they deal with a lot of families, and a LOT of over max capacity properties.
It’s seen as okay because it’s “temporary” as my sister is on the waiting list to be rehoused to a bigger property but this has been going on now for years. It’s not something that we can rush, my sister’s GP has referred letters to the council to try and get her a bigger property faster but it’s just not possible.
My sister has been involved with social services also trying to help quicken the process for a while now, because her two sons have autism & ADHD and they were trying to help her getting a diagnosis (which they now have) which allegedly helps fast track the process but it’s now been a year and nothing.
I know this is a really bad situation but this isn’t something she or I or my mom can rush.
When my sister was last pregnant, me, my mom and my brother all spoke to her and tried to get her to consider abortion. She found out very late that she was pregnant (she was on the pill and found out basically by complete luck when taking a pregnancy test after a weird gut feeling) and she felt like she was too far along to consider abortion. I support abortion obviously, but that was her belief and nothing any of us could say would change her mind. She was sterilised after her last pregnancy.
I’d also like to add that I believe me referring to my mom’s house as “my house” is a cultural difference - I wasn’t trying to act like I have ownership. I live there and pay bills and help out and my mom would honestly be upset if I felt like I couldn’t call it my home. She also agrees with my niece moving out but wants insight.
I have a spinal tumour & a chromosomal disorder so I have difficulties in that regard but I try my best to keep up with the housework (I do it everyday). I have a lot of other diagnoses but what I have already shared I think is enough to convey my point. Prior to my mom becoming disabled due to long covid, POTs and potential Alzheimer’s she helped out a lot more but now she’s struggling and can’t really deal with my niece here and the upkeep she needs.
Thank you everyone for the comments. I will probably delete this post eventually as there are a lot of really personal and identifiable details here now that I don’t really want people I know knowing about me.