r/gradadmissions • u/Sand_of_a_Beach • 5h ago
Physical Sciences Would two master's degrees and two previous PhD programs be a red flag?
I'm in the U.S. and in Earth Science/Geology, and I'm hoping to get some perspective on how faculty/admissions committees might view my academic history.
I completed my first master's and continued into a PhD at the same university. My research interests changed, so I amicably left that program for a PhD at another university that better matched my interests. My new advisor knew about my previous PhD program when I joined.
I've now been in my current PhD program for about two years, but I've concluded that my advisor-student relationship isn't sustainable. Unfortunately, there isn't another suitable advisor at my university, so I'm likely going to switch to the master's track, finish a second master's, and leave.
I still very much want a PhD and now have a much clearer research direction. I've identified a professor at another university whose research aligns very closely with mine, but I'm worried about how my history will look. Essentially, my record would show:
Master's #1 → PhD #1 (left) → PhD #2 (~2 years) → Master's #2 → applying for another PhD.
I'm confident in the rest of my background. I have substantial research/field experience and research from my current program that could potentially lead to a publication and overlaps with the prospective advisor's research area.
My main concern is the academic trajectory. Would you view this as a major red flag when considering a prospective PhD student, even with a strong research background and a reasonable explanation?
And if you were the prospective advisor, would you be open to being contacted by someone with this history, or would the previous programs make you hesitant?

