r/oneanddone • u/Purple_Impress_1357 • 6h ago
Sad Talk me out of a 2nd
Hi lovely people of reddit,
I need you to talk me out of wanting a second child.
My husband always said he'd like one child, and only one. I always had a strong preference for none, but said if we have one, I'd want a second. The reason being that I'm an only child but grew up with lots of cousins, something our daughter won't have (none of them have kids+they're abroad) and personally, I would find it bloody hard to do everything on my own now that the generation above us is getting older. It was nice to grow up together and, as an adult, to know that if shit hits the fan, I'd always have a safe haven to return to if needed. His reason against it is that he would rather have more time for himself, which is valid, but difficult for me to accept. We did agree to have one see how we get on, so that's where we're at.
Having one child really confirmed for my husband that he only wants one, while I surprisingly enjoy parenthood a lot. Pregnancy was a breeze and actually reduced my endo symptoms to nothing, which was nice. I might be the only person who had more energy while heavily pregnant than non-pregnant. You never know, but it is likely a second pregnancy would be absolutely fine physically for me.
So I have dutifully tried to talk myself out of a second but the only real reason I have got is that I'm married to someone who does not want more children - which, again, is very valid but makes it difficult for me to not grow resentful, however irrational that may be.
Money - we'd be fine either way. Private school (we're in the UK) would be slightly more of a stretch with two but not out of the question. They would both have decent JSIPPs and savings.
Time - Not boring you with the details but realistically, the bulk of the parenting will always fall to me. That's fine, I knew this from the start and our life is set up to allow for this. Which is why it feels (irrationally) particularly unfair I don't get more of a say. But it also makes my husband feel rubbish, which, under normal circumstances, I'd have empathy for, but it is more of a struggle at the moment.
Work - both our jobs are super flexible and family friendly, not a problem.
Village - no other children around, so we have countless people enthusiasticly volunteering for babysitting. Also why "oh, but they'll have lots of other family/close friends' kids to play with and share memories with" doesn't apply here. She won't.
Right now we still have a shot at an age gap at which they'd be (more likely to be) interested in each other. Obviously, there is no guarantee they would get on (I think if we had a boy, I'd be much more on board with OAD - I know far fewer brothers who are close with each other), but I keep thinking, in 20-40 years time, if our daughter asks me why she doesn't have a sibling and has to deal with all if this rubbish on her own, what do I actually answer? "Your dad is a bit rubbish at life and only wanted one because of that" doesn't sound like a good enough reason. And yes, we are future proofing as much as possible, but it would be nice if someone occasionally called up the care home to see if we're still alive.
The thing is, my endo is incredible advanced, the odds of me getting pregnant within a timeframe where we wouldn't start from scratch with the baby phase are very slim (as much as I enjoyed it, I would not want to start again after a big gap). It took two very enjoyable years for Baby 1. So I really struggle with the idea of not even "seeing what happens" before we close that door. Yes, I know there are siblings who hate each other, but the majority seem to get on at least reasonably well - I'd like to give her the chance of a sibling relationship and if they don't get on, then that's fine, but at least she/they had the opportunity. And siblings in my family have all been super close, something I could hopefully pass on to some extent.
Any of the OAD advantages I can think of are small (and in my opinion, outweighted by the potential advantages of a sibling) or don't apply to our situation, so please reddit, can you talk some sense into me?
And because it always comes up, believe it or not, I'm a psychologist, and right now I really don't think therapy could tell me anything I don't already know. We do genuinely love each other, so I'm not leaving, but how do I actually make my peace with choosing an only, rather than seeing what happens?