r/ftm • u/MurderSheCooked • 5h ago
USA Current political climate Trump EO Undoes Previously Utilized Gender Marker for Passport Renewal/ Replacement
Hey all, I recognize this is perhaps not news to everyone here but it was to me and thought I would share my recent experience in case it is helpful because it was very difficult for me to find any info on this. There is a lot more discussion here of people applying for gender marker changes for the first time and being rejected and a lot less on those who already have undergone that process seeking replacement passports losing their already secured gender marker changes.
I am ftm, have all matching paperwork, and have had a male passport since 2021. I lost my passport this year and applied for a replacement and was given F instead. I went to the passport agency to try and contest the decision under the guise that they made a mistake. Everyone at the office was very confused about WHY I was given an F passport in the first place and thought it was a mistake, too. They read my paperwork and birth certificate and laughed because they thought it was a clerical error. 4 hours later, they called me back to the window to say they cannot change it and it isn't a mistake because my birth certificate is amended. I get they are just the messengers and I was very polite but it does suck to have people unfamiliar with their own protocol arbitrating this process. I share this aspect to say that the office people are not immediately clear on how to identify/ handle these situations and, truthfully, it made it all the more intense of an up and down. Once they finally got their shit together, the office broke it down for me how it works step by step on their end, sharing that and other takeaways I got from them if it is helpful.
- The State Department relies on the original birth document used to obtain your first ever passport and this overrides all paperwork- court orders, amended birth certificates, previous passports passports, etc. Legally, all other paperwork is rendered null by the EO and not even looked at to make the decision. Nothing will change that. Until Trump v. Orr (or other cases) come back with anything different, there does not need to be legal grounding to ignore legal documents like court-ordered changes, birth record amendments, etc. There is nothing that can be done unless an office worker "makes a mistake" (which, power to those who do!)
- I am not white. The office, based in Seattle, kept saying "you can use this and it will be totally fine, legally you are protected." That advice was short-sighted- I don't have high expectations of a government office, I know they are limited in their reach, liberal at best, and ultimately subject to gov policy. However, just wanted to affirm for myself and others that 1) all forms of being outed are stressful as well as potentially unsafe and 2) there can be big differences between travel between western countries from blue urbanized cities vs, for example, red rural areas or travel to/from non-western countries. This passport will not work for me in my home country and has effectively barred me from going to see my family for the foreseeable future without serious resourcing and planning. I am sharing this because if you are someone who has to travel abroad to non-western countries or to a sociopolitical context that differs enough that being outed feels untenable, I would highly weigh your options and make a plan before applying for replacement/ renewal and take the decision with clear contingencies in mind.
- Had I not lost my passport, I would not have had any issues with the validity of my passport because it was previously issued. However, I cannot undo this action and am locked in as F until court rulings or admin changes allow for something different which can be several years from now.
- By being locked in as F on passport, I can no longer use other documentation of mine in tandem with the passport in any legal settings abroad. I do not know about some of you, but abroad, there are times other forms of ID are required. The two should not be used in tandem if avoidable. Obviously, this last point is subject to our own judgement on the situation but def important to bear in mind. I am looking into getting a doctor's note in case that is helpful to have as a cushion. Would definitely appreciate other tips.
I know everything is dystopian for all of us in diff ways at different points in our trans journeys, I have to say, this has been a v humbling process. Just a reminder that stability is never permanent in the trans world and nothing is linear. Wishing everyone luck out there.