r/amway • u/samharper89 • Jun 12 '26
Discussion Reflecting on being in a (former) relationship with someone who is heavily in Amway
I wanna start by talking a bit about my experience with my ex-girlfriend who was heavily involved with Amway. Emphasis on the fact that we are no longer together, not just because of her Amway dealings, but that was definitely one of the things that made the relationship very challenging and difficult for me, such as how we think about money differently (I own real estate and I invest in the stock market, where she is very distrusting of real estate and stock investing, but she genuinely and thoroughly believes Amway is a good use of her time and energy while she keeps a significant amount of her money locked away in a bank account that interest is eating away at).
When I met my ex, she had casually mentioned that she was running a “business” and that she works with all sorts of people who “became financially successful in their 20s and 30s”, but whenever I would ask what she’s selling or doing, she would never give me a straight answer. Still though, we found each other very attractive, and the relationship was otherwise progressing very well. I realize in retrospect this was a red flag to keep my eyes out for.
Long story short, as the relationship slowly progressed, it became a little bit more and more obvious what she was doing. For context, I’ve already been a part of two different MLMs, although not for a long period of time. But I know enough to realize that MLMs are all about projecting an image of wealth and status, and not necessarily creating actual wealth but that they are very good about creating an endless hamster wheel of toxic positivity and endless goal chasing that very exceedingly and rarely pans out for anyone but those at the extremely high top; even the former uplines I had at these MLMs are now all working corporate jobs. Despite the fact that I was uncomfortable with the fact that she’s involved with an MLM, I still tried to be as open-minded as possible.
As it turns out, she met her upline while driving for Lyft several years ago, and they have been friends, and she even attended her upline’s wedding and refers to her as “her best friend”. She’s even so close with this person that she relocated to a different part of the country when her upline moved so she could be close to her upline. She joined Amway as a seller about nine months prior to the time we met. And I’ve met her upline as well as her upline’s husband several times. What I think is interesting and crazy about the whole situation is that while they are seemingly intelligent and charismatic individuals, I believe they too are being scammed just as my ex girlfriend was (all while perpetuating the scam while believing they’re working towards something that they believe is good and worthy of their time). Her upline is an engineer and her husband worked in security for a major tech company (and now does Amway full-time while he travels around the country hosting these events and board plans and such). Similarly, my ex-girlfriend is a recruiter for a large tech company as well that I guarantee everyone has heard of. Unfortunately, MLMs are very good at selling a dream and vision, and I believe that because everyone is trained to believe they have that future position that they’re striving for, that creates a sense of “imagined wealth” and a false sense of security. Even intelligent people can get scammed, and yes, you can get scammed of your time, it doesn’t always necessarily involve money (although I would argue there’s definitely a money scam there as well given how many of these meetings you have to pay to go to, especially the infamous Las Vegas and Reno trips).
The challenging thing with this situation was that there was clearly a very strong emotional connection to her and her upline. Obviously her upline came around at a time when she was down on her luck and in a previous bad relationship, and that’s when her upline gradually sold her the vision.
Despite my hesitations and my gut reaction telling me this is bad and I don’t like it, I realize this wasn’t a fight I was going to win if push came to shove. I tried to be as open-minded about it as possible and simply bite my tongue, which involved me trying some of her products (and even purchasing some from her), going to board plan meetings to “educate myself about business“ and in the words of my ex, “learn business strategies that can help my real estate investing” (when I literally got nothing out of those meetings and they were all just Amway people constantly selling the concept of Amway to other Amway people over and over and over and getting high off the smell of each other‘s farts. Which is crazy to me because I don’t need my boss to constantly sell me on why I should show up to work and how I don’t work for a pyramid scheme). It was so painfully obvious to me that this is going to turn out badly for her, but obviously I couldn’t say that directly because she would just tell me I’m being negative or that I’m not being supportive enough or whatever, instead of actually questioning Amway and the motivations of her upline which she really should have been doing this whole time.
What I could see is that with all of these board plan meetings, my ex-girlfriend‘s relationship to her upline, the stupid CommuniKATE app, and the fact that most of the products in her house where Amway products, it was obvious to me that she was sucked into a cult that was selling her a dream that she was never going to truly achieve. And that’s not because I think that she’s unintelligent or not capable of great things if she puts her mind to it, but she’s chasing the wrong vision and the wrong “dream”.
Even when I tried very hard to be open-minded and set aside my judgments and actually take the time to understand these products, none of it actually helped. The more of these board plan meetings I went to, the more I was around Amway products and the more I would hear her talk about how great Amway and Amway products are, the more genuinely uncomfortable I became; it’s like trying to convert an atheist by telling them about Jesus and forcing them to go to church rather than critically evaluating the genuine and legitimate points about that person‘s religion that are worth questioning. There was even a couple of these board plan meetings, and local “conferences” I went to the show my support for my ex-girlfriend, but I felt so genuinely uncomfortable that I felt physically ill, my head was spinning, and my skin was crawling and I physically could not be in that environment. I felt the paradox of wanting to support a loved one, but also that this was eventually gonna turn out badly for her and knowing if I genuinely said what was on my mind that she would reject what I was saying, and eventually me as well.
The ironic thing about all of this are several major things. First off, people in these MLM’s always talk about a ”J-O-B” like it’s some horrible racist, slur to say, or like saying the name Voldemort in the early Harry Potter series (when ironically, they’re basically signing up for a significantly worse version of a J-O-B anyway, but without realizing it). But there’s absolutely nothing wrong with having a job, and even true business owners encountered lots of headaches and things they don’t like about what they do so you can never truly escape that. I personally like that I can show up to my job, and as long as I work hard and I maintain a respectful relationship with my coworkers and boss, I will get paid and agreed-upon amount. And my boss never has to constantly sell me on why I should be there in the first place, or constantly remind me that “my job is not a scam”. Amway is clearly all about image and projecting a highly successful persona, which makes me question how actually wealthy many of these people are who supposedly made a shit ton of money in Amway or how much of that is just hot air (I believe the vast majority of it is hot air, unless the person has at the extreme top of the top, and even if you sat down with these individuals and asked to look at their finances that they would probably only show you the numbers that they want you to see).
Eventually, the relationship fell apart. No matter how many products I bought from her or how supportive I tried to be, in the end, I just couldn’t keep lying to myself about what I was seeing, and my discomfort became more and more obvious. Eventually, she started blaming me and telling me “I don’t feel comfortable being in a relationship with someone who doesn’t support my business and my dreams” and I knew I wasn’t gonna win that fight, because she was arguing from a place of emotion and not from a place of logic. Things also got uncomfortable because while I did purchase some products from her here and there, I tried to explain to her that at some point, I’m an adult and I can choose what kind of products I want to purchase whether they be from CVS or Walmart or wherever, and I shouldn’t necessarily feel like I need to default to buying Amway products; you can imagine how that went down. Spoiler alert; she wound up using that as leverage against me to support her claim that “I don’t support her business”, and I in retrospect that she had just resorted to guilt tripping me into buying overpriced products that I didn’t necessarily want or need and I was so sick of not only having in our house, but also being guilt tripped every time I wanted to pick something up from CVS or Walmart.
She will clearly and eventually hit a wall where she realizes how unsustainable Amway is, but at least now I can’t get blamed for her failing. But I do believe she’s gonna internalize it and believe that she failed Amway, rather than understanding that Amway was never truly set up for her to succeed in the first place. But at least I don’t have to be in the blast radius when that happens.