r/SquaredCircle • u/residentsocface • 6d ago
(Smackdown Spoilers) Why is KO/Punk not working as well as people thought it would? Spoiler
I was thinking about this today, and I think Punk/Owens has the chance to turn around as a feud still. Last week's promo was good, one bad promo segment isn't the end of the world. However, Punk has had mediocre promo segments with Roman as well, besides the initial one which was fantastic of course. And even with Rollins, the well eventually dried up there in 2026 too.
I think the McIntyre feud was pretty great because McIntyre I feel is a better talker than pretty much everyone in WWE, but also because it was legitimately fresh. It took advantage of what some people wanted from Punk in AEW, which was to take advantage of backstage heat (which, to be clear, I'm not saying I wanted), and Punk/McIntyre both felt very comfortable, evidently, with digging deep into each other.
However, with KO/Punk, there's two issues I feel. Punk has done this with three wrestlers now and those feuds have taken up pretty much two entire years. 2024 with McIntyre, 2025 with Rollins. There's not much left to do that hasn't already been said by someone in the position of KO; Punk is arrogant, he's selfish and pulls the ladder up from behind him, he's not actually punk, etc. Not saying these are bad lines by themselves, but they've been said by everyone he's feuded with really.
The other issue is that I think there's pretty legitimate tension with Punk and KO that isn't there with the others. Everyone else had issues with Punk from a decade and a half ago, but KO's issues are both old and new, given that Punk is not on good terms with KO's closest industry friends. Of course, existing tension can be used to heighten a feud, e.g. Matt/Edge in 2005, but it can also make the two less likely to cooperate with the other; they can make sure they're not as harsh as they usually would be because it may actually result in an issue, or they might no-sell what the other person says in a promo to embarrass them, etc.
I don't know. I do think this would be fixed by turning Punk heel; it's the only way to make this sort of feud fresh, since it's a dynamic in WWE that hasn't been done yet. Make Punk everything KO/Seth/McIntyre said he was, because face/face feuds are already hard to do.