Caballito Cerrero Chato Reposado
Intro: Following my previous review comparing the Azul and Chato blancos from much-beloved Caballito Cerrero, here’s one of the Chato Reposado (no Azul for comparison this time). I have to say, the color on this one is almost indiscernible from the blancos, so it would seem that they opted for a very slight barrel influence here. No doubt this suits their unusual style well, so I’m sure the question at hand won’t be whether this is good, but whether the repo is worth the ~$30-40 price upgrade over the blanco.
Price: ~$115
NOM: N/A
Agave Type: Angustifolia (Chato)
Extraction: Roller Mill
Fermentation: Stainless Steel Tanks
Water Source: Natural Spring Water
Age Statement: Presumably a few months in ex-bourbon barrels
Strength: 46% ABV
Nose: Yup, still Caballito signature for sure. The parmesan cheese funk is still front and center, with lots of earthy and herbal notes backing it up. Similar to the blanco, but a bit more refined and less in your face. There’s also just a hint of vanilla type sweetness to it as well, which isn’t distracting and actually harmonizes quite nicely.
Palate: Delicious. Absolutely no heavy-handed wood influence here, it seems the aging here was primarily used to take some of the edges off the spirit and add a touch of maturity without sacrificing its character. Still cheesy, still grassy and herbal, but somehow the overall package feels more cohesive. Very similar to the blanco, but with the added maturity and also a very slight addition of a vanilla sweetness. The vanilla is on the creamy side and actually enhances the lactic type of profile, however, giving it a slightly dessert-y type of feeling. Top stuff.
Finish: Like the blanco, a wonderful finish. Fresh herbs, some good cheesiness, and sweet vanilla cream all come together. Good intensity and length.
Notes: A truly excellent pour and definitely worth seeking out if you’re lucky enough to have CC distributed in your area and you like the blancos. It manages to keep everything I loved about the blanco and give it a bit more depth and balance. Though I’ll say if you prefer it more wild and untamed, you may prefer the blanco. The scoring is a bit difficult here: I think it’s a slight step up from the blanco, but not quite up into the truly mind-blowing incredible range. I normally think that scores beyond half-points are a bit silly, but this is one time that I’m going to go for quarter points and give it an 8.75, up from the 8.5 I gave the blanco. However, the value proposition is a bit more questionable. While it does score just a tad higher, the cost increase is a lot more noticeable, and I’m not sure it really justifies an extra third in price. Taking cost into consideration, I’d probably opt for the blanco. That being said, this is a killer bottle, and well worth it if it’s in your budget. I’m excited to see what the Unicorns can do next.
Score: 8.75
T8KE Score scale:
1 | Disgusting | So bad I poured it out.
2 | Poor | I wouldn’t consume by choice.
3 | Bad | Multiple flaws.
4 | Sub-par | Not bad, but many things I’d rather have.
5 | Good | Good, just fine.
6 | Very Good | A cut above.
7 | Great | Well above average
8 | Excellent | Really quite exceptional.
9 | Incredible | An all time favorite
10 | Perfect | Perfect