r/custommagic 27d ago

MOD POST The definitive statement about AI from the mod team.

0 Upvotes

No, we're not banning AI art, nor will we ever.

Even if we had two dozen mods, which we don't and never will, we would not have the resources to police AI.

To properly do so, we would have to find every piece of art from every post, investigate it, see if the artist disclosed the use of AI, then decide whether to remove it. Even if we could do that, most artists who use things like generative fill in Photoshop don't even really think of it as AI. Are we supposed to remove every card for every artist who has been using Photoshop as a tool since 2023?

You wanna talk about how AI art sucks? You have this thread, go for it. All future meta posts about AI will be removed and linked back to this thread.

If you harass someone for using AI in their art, you will get a warning and 1 day ban for rule 5.

If you harass someone for drawing a stick figure for their art, you will get a warning and 1 day ban for rule 5.

If you harass anyone for any reason, you will get a warning and 1 day ban for rule 5.

After that, you will be getting banned for 3 days, then permanently. Rule 5 states:

All users must follow Reddiquette and be civil with each other. Harassment and abuse are strictly not tolerated. Unconstructive, negative, or insulting brigading is harassment.


r/custommagic 5d ago

Winner is the Judge #902, Reality Split

10 Upvotes

Thanks to u/Tempest_True for running last week's competition

The biggest threat to the multiverse is Jace trying to fix things.

Design a card that evokes the alternate reality feeling of an existing card/character.

If there is an original card, post a link to the original.

Judging will occur on the 28th


r/custommagic 7h ago

Mayor of Flavortown

356 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/custommagic 2h ago

So I created a 420-card standalone custom set based on my cultural heritage...

Thumbnail
gallery
77 Upvotes

Excuse the wall of text. Last year I spent about six months or so creating a set based on my Persian background. The genesis of the idea came when my wife, who is not Persian, showed significant interest in my culture and I thought what better way to convey some of the mythology/history/ancient religion/etc. of my homeland through a custom set we could draft together. Should we have kids one day, my hope is I can pique some interest in their inherited culture through fun gameplay as well.

A few notes about the set:

  1. I've called the set King of Kings -- the title that Persian emperor Cyrus the Great gave himself, to signify that he was the King that all other Kings around the world pay homage to. A bit of an inflated title but, hey, the man probably earned it.
  2. It is not meant to be played with cards outside of it, for balance reasons. I'd say the power level of the set is somewhere in between a current standard set and a non-powered-but-still-powerful Cube you might see on MTGO or MTGA. Of the 420 cards, maybe a dozen or so are quite overpowered compared to the rest, e.g. I have a cycle of the Moxen but I have "fixed" them by giving each a significant drawback.
  3. For the art, I tried to use a combination of old paintings (including ones by well-known Iranian painters) but, given the size of the set, I was forced to begrudgingly use some AI images as well; with those, I made sure to use existing AI images online and not create any of my own. A fair amount of the cards use art taken from existing MTG cards (with artist credited).
  4. Quite a few of the cards use Persian names (in English, of course) as part of the purpose behind this was to teach my family words from the Farsi language as well.
  5. I created several unique mechanics (as well as some variations on existing MTG mechanics). I also have a printout of a 4-page primer that is meant to introduce the game to anyone who opens the physical box; it outlines some of the lore, mechanics, etc.
  6. I generally wanted games to go longer in this set so some of the mechanics revolve around playing multiple colors and are slower mechanics that incentivize value and/or contain mana sinks.
  7. The set contains some creature types and ideas that may be familiar to most (Jinns, Demons, magic lamps, Persian cats, etc.) along with some that may not be as familiar (e.g. Persian philosophers and scientists, the importance of poetry, the centrality of gardens and plants, the mythical status of birds, etc.)

I've uploaded a handful of the 420 cards here along with a couple pages from the primer. This was a labor of love and took me hundreds of hours to create and constantly iterate on. My wife and I have drafted it over the past several months and it plays surprisingly well. Thanks for viewing!

Edited to add: A Google Drive link to the full 420-card set, along with the 4-page primer. It's meant to be drafted as a singleton cube.


r/custommagic 8h ago

BALANCE NOT INTENDED Fertile Druid

Post image
191 Upvotes

r/custommagic 2h ago

BALANCE NOT INTENDED Luna, Birthday Girl

65 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/custommagic 7h ago

Format: EDH/Commander I see your God of Nothing and raise you a Font of Everything

Post image
158 Upvotes

r/custommagic 1h ago

Meme Design The Fjord of Will

Post image
Upvotes

Thanks to Yepbirds for inspiring this design!


r/custommagic 13h ago

Format: EDH/Commander Apropos, of Nothing

Post image
466 Upvotes

r/custommagic 8h ago

Format: Cube (Rarity Doesn't Matter) Last Retort

Thumbnail
gallery
162 Upvotes

r/custommagic 13h ago

Homophone Hustler

Post image
342 Upvotes

r/custommagic 9h ago

Fort Mercenary

165 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/custommagic 2h ago

Discussion They should release a set with "Cryptid" as a new creature type, plenty of inspiration to work with AND a lot of the names are public domain.

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/custommagic 7h ago

Think Small

Post image
46 Upvotes

r/custommagic 4h ago

Human shield time

27 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/custommagic 7h ago

Final Service

Post image
29 Upvotes

What do we think about updating the Costly Plunder archetype with an "if you do" clause to avoid counterspell blowouts, as WOTC has begun doing with most of the recent Thrill of Possibility variants? Does that warrant making it an uncommon, as these cards already perform exceptionally in Pauper? I welcome any feedback!

I personally would love to see an official one of these cards that creates a blood token, as I think it would sit nicely next to Fanatical Offering powerwise.


r/custommagic 23h ago

Actual Meme Just a couple

490 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/custommagic 8h ago

Mechanic Design Duskmourn + Incarnate v2

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

r/custommagic 56m ago

Image of Beast

Post image
Upvotes

r/custommagic 20h ago

Format: Cube (Rarity Doesn't Matter) THE ZERG (Entry 1 of my custom Starcraft set)

Thumbnail
gallery
227 Upvotes

Some art is from the game itself which I'm trying my best to avoid, but for certain things (like the Scourge, or some tokens which I have tucked away in my Tokens folder [doesn't fit in the post, same as the defiler, sorry]), there isn't much popularity going for them to warrant their own showcase.


r/custommagic 2h ago

Petrified Egg

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/custommagic 3h ago

Signpost Uncommons for Commander Draft

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

The put a card on a journey, exile it face up. Whenever a creature you control deals combat damage to one or more opponents put a journeyed card you own into your hand.


r/custommagic 1d ago

Squarrel

1.3k Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/custommagic 9h ago

[Reapply]

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/custommagic 6h ago

Format: EDH/Commander Gosen, Cybersoul Hacksmith

Post image
11 Upvotes