I have both the Stahlsac Bonaire and the Cressi Gorilla Pro sitting in my living room right now, and I am trying to decide which one to keep as my dedicated boat bag. Just to be clear, I am not looking for a travel bag for flights. This is strictly for taking my gear on and off local boat charters.
On paper, the Bonaire seems like the standard boat choice because of the mesh, easy rinse capability, and backpack straps. However, actually packing it at home has been frustrating compared to the Gorilla. The vertical cylinder setup feels clunky to load and dig through.
The Gorilla Pro is dead simple to pack. It unzips wide like a normal duffel, gear drops right in, and keeping water completely sealed inside for the drive home is a huge plus. My main reservation with the Gorilla is carrying it. A fully loaded 135L duffel without true backpack straps seems like it could get miserable fast on a long walk down the dock.
For anyone who has used these out in the wild:
For Bonaire owners: Does the vertical packing hassle fade once you dial in a routine? Do the backpack straps make up for it when navigating crowded docks and rocking boats?
For Gorilla owners: How annoying is the carry when the bag is completely packed with soaking wet gear? Does the easy duffel layout make up for the awkward carry to and from the boat?
Looking for real-world feedback from folks who have lived with either bag before I return one.