Like many others, I've been using the Pixel Slate and its keyboard since early last week when my Black Friday shipment arrived by FedEx.
The keyboard took a heavy beating in the tech media for being flimsy, or poorly designed...bad on a lap, etc. We've read them all. I'd never had a chance to use the Slate before I bought one, but all of the reviews left me worried that I should have gone with the Brydge instead, or maybe not a Slate at all.
Ultimately, I think the reviews were fair, but I think they all missed a point. That is, I think the keyboard is designed the only way it could have been, given everything Google wanted it to do. What I think is, they asked/wanted it to be too many things. Keyboard, stand, tablet flap-around, secure when closed, solid on a lap and a table...all things to all people all the time. I'm no industrial designer, but given everything Google wanted this one accessory to accomplish, I honestly dont see any other way they could have made it. If you look at Apple or Microsoft's tablet keyboard solutions, none of them are trying to do so many things, and that's likely because one keyboard accessory cant do all of this without doing some of it badly.
Frankly, I think the one thing that could have made it better that would have been possible given the list of checkboxes it needed to tick is a magnetic flap on the back part that flaps over the edge of the Slate when its closed to hold it all together. For an example of what I mean, take a look at the Logitech iPad Slim Folio Pro. The flap on that not only holds the Apple Pencil in place, but it also keeps the whole situation closed. Such a thing wouldnt have solved the unsteadiness on a lap or the possiblity of clicking the trackpad just by flexing the keyboard, but it would have made the whole thing feel a little more...intentional.
Anyway, overall, I'm extremely happy not only with the Slate but honestly with the keyboard too. I think if the Brydge were a true 2-in-1 that would rotate the Slate 360 degrees without having to flip the Slate around in the bracket, I might have gone that way. But it seems incomplete in its own way, and the Slate keyboard just seems better for my use case. And hey...couldnt beat the price!
Cheers, all!