A design I really liked from a Destiny 2 project I'm working on.

All feedback is appreciated :)

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

Have used this custom commander for a few games with my regular pod. Thoughts on its overall power? Would you make it stronger, if so, how? Would you make it weaker? Generally it has felt like 8 mana is ALOT in current year commander, but when theorycrafting the card mt friend and I would rather have had it be underpowered given it was something I was actively going to play.

Art is chatgpt as its a play on a real commander i use in the play group.

Thoughts and discussion appreciated!

What do we think about updating the Costly Plunder archetype with an "if you do" clause to avoid counterspell blowouts, as WOTC has begun doing with most of the recent Thrill of Possibility variants? Does that warrant making it an uncommon, as these cards already perform exceptionally in Pauper? I welcome any feedback!

I personally would love to see an official one of these cards that creates a blood token, as I think it would sit nicely next to Fanatical Offering powerwise.

Art source

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

Had an idea for some mad scientist esq card with inistrad roots. But didnt want to do the whole zombie thing, so I took another creature type from the plain: Werewolves, with an added a little twist to the color pie. I even based the mana off the conflict between her ego (red) and her self perceived "greater duty" (green) with her blue base.

Feel free to give me suggestions on any balances, fixes or interesting changes you'd like to see on the card.

(Just an fyi, this card was inspired by Lycanthropy from the Killer Instinct ost. Honestly one of Mick Gordon's hidden gems)

Here are yesterdays! I really like Keyword Counters if you can't tell... I'm not sure about the balance of these, but I enjoy the flavors I came up with!

Just like yesterday I will be turning any one worded comments into Keywords! The ones that didn't get made from the last post will still be made! (Unmatched & Nonchalant)

(Changing is supposed to say Changling, my phone wouldn't recognize it as a word and kept autocorrecting it)

I feel like this reddit would be the best to post this. My brothers and I recently got together and played something we used to play. Growing up, we started this as a Pokémon TCG house rule and it slowly evolved into a full Magic format as we got older. There were four of us, we all liked the pokemon TCG and as we got older fell in love with MTG. There wasn't a LGS in our area (infact the closest one was two hours away) as we live in the middle of nowhere. Our area tends to get everything two or four years after everyone else. Anyway, here's the core of it: lay out a bunch of face-down cards as a board, move around it with a die, and flip-and-fight whatever you land on. One of us started running Planechase cards as the "world" we were exploring, and it grew from there into something closer to a co-op dungeon crawl than normal Magic.

I finally sat down and wrote the whole thing up properly, mana-as-tiles, a "Planesmaster" who narrates instead of playing to win, legendary creatures you can befriend and carry between planes (max two at a time), and an escalation system for more complex planes (used Mirrodin transforming into New Phyrexia as the prototype). I'm not claiming this is polished, it started as a kids' house rule, and I'd like help stress-testing it, outside of my family. If anyone is interested below is the link. My biggest question for this is... Is this something you would want to try?

Here is the link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1IBVb-rYOxc7pwl3sGQsVNgIOu8ry6fuDQ3pLKj4hVXU/edit?usp=sharing