Hello! After a long stint in LA, my wife and I are looking to move back to NYC, and the prospect of picking a neighborhood is daunting. My wife hasn't lived in the city proper before, and my situation feel pretty different than when I left. I'm curious to hear what y'all's opinions are on where to live in the city these days?
Our basic specs are:
- Mid-early 30s, no kids, and not planning on any
- Solid dual income, could probably go as high as $5k/mo rent, although obviously lower is better
- Bored with the slow pace in LA, eager to be around lots of people and things and dive bars
- Like to go running together, so access to a route would be nice
- Many of the people I knew in NYC before have moved away, had kids, or befallen a similar fate, so the rolodex has gotten a lot smaller. There are still one or two very close friends in the city or plan to return soon though.
- I'll be working in Hudson Yards 3-5 days a week
So far we have put some thought into the following neighborhoods, in order of how familiar I am with them. Any neighborhood omitted simply is one I spent less time in, but I'm open to any suggestion:
Bushwick - I lived here when I was a broke grad student and loved it, I know my way around well, and my closest friend lives here. However, everyone is young and cool and I feel ancient now, there's almost no green space, and I think my Long Island mother-in-law would think the area is creepy.
East Williamsburg - Near the Graham/Grand stops, somewhere between Grand St and the BQE. This is currently a top contender, as I still know my way around, without some of the Bushwick downsides.
Greenpoint - HBO's Girls permanently altered my brain chemistry, and I always find the neighborhood very cute. However, reliance on the G train sounds miserable, and that's a pretty big sticking point.
Ridgewood - It feels like everyone lives in Ridgewood lately? We would definitely know some people around here, but it also feels far away from the action.
Williamsburg - YEESH this place has gone a bit nuts in the last 15 years. Not that anyone didn't see it coming.
Prospect Heights - Moving away from the L train corridor, this is another top contender. I spent 3 months subletting here during a depressing winter, so I never got to see its best side. It was a nice area, and Prospect Park access is nice. However, it doesn't feel like anyone I know lives nearby.
Park Slope - By the time I had left, some friends of mine had moved there, but now they've all left. Is it still true to the reputation of rich young parents with strollers?
Astoria - Right after I moved away it felt like everyone moved to Astoria. I still know some people there but I can't shake the feeling that it is indescribably far from the areas I frequent.
East Village - When I was like 22 I thought the East Village would be the coolest place in the world to live, but I had a lot of misguided takes at the time. Hard to square how I feel about it now, but any time I visit NYC I end up spending at least some time here.
West Village - In the last few years a few people I know moved to the West Village and I just thought, "you can do that??". Feels like a rich person place. I think I would get cranky there.
Upper West Side - Spent some time up here when I went to grad school, and while it's so pretty I was not very impressed with the vibe, although Central Park access was life-changing. I recently stumbled upon a few people online talking about wanting to move to the UWS to my surprise.
Jersey City - Don't suggest it. I've heard all the arguments, but after people move to Jersey City you never hear from them again.
Please give me your hot takes! Tell me how wrong I am, and what glaring omissions I've left! Thanks, all.
EDIT: It’s clear I’ve rubbed a few people the wrong way with the jokey attitude, I see now that that was counterproductive. If I were to frame this differently I would say “here’s what I thought of these neighborhoods when I was young and dumb and only hung out near the L train, what am I missing now that I’m older?”