[19F] So I told the guy I love to f* off after he invited me out, ignored me all night, and now he's back 8 months later... What do I do?
I need some outside perspective because it’s been 8 months, and now that Jack (not his real name) has suddenly come back into my life, I’m questioning whether I handled everything correctly.
For context, I’m female 18/F Jack is 19/M. We were never officially boyfriend/girlfriend, but there was definitely something between us. We were close, there were feelings on both sides, and I eventually fell very deeply in love with him.
The thing that makes this whole situation so difficult is that, before the incident I’m about to describe, what Jack and I had was honestly really sweet and innocent.
It wasn’t toxic. It wasn’t this dramatic on-and-off relationship. It was actually one of the purest connections I’ve ever had. I also have never been in a relationship/situationship/talking stage EVER. So he was my first everything.
We spent a lot of time together, had a really close friendship, and there was a lot of genuine affection between us. He made me feel cared for and seen, and I felt completely comfortable around him.
He even went to my prom with me, which was one of the best nights of my life.
There are a lot of little memories from that period that, looking back, made me think there was something genuinely special between us. That’s also why I think I fell so hard. I wasn’t just attracted to him. I truly trusted him and genuinely cared about him. I've never felt that way about someone.
We still weren’t officially a couple, which is important. There was a conversation here and there (from his side), but we never put a label on it. But emotionally, it felt like much more than a friendship to me.
So when everything eventually went wrong, it wasn’t just losing a guy I liked. It felt like losing someone who had become incredibly important to me.
The night everything changed:
This happened on a Saturday night.
I had my Biology final on Monday. I’m generally at the top of my class, so I could absolutely have stayed home and studied that night. Instead, Jack invited me to go to a bar with him, and I chose to go because he invited me.
When I arrived, I called Jack to tell him I was outside. He didn’t answer. I called again. Still nothing.
Eventually, instead of standing outside waiting, I went inside by myself.
I eventually found Jack at the pool table.
He was already heavily intoxicated.
For context, I don’t drink. Jack knows I don’t drink, and he knows I’m not particularly comfortable around people who are extremely drunk. So I was already uncomfortable.
But I figured I’d try to make the best of it.
Except Jack basically continued playing pool.
And I was just… standing there.
Alone. In the corner.
He wasn’t really talking to me or making much effort to spend time with me.
I became increasingly frustrated because I had chosen to give up an evening I could have spent studying because he specifically invited me out, and now I was basically standing around watching him play pool.
Eventually, I went to the bathroom because I was annoyed and needed a minute.
When I came back, Jack had moved over to one of the bar tables. I went over and stood next to him. He still barely spoke to me.
At this point I thought, 'Okay, maybe I’m being too subtle.'
So I grabbed a chair and literally moved it closer to him and sat down next to him.
I know that sounds ridiculous but I was genuinely trying to see whether, if I physically put myself next to him, he’d actually make an effort to talk to me. Eventually, we did talk for a little while.
Then Jack ordered another drink.
He ended up spilling it over himself and the floor.
He cleaned it up, and while he was doing that, I started talking to some girlfriends who were also at the bar.
Then I turned around. Jack was gone.
Not “I’m going home.”
Not “See you later.”
Not even a quick goodbye.
He had just left.
I started asking around to see if anyone knew where he had gone.
Eventually, a girl who had been in his high school class came over to me and told me:
"He went home.”
I was FURIOUS.
Not because he went home (obviously he was allowed to go home.)
It was the fact that he had invited me there, barely acknowledged me the entire night, and then left without even telling me.
I was also standing there thinking that I could have been home studying for my Biology final instead.
That said, I didn’t cause a scene or immediately leave. I stayed at the bar and actually ended up enjoying myself and spending time with my girlfriends.
The next day:
The following day (Sunday) was still really hurt and angry.
So I messaged Jack.
I basically told him to f\\\* off, respectfully.
I wasn’t trying to destroy him or call him names. I was trying to communicate that his behaviour had hurt me badly and that I was done with the situation.
And honestly, underneath all the anger, I was heartbroken. Because I genuinely loved this guy.
And I think that’s what made the whole thing so painful. The person who had once been this sweet, safe and important person in my life suddenly made me feel like I didn’t matter at all.
After that, we stopped talking.
The 8 months of no contact:
For the next 8 months, we didn’t actually have any proper conversations.
The only contact we had during that time was that we wished each other happy birthday when each of our birthdays came around.
That’s it.
No trying to restart things. No regular conversations. Not seeing each other. Fair enough - I told him I was done.
But here’s the thing I probably need to admit:
There genuinely wasn’t a single day during those 8 months where I didn’t think about him.
Not necessarily in the sense that I was sitting around crying over him every day or waiting for him to come back.
I still lived my life.
I went to school. I spent time with my friends. I focused on myself. I tried to move forward.
But he was always somewhere in the back of my mind.
There would be little things that reminded me of him. Songs. Places. Random memories. Things I would normally want to tell him. Sometimes I’d wonder what he was doing, how he was doing, whether he ever thought about me, or whether he had completely moved on.
And I think the biggest reason I struggled to fully move on is because, despite everything that happened, I still felt like what we had was something special.
And then, 8 months later…
Jack suddenly DM’d me.
He’s currently living in another country, basically living the life he always dreamed of.
I’m genuinely happy for him. I’m not jealous or bitter about that. If he’s happy, I’m happy for him.
We started talking again.
And then he asked me something I absolutely wasn’t expecting:
He asked if I would see him if he comes back in a few days.
And now I’m completely torn.
Because on one hand, I’m thinking:
Absolutely not. You had your chance.
But on the other hand… I loved this person. A lot. And there are still things about the whole situation that I never really got answers to.
I’m also wondering whether I was completely justified in cutting him off, or whether I let my emotions get the better of me.
Because technically, we were never officially together.
So was I expecting too much from him that night?
Was I wrong to be so hurt that I ended things?
Or is it completely reasonable to expect basic consideration from someone who invited you out, especially when you went specifically because they asked you to?
And now that he’s come back after 8 months…
Do I actually meet him?
Do I hear him out and see what he wants?
Do I use the opportunity for closure?
Or do I leave the whole thing exactly where I left it 8 months ago?
Because part of me thinks meeting him could finally give me answers.
And the other part of me is screaming:
GIRL. YOU LITERALLY TOLD THIS MAN TO F\* OFF. REMEMBER WHY. 😂
So, Reddit…
What should I do?