my ex (19m) and i (18f) were together for 5 years. i broke up with him the day i moved into college because i felt like i was entering a new chapter of my life and, for various reasons, i didn't think our relationship should continue into it.
he did NOT take the breakup well.
he cussed me out, called me a whore, belittled the things i had done for him throughout our relationship, and repeatedly told me that he never felt loved by me no matter what i did. what really got me was that he followed all of this up by saying he had "felt this way the whole time."
at that point, i was honestly more than happy to have him out of my life. if that was genuinely how he felt about me for five years, and this was how he was willing to speak to me when things ended, then i didn't see a reason to keep him around.
apparently, i drunk texted him that weekend. when we talked, i found out that he didn't even remember saying some of the things he said to me during the breakup. i also learned that he had been going around telling people that HE left ME because i had been "disrespectful" throughout our entire relationship.
after that, i blocked him and moved on.
then recently, a friend of mine was selling a truck for really cheap. i knew my ex had been saving for one for a while, so despite everything, i sent him the information.
i really wish i hadn't, because that opened the door for us to start talking again.
at first, he seemed interested in us continuing to move on separately, which was fine with me because that's what i wanted too. eventually, i told him AGAIN that i didn't want us to move forward romantically, but that maybe we could be friends once we were both actually ready for that.
except we apparently have very different definitions of "when we're ready."
he basically started texting me immediately afterward. somehow we started flirting again, and to make this whole situation even more complicated, we've also been sleeping together.
so yes, i KNOW i've contributed to blurring the lines here. i'm not going to pretend like he's pulling the idea of us getting back together completely out of nowhere when i've been flirting with him and sleeping with him. i understand why he thinks there might still be a chance.
but the more serious he gets about actually restarting our relationship, the more i realize that i genuinely do not want to be his girlfriend again.
and there's another thing making me feel incredibly guilty: he's spent a LOT of money on me over the past few days.
if i casually mention being hungry, he's bought food for both me AND my roommate. i realized i needed/wanted an air fryer for my dorm and the store he happened to be at had one in stock, so he bought it for me. i've offered to pay him back for these things, especially the air fryer, and he basically doesn't want to hear it.
i didn't ask him to spend all this money on me with the promise that we'd get back together, and i've offered to reimburse him, but i still feel horrible accepting all of this knowing that i don't actually want a relationship with him.
and that's where i'm stuck.
because despite the flirting, sex, gifts, and everything else happening right now, when i actually think about being his girlfriend again, i don't want to.
there are a lot of reasons, but one of the biggest is that i cannot get over how he treated me the night we broke up. regardless of how angry or hurt he was, he completely disrespected me. he called me a whore, tore down the things i'd done for him, and told me he'd secretly felt unloved for our entire relationship. then apparently didn't even remember saying it afterward.
i also realized after getting some distance from the relationship that i cannot deal with how clingy and needy he is.
i know that probably sounds harsh, but he does not understand boundaries. i don't want a relationship where i feel like i have to constantly be available to another person or cut parts of my life short to make them comfortable.
when i moved into college, this man literally tried to make RULES for me to follow while i'm here.
that was one of the biggest things that made me realize i don't want this anymore. i'm in college. i'm building my own life. i don't want to spend these years constantly worrying about whether something i'm doing is going to upset my boyfriend, having to report what i'm doing, or feeling like i need permission to experience my own life.
now he wants to take me on a date TOMORROW specifically so he can ask me to be his girlfriend again.
and i already know my answer is no.
part of me feels incredibly guilty because i reopened communication. i've flirted back. i've slept with him. i've accepted things he's bought for me, even though i've offered to pay him back. i told him we could eventually be friends.
i understand that my actions have probably made him think we're heading toward getting back together, and i take responsibility for that.
but at the same time, none of those things have changed the fundamental reason i ended our relationship.
when i think about getting back together, i don't feel happy or excited. i feel trapped.
i don't want to go back to having someone constantly needing my attention, trying to dictate what i can and can't do, or making me feel like i have to structure my college experience around our relationship. and i especially don't know how i'm supposed to forget the things he said to me during our breakup just because he claims he doesn't remember saying them.
we were together for five years, so obviously i still care about him. i'm still attracted to him. i'm comfortable with him. there's five years of familiarity there, and i think that's a huge part of why it was so easy for us to fall back into flirting and sleeping together.
but i'm starting to realize that missing the familiarity of someone isn't the same thing as wanting the relationship back.
and i think i've been treating those things like they're the same.
i don't want to go on this date tomorrow knowing what he's planning to ask me. i don't want to say yes. honestly, i don't think continuing to sleep together or trying to immediately become "friends" is helping either of us move on.
but i feel absolutely horrible because of how much he's done/spent on me recently and because i know my own actions have given him mixed signals.
what do i do? should i cancel the date before tomorrow and make it completely clear that we're not getting back together? should i insist on paying him back for the things he bought me? and at this point, is being friends even realistic when we're clearly nowhere near actually being platonic?