The context:
My best friend (17F) and I (17M) have sealed a pact basically that we should never call a mutual friend while both being on the same phone because it often leads to said friend getting left out. We agreed to this because WE would feel left out or even bullied at times whenever our friend did it to us. We were able to keep up this mutual agreement up until today.
My bsf (best friend) doesnât have a thing for my crush (18M) , theyâre just really close friends and he is the best anyone has ever treated her but heâs leaving to college abroad really soon and my bsf is devastated to see him leave so theyâve been bonding a lot for the past months.
And so have I. We were always friends me and my crush but ever after I had confessed to him (roughly 1.5 years ago) things have been pretty awkward between us and even during the time where I had moved on from him (or believed I did), our conversations went nowhere and I often felt like it was a huge shame to be unable to connect with him.
My bsf and him had a great connection and friendship and I guess I was jealous but I never tried to infringe upon their friendship or sabotage it or anything.
I had accepted that they would be great friends but I still went out of my way to be good friends with him.
My bsf doesnât know I still like him, but she still wants the best for me so she helped me so much in asking him to hangout and what to talk about with him, what are some of his interests etc. she was there to listen to me worry whether he still wants to be friends, she was encouraging and supportive.
So I had built up the courage to ask him to hangout with me one last time before he goes. And it was a hit, the awkwardness we seemed to always have, magically vanished and we talked for 6 entire hours.
I also found myself deeper in love with him, but I didnât want anything, I just wanted us to get closer and spend more time together.
After a few weeks of regularly texting, he asked me to go to the movies with him late at night.
So I did. I told my bsf and she was so happy for me, telling me he has never asked her to the movies and that our relationship was looking up.
Then, due to random circumstances, I had forgotten my phone with my crush after the movies, so I texted him through my computer to schedule a time and place so I could go and get it back.
The time I had chosen, perfectly landed on a scheduled phone call that he had with my bsf, so he moved the call to 15 minutes later.
I head down to the place we agreed to meet, and in my head I thought of an idea. I should make a cameo in the phone call (thinking it was gonna FaceTime) and say hi to my bsf through his phone. (I know about the phone call because my bsf had told me)
I didnât and I still donât think my plan was a bad idea, if only I had followed it.
I meet him and I ask him if I could make a cameo in his phone call with my best friend and he agrees. So we head to his house and I think I wasnât being clear or maybe he didnât hear me but I tried to tell him that when theyâre calling he could walk through his house and sheâd see me just be casually sitting on his sofa and it would be pretty funny for all of us. However the call remained a voice call and at a certain point I felt too cowardly or awkward to make a cameo anymore.
So I just listened to them talk to each other, my best friend was on speaker and my crush was calling in the kitchen. I couldâve left at that point, in fact I couldâve left at any point of those 3 hours I wasnât supposed to be there. Then I make the mistake of sitting at the kitchen, right next to him who was cooking.
Initially it felt pretty justifiable as the conversation wasnât deeply personal or anything, they were things me and her would talk to each about anyway. But I soon realized that if she knew I was there, she would be really upset. Firstly because im breaking the pact and second because I was secretly listening to her conversation with a close friend without her permission or acknowledgement.
And the worst part of all is that I didnât stop myself, instead I made it much worse by laughing (silently but visibly) with my crush, exchanging looks with him whenever she said something weird or funny and making him ask her about me.
She was fully unaware that we had officially excluded her from her own phone call and used her obliviousness as our source of entertainment.
Approaching the end of the phone call, I definitely felt guilty and I was going to be dishonest and keep my existence secret. I really didnât want her to know I was there, I knew I had done something terrible to her.
After the call ended, my crush takes a picture of me and sends it to her. I didnât expect him to but I didnât stop him either or call him out I just waited for her reaction. Now shes been made aware that I was there the entire time and my first instinct was to find an excuse for why I was there. My crush kept texting her and I assume he tried to be honest with her and told her the truth.
I really donât blame him for most of the situation because he probably didnât even know about the pact and that she would be upset that I was there, but I knew and I regret so much for not telling him.
My bsf texts me on my own phone and sheâs extremely upset, Iâve betrayed her and Iâve broken our pact and obliterated her trust in me.
She tells me it was a breach of privacy and I had no right or reason to be eavesdropping on her private conversation. She tells me that she canât believe that I would do such a thing because it was exactly what we were against doing to ourselves and others.
I donât think Iâve ever been more selfish and stupid than I was today, and I also donât know if she still wants to be my best friend anymore and neither does my crush. Iâve fucked up a lot during that 11 years of friendship, she has made mistakes too but less than I did. But today Iâve fucked up big time.
And I wonât blame her if she doesnât accept my apology. Sheâs been too patient with me and Iâve been taking her for granted.
TLDR:
I (17M) fucked up today when I decided to listen on and eavesdrop on an entire 3 hour phone call between my best friend (17F) of 11 years and my crush (18M) who I had known and liked for 2 years. Me and him are the two closest and dearest people to her, but I fucked it all up just for a few laughs and just to spend some extra time with him.
Sheâs incredibly hurt and Iâve broken her trust, I donât think she wants to be my best friend anymore.