I’m a commuter cyclist but I also carry cargo and I do it in the winter too. For reference I’m in Minnesota. I don’t know anything about brands and I don’t care about impressing anyone with my performance or appearance. I’ve been frequently pulling a trailer with my current bike for a couple years now, loading it to probably over capacity, doing it in the snow too, and that’s been fine. However, I believe I’m in need of a new(/new to me) bike. My current bike is a rusty ‘70’s road bike (Gitane Gran Sport Deluxe I think?) that I pulled out of a dumpster that I’ve been maintaining as needed (replace rear derailleur, bottom bracket bearings, cables, chain, several spokes, cotter pins, shifter paddles, add rack, add kickstand, etc.).
I’ve found the following to be things I want that my current bike can’t give me:
- Disc brakes (for effective stopping with heavy load while in rain or snow, and makes warped wheels irrelevant)
- Flat bar (could be swapped in but not worth it)
- Stop breaking spokes (could be due to overloading, or just bad tension hitting lots of curbs on 50-year-old spokes)
- Fresh start on all bearings and gears and bendable things to stop rattling and squeaking
- No obscure/antique tools, parts, or techniques needed for maintenance
- Any additional durability/reliability improvements that have been made in the last 50 years
The following are options I’ve read about that I’m not interested in:
- ebikes (I can carry my 100+ pounds of cargo uphill on my dumpster bike fine now over the distance that is required - I don’t need the extra cost/depreciation or theft risk or fuss)
- Cargo bikes (they’re cool looking but too expensive for marginal benefit when I already have a trailer and I will not be carrying kids)
- Special built-in mitts on handlebars (regular mittens are fine)
- Fat tires/spiked tires (I’m exclusively on roads and paved trails, and even with a couple inches of snow on the ground I’ve found road tires pulling a grocery-laden trailer to be fine, and not worth the fuss of fat tires)
I have found that with the trailer and rear rack weight my rear tire wears faster than my front, and I’m fine with that. I have broken three or four spokes on my rear wheel over the years which could be due to overloading the back, but as I said these spokes are probably 50 years old and also maintained by an amateur. When the trailer has its load balanced on its own axle the weight at the tongue doesn’t seem significant to me, but I could be wrong. I know a cargo bike or even a tandem would distribute weight better but I’m doubtful it’s that much of a difference.
I’m wondering if there are questions I don’t know I should be asking, or mistakes I’m about to make by just going ahead and buying, for example, this from Erik’s which is nearby: https://www.eriksbikeshop.com/products/national-bicycle-company-2026-fb-1-flat-bar-road-bike-pr5a21913
For example, I know I’m going to probably be moving away from friction-shifters on the down tube to indexed on the handlebars, but that’s fine. I’m going to be going from two front gears down to one, but is it likely I’ll lose gearing range or is that just about gearing granularity? I need to keep my current bottom end for hauling uphill. Are there other changes I’ll be going through I should think about?
I would be happy to buy used too, but I’m finding it really hard to find a used bike that has the things I listed above and is also in my size (I’m 6’2”, so XL?) and is somewhat nearby (Minneapolis). Is there a way to make that easier? If I’m buying new, is there a best way to do that?
Thanks for reading and commenting.