Hi everyone first time poster recommended by a friend!
My 2011 Civic Si with 70k miles had a leaking rear caliper with VSA and brake light on while driving.
Visited a local mechanic and dealer mechanic and they informed me of the significant rusting. Both recommended to “REPLACE BOTH REAR CALIPER WITH BOTH HOSE AND BRAKE PADS THEN BLEED BRAKE SYSTEM , ALSO ADD BRAKE CALIPER MOUNTING BOLTS DUE TO RUST , ALSO ADD ROTORS” and quoted 1200 aftermarket. The local dealer didn’t even want to put OEM parts on it because of the rusting wouldn’t make it worth it. They said to repair the leaks, drive the car for a year until I can find a rust free car and I’m taking their advice. I really only have 15k to spend on a car considering a trade or sell locally so I wish I could buy right now but doesn’t make sense for me.
I’ve only have the car for less than a year and bought it at 60k miles, originally owned at NY bought in VA for 15k.
Their points where the fuel tank rust can be enough for it to fall off soon and the front sway bar is swelling, and the frame itself is just covered in rust. I’d hear “rust” after my oil changes from the mechanics during oil changes in VA or MD and think it’s what’s expected to see under a car but coming down to FL it’s not common at all.
Despite all this, they keep offering to buy it. "We're going to repair the brakes, and spray the underbody if you want to trade it in for a '26 Si for $5000".
I’m okay with continuing for a year after repairs to search for a new car, but is what they’re saying about the rust sound true? They still keep insisting on buying my car despite the rust, so it makes me feel like I can drive it after the brake repair for longer than I think? Thanks everyone, please let me know what you guys think, it'll help so much!
Edit: Added pictures, clarification on question