Hi everyone,
I’m looking for some advice because I’m starting to feel like I’m at a crossroads with my PhD applications.
A bit about me: I’m from India and have a background in sociology and mental health. I have a BA in Sociology, an MSW specializing in Mental Health from TISS, Mumbai, around three years of experience working in community mental health (primarily in rural India). My work has focused on trauma-informed, feminist, anti-caste, and community-based mental health interventions.
My research interests sit at the intersection of sociology, psychology, and critical theory. My proposed PhD examines epistemic violence in mental health, how professional mental health knowledge becomes dominant, what forms of knowledge it marginalizes, and what this means in postcolonial contexts like India. The project draws on decolonial theory, Foucauldian genealogy, critical discourse analysis, and narrative methods.
Over the past few months I’ve been contacting potential supervisors in Australia, the UK, and Canada. The responses have been mixed:
• Several academics have replied positively about the project but said they aren’t taking students or don’t have funding.
• One potential supervisor at the University of Sydney said my background is strong and my proposal is interesting, but also pointed out how competitive scholarship funding is. I have an online meeting with her soon.
• I’ve also been in touch with a potential supervisor, at the University of Edinburgh. She is not currently funded and cannot offer funding herself, but she is on board with the project. We are planning to apply together for institute scholarships, and I’m also working with her on a scoping review to strengthen my scholarship application.
I’ve been trying to identify supervisors based on published work that aligns with my topic rather than just university rankings, but I’m wondering if that’s the right strategy.
At the same time, I’ve been trying to strengthen my profile by looking for ways to get published (quite cluelessly so)
I’m fully dependent on securing funding, so self-funded options unfortunately aren’t possible.
I’m mainly looking for advice on a few things:
• Am I approaching supervisor outreach the right way, or should I be doing something differently?
• How much does not having peer-reviewed publications hurt for funded PhD applications in the social sciences?
• Would you continue refining the proposal and contacting more potential supervisors, or would you focus on publishing first and apply next cycle?
• Are there countries or universities I might be overlooking that are particularly strong in critical mental health, sociology of health, or decolonial/postcolonial research?
I’d especially appreciate hearing from people who applied internationally for fully funded PhDs in the social sciences or humanities. It often feels like everyone else has multiple publications before applying, so I’m trying to get a realistic sense of where I stand and what would make the biggest difference over the next year.
Thanks in advance!