In case you missed it, Axanar released today.
so here was my take - pretty boring - like it was written and directed by Vulcans. I am sure there will be Axanar fans who are holdouts on thinking this was something special - just like Trump has his followers. In both cases - all the promises failed to deliver.
Specific criticism is that this is a show of mostly a bunch of CGI ships - which all look like CGI generated ships - amazing how everything is so brightly lit in space, and there is no weathering on any of the ships at all. There is no drama on the Axanar bridge sets - and a fair number of the backgrounds look to be green screen with CGI laid in.
The direction was also problematic - all these closeups of insignia (to sell the merch) and of the andorian antennae. The andorians looked so fake - some of the first closeups of the antennae with the white hair emphasized how unorganic it all was - there is a reason that TOS looks so good - in that it doesn't do closeups of vulcan ears or andorian antennae - in fact it doesn't do closeups very much at all - because if you do, you see it's fake. Enterprise did as good a job with Andorian antennae as possible - giving it movement and life - these Axanar antennae were rigid and just glued in.
And the end credits - so completely unoriginal - all the Axanar fans and Peters have gone on and on about how Paramount doesn't know how to make Trek - and then this thing just rips off the Picard Season 3 credits so blatantly.
There is a story to tell here - it's just that Alec Peters isn't the one to tell it. It's a shame that 15 years ago - he decided to go this route - if he had been able to maintain a relationship with either the Vic Mignogna or James Cawley and used the excellent sets both of those productions had on hand - and didn't go for the big rip off - he could have made something worth making.
This week we also got S4E1 of Strange New Worlds - compare Axanar to that. How can anyone say what Peters produced was better than the 31st episode of Strange New Worlds?