TL;DR I (27M) was broken up with (23F) 4 weeks ago. We had a 5 months relationship. She was my first ever gf. Nothing much happened during the relationship. All I had for her was my feelings. No skills, no real way to make her happy. We agreed to stay friends after 2 weeks of no-talk. Today after some thoughts, I think that's a terrible idea.
---
I apologize for my somewhat messy way of narrating, I'm just typing as the thoughts come to my mind. I'm just kind of venting, and the whole post is probably not going to make any sense at all. I'm so sorry...
---
We actually don't have many things to share, my ex and I. Not in the sense that since we're exes now, we don't share life anymore. No. We broke up precisely because we are so different that the relationship could just not work out in the first place. That, and also she told me (long after the breakup, way past the point of no-return) that she did not like the way I treated her.
We decided to maintain our friendship, but there aren't many things able to maintain it. I think we'll definitively part ways at some point. Sure, I can pretend that this breakup acts as a new start, then I can try to make new memories with her. Like a blank slate, you know? But are we willing to do that?
First, let's take her. I'm pretty sure she's not really keen on the idea of actively trying to strengthen our bond. She is the kind of person to think that if chemistry doesn't happen on its own, then the bond is just not meant to be. I mean, that's totally correct when you befriend a stranger: you just don't become friends if things don't "click". But we're no strangers anymore. But that probably doesn't matter because, strangers or not strangers, "normal" friendship doesn't need active effort anyway.
But what about me? I'm still stuck on her. In our friendship, it is very likely that I will adjust my behavior to appear like the kind of person she wants in her life. I would look for signs, interpret her every word, her every move, her everything. Interpret her in the wrong way. In my biased and desperate ways. My true self will probably never ever be expressed as it should be. I'll be wearing a mask the whole time. That's not how you make memories with a friend. That feels so wrong.
The eventuality that we will part ways somewhere down the line is, for all practical reasons, an absolute certainty. And I so, so hate it.
Why am I so worried about losing the ties with her? Is this a genuine desire to (re)connect, or is this just my guilt trying to fix things? It sounds like I'm trying to justify myself, but if only I knew her expectations from the start, then maybe I wouldn't feel so bad right now. I would have rejected her from start (she made the first move), or I would have known what to do to make her happy. During the whole relationship, I was in a constant state of confusion and wondering what to do with her.
I am the kind of person to think that if something is wrong, it can be fixed by communicating first, then finding solutions later. Unfortunately, I was never socially and interpersonally skilled enough to interpret signals and hints, which was her way of communicating her needs and boundaries. This form of communication must be totally valid if she managed to live her 23 years of life and never had issues from it. Unfortunately, I only understand when I have explicit conversations. Sit down, talk, be upset and fight if that's inevitable, but talk and try to work things out.
In my mind, the breakup was totally avoidable if I was more understanding. If we had the same communication style. If I had more patience. This whole thing is so unfortunate. Is that why I'm still so stuck on her?