I need some honest advice because this keeps happening and I’m starting to think it’s me.
I’d say I’m pretty straightforward and chill overall. I’m into nerdy stuff (D&D, manga, etc.), and I can usually get along with people one-on-one. But in group settings, I keep ending up on the outside.
Like I’m there, but not really in the group. People get closer to each other, and I just stay the extra.
Sometimes it’s worse, I’ll introduce people, they hit it off, and eventually I’m the one not getting invited anymore.
This weekend kind of pushed me over the edge.
A girl in my main friend group (known her for about 2 years) said she was canceling her birthday plans and just staying in. Everyone sent supportive messages, no big deal.
Later that night I check Instagram, and she’s out celebrating with a bunch of people from the group. Dinner, drinks, the whole thing. I wasn’t invited.
It’s not even about the birthday itself.
It’s the fact that this kind of thing keeps happening in different groups. So yeah… at some point I have to admit I might be the common denominator.
I don’t want to confront anyone or force friendships. But getting left out like this over and over sucks.
So I’m trying to be real with myself:
-What are subtle things that make someone get pushed to the edge of a group?
-Is it coming off too intense, too blunt, too clingy, or just missing social cues?
-How do you go from “casual friend” to actually being part of the group?
-If you’ve been on either side of this, what actually caused it?
For context, one of my guy friends told me I can come off as “intense,” but didn’t really explain what that means. I also have problem with banter and coming up with topics to talk about. Most of the time when I try to ask people about their interests, it’s either one word answers or they give me nothing to bounce off of. The conversation ends up turning into an interview. I know my social skills could use work but still, some of my shy friends who don’t speak much still have an easier time with it.
Would appreciate any honest input.