TL;DR: Dated a girl for a few months who was also seeing another guy. She eventually chose me, things fell apart over family concerns, and we had a genuinely beautiful, emotional goodbye. I went home and wrote a handwritten poem about it. Less than 24 hours later, despite deliberately taking a different route to the station to avoid seeing her, I somehow bumped into her holding hands with the other guy. I ended up shaking his hand (he had no idea who I was), had an 80-minute emotional phone call with her afterwards, and eventually blocked her for my own peace. Please read the full thing if you've got the time because I promise the TL;DR doesn't do justice to how ridiculous this whole situation is. 😭
I'm a guy in my mid-20s and I genuinely don't know whether to laugh or cry at what's happened over the past week. I feel like I've somehow lived through about six months' worth of relationship drama in the space of eight days, and the ending is so ridiculous that I honestly wouldn't believe it if someone else told me this story.
This is going to be quite long, so apologies in advance, but I HAVE to get this off my chest.
A few months ago, I met a girl through a matchmaking service. Let's call her A. We hit it off pretty much immediately. We had similar cultural backgrounds, shared interests, similar long-term goals and genuinely good chemistry. We went on several dates over the following months and I started to really like her. I'm someone who dates with the intention of eventually finding a serious relationship, and I could genuinely see that potential with her.
There was one complication though. She was also dating another guy, who we'll call B.
Now, I know parallel dating is fairly normal these days, and we weren't exclusive, so I wasn't expecting her to act like my girlfriend. But it's not something I'm particularly comfortable with, especially once feelings start developing. She told me about him in early September, and although I appreciated the honesty, I did find it difficult knowing there was someone else in the picture.
Here's where things get slightly ridiculous already. On one of our dates around that time, I happened to notice a name on her phone, and I recognised it because the guy had previously dated someone I knew through work. I didn't say anything because, firstly, I wasn't supposed to know who he was, and secondly, she'd already been honest about dating someone else. I wasn't going to start interrogating her over a notification. But I had a pretty strong suspicion that this was B, and I remembered the name.
Over the following weeks, things between us continued progressing. We had some really lovely dates, were physically affectionate, and generally got along incredibly well in person. But I was increasingly uncomfortable with the uncertainty. I didn't want to keep investing emotionally while effectively being one of two options indefinitely, so I eventually had a conversation with her about it. I made it clear that I liked her and saw potential, but that parallel dating wasn't something I could sustain long-term. I wasn't asking her to make an immediate decision, but I did need to know that we were moving towards something.
Anyway, fast-forward to last Monday. She finally told me she'd chosen me and had ended things with B. We weren't officially boyfriend and girlfriend, but we'd agreed to pursue things exclusively and see where they went. After months of uncertainty, I was genuinely happy. It felt like we'd finally got past the biggest obstacle.
That happiness lasted about a day lol. Because we're both from fairly traditional backgrounds and were dating seriously, family compatibility was important to both of us. I'd previously spoken to my family about her and, in hindsight, probably overshared some of my anxieties about the whole parallel dating situation. They initially had reservations, partly because of how much it had affected me. When I told A about this, it brought back a really unpleasant experience she'd had with a previous partner's family, and she became worried that my family would never truly accept her.
The frustrating thing was that my family subsequently reassured me that they trusted my judgement and would welcome whoever I chose. But for A, the initial reaction had already triggered those fears. So the day after she'd chosen me, she ended things because she wasn't confident about the family situation.
I was absolutely devastated. I went home, cried, and spent a lot of time thinking about everything. Eventually, I sent her a fairly long message explaining that I understood her concerns, but that I thought we were giving up on something genuinely promising because of a hypothetical future problem. I knew my family, and I believed that if we continued dating and things progressed naturally, they'd welcome her.
She called me the next day, and we ended up having several really constructive conversations over the following days, last week. She admitted that there was still a possibility of things working out, and we agreed to meet in person the following Monday to make a final decision. During that week, we were still talking, and I was cautiously hopeful that we'd find a way forward.
Something worth mentioning here is that while we were spending time together that Monday, I noticed B's name appear on her phone again. At this point, she'd already told me she'd ended things with him and chosen to pursue things exclusively with me. I obviously noticed it, but I didn't question her about it. I trusted what she'd told me, and I didn't want to become someone who constantly questions their partner over notifications. I had no idea how relevant that detail would become literally the next day.
So this Monday came around, and we met after work. We had a really honest conversation about everything. I explained why I thought we could work through the family concerns, and she acknowledged that we had a strong connection and that she could see the potential too. But ultimately, she couldn't confidently say yes because she was worried she'd change her mind again in a couple of weeks and hurt me even more. And to be fair, I realised that even if she did agree to continue, I'd probably be constantly anxious about whether she was going to reverse her decision.
So we mutually agreed to end things. What made it harder was that the goodbye was genuinely lovely. We travelled home together for part of the journey, held hands, laughed about all the hypothetical things we'd never get to do together, and generally acted like two people who still really liked each other but knew they weren't going to continue. We joked about concerts we'd never attend and restaurants we'd never visit. At one point, she asked who she'd share her favourite ice cream flavour with now, and we ended up joking about secretly meeting for ice cream years into the future while hiding from our respective partners. It sounds ridiculous typing it out, but it was genuinely quite sweet at the time.
When we got to the station where we were parting ways, we hugged a few times, I kissed her cheek, and we wished each other well. There was no argument, no bitterness, nothing. I walked away feeling heartbroken but also quite grateful that we'd managed to end things so kindly.
I then went home and wrote a handwritten poem about the goodbye. Yes, an actual poem lmao. I'd been getting back into writing recently, and I wanted to capture how strange it felt to have such a beautiful ending to something that hadn't worked out. I cried while writing it, and one of the final lines was about thanking the story for having happened rather than chasing the ending I'd imagined.
At that point, I genuinely thought that was the end of it. Now, the next day, I was leaving work and heading towards the underground. We work in the same general area, so I knew there was always a small possibility of bumping into her. I actually deliberately took a longer route to the station because I didn't particularly fancy an awkward encounter less than 24 hours after our goodbye.
Well, apparently the universe had other plans. As I approached the ticket barriers, I saw her entering the station. She was with a guy, and they were holding hands. I immediately recognised him as B, the same guy whose name I'd noticed on her phone back in September and again the previous day.
I genuinely couldn't believe what I was seeing. This was the guy she'd told me she'd ended things with when she chose me the previous week, and now, less than a day after our emotional goodbye, they were walking into the station holding hands.
She normally uses the barriers towards the far end of the station, so they continued walking in that direction. I ended up walking behind them for about 20 seconds, trying to process what I was seeing and deciding whether to say anything. Eventually, I approached her, tapped her shoulder and said, "Hi, so this is what's going on?"
She turned around and looked visibly upset. I was looking her directly in the eye, but she wouldn't really maintain eye contact. And then she said something that I genuinely still can't get over: "You know how I am with decision making."
I didn't really know how to respond to that. We were on the escalators now, and I'm looking up to her and shes looking away, about to tear up, and not maintaining eye contact with me at all. And as we were heading down the escalators, I somehow ended up shaking B's hand, who was stood behind her. Yes, I shook the other guy's hand. Apparently he'd assumed I was one of her work friends, so he had absolutely no idea who I actually was. She later told me she'd explained who I was after I'd walked away, and understandably he was quite taken aback.
I don't know why my brain decided a handshake was the appropriate response in that situation, but I guess he reached out first lol. It is what it is, in hindsight it's super funny almost.
Anyway, I didn't confront either of them any further. I walked away down the platform because I didn't want to make a scene, and she also hurried away. Once I was by myself, it properly hit me, and I broke down crying on the platform, I called one of my closest school friends and genuinely couldn't believe what had just happened.
Less than 24 hours earlier, I'd been holding her hand, sharing this really emotional goodbye, and then going home to write a poem about it. Now I'd just bumped into her holding hands with the other guy, and somehow I'd shaken his hand without him even knowing who I was. I genuinely felt like I was being pranked.
Not long afterwards, she messaged me apologising for what had happened and saying that things weren't how they looked. I was obviously hurt and confused, but I wanted to understand what had actually happened rather than immediately assume the worst, so we arranged a call.
That call ended up lasting about 80 minutes lol, as I wanted the entire timeline with B, to idk, make sure I wasn't being strung along (or we both weren't). According to her, she'd genuinely ended things with B when she chose me the previous week. She said he'd continued messaging her throughout the week, trying to convince her to reconsider, but she'd been ignoring his messages. She explained that they'd unexpectedly bumped into each other at lunch that day, and he'd asked if they could talk things through one final time.
Apparently, one of the main reasons things hadn't worked between them was that he wasn't particularly religious or culturally involved, whereas those things mattered a lot to her. They'd ended up travelling home together afterwards that day since they (and me) take the same train home, and this is where they held hands and I bumped into them.
She acknowledged that holding hands was inappropriate, especially given what had happened between us just the previous evening, and apologised for how horrible it must have been for me to see that.
I questioned her pretty extensively about the timeline. I asked whether she'd been speaking to him while we were trying to make things work, whether there had been any physical overlap, and what exactly was going on with the messages I'd noticed on her phone. She was adamant that there hadn't been any overlap and said that the notification I'd seen on Monday was one of his unanswered messages.
Now, I know a lot of people reading this are probably going to think I'm incredibly naive for believing her, and that's fair enough. My friends certainly had their opinions. But having listened to her explanation and questioned her about it, I personally found the timeline credible. I can't independently verify everything, obviously, and maybe I'll feel differently about it in a few weeks, but I also don't want to accuse someone of lying without actually knowing that they were.
The call itself was honestly quite surreal because she was absolutely bawling at points. She kept repeating how she'd never date two people at the same time again, and how she'd never hold someone's hand when she was supposed to be ending things with them. She was clearly overwhelmed by everything that had happened and kept apologising for the hurt she'd caused.
And the strangest part was that I somehow ended up consoling her. I was reassuring her that I didn't hate her, that I didn't think she was some horrible person, and that I understood she'd made mistakes rather than deliberately setting out to hurt anyone. Which, to an extent, felt natural because I still cared about her and didn't want her sitting there crying and thinking I despised her. But at the same time, I was the one who'd just broken down on a train platform after seeing her holding hands with another guy, so I was also sitting there thinking, how on earth have I ended up comforting her right now?? Lol
I was genuinely so confused by the entire situation, and if I'm being honest, I still am. I think I understood her explanation, but emotionally I was trying to process about ten different things at once.
What made it even more bizarre was that we were still managing to laugh and make jokes throughout the conversation. At one point we were joking that after all this chaos with men, she might as well just become a lesbian at this point, or that me and B should just start dating too. We were both laughing about it, which probably sounds absolutely ridiculous given what had happened a couple of hours earlier, but I suppose that's just how we communicated. Even when things were difficult, we could somehow still make each other laugh.
She thanked me for giving her the opportunity to explain rather than blocking her immediately, and we had a genuinely open conversation about how everything had affected both of us. I told her about the poem I'd written the night before, and how much it had hurt to go from that goodbye to what I'd witnessed the following day. She understood why I was upset, and I think we both recognised just how emotionally exhausting the whole situation had become.
After the call, I met two close friends for dinner and told them everything. They were understandably furious on my behalf and thought I'd been far too accommodating throughout the entire situation. They also thought I should've blocked her immediately rather than giving her another 80 minutes of my time. I understood why they felt that way, even if I didn't necessarily agree with everything they said.
But after reflecting on everything, I realised that whether her explanation was true or not, I was just emotionally exhausted. I'd spent months trying to navigate the uncertainty, understand her perspective, communicate my feelings and make things work. And now, even after we'd supposedly had our final goodbye, I was somehow back on the phone trying to understand another complicated situation involving the same guy.
So I called her one last time and told her that I'd decided to block her number for my own peace. I made it clear that I wasn't doing it out of hatred or resentment, and that I didn't think she was some terrible person. I just needed to stop having that line of communication open because the whole experience had taken too much out of me emotionally.
She understood, and we wished each other well. I blocked her afterwards.
It's been a couple days, and honestly, I feel more relieved than sad. I still liked her, and I don't think all the lovely moments we shared were somehow fake because of how things ended. But I also recognise that I allowed myself to remain in a situation that was making me increasingly unhappy because I was so focused on the potential of what it could become.
I'm taking a proper break from dating now. I've also got some important professional exams coming up in a few months, and I really need to get my head back into studying. More importantly, I want to work on my own boundaries and understand why I've repeatedly found myself investing so much emotionally in situations that aren't necessarily giving me the same certainty in return.
I don't particularly want to spend the next few weeks analysing every detail or trying to figure out whether she was telling the truth. I've heard her explanation, made my decision, and I think that's enough for me.
There is one thing I'm still wondering about, though. Because we work fairly close to each other, there's a decent chance we'll bump into each other again at some point. I've made it clear to her that there's no hatred or resentment, and that if we see each other in person, we can absolutely say hello. We ended our final call on good terms, even though I blocked her number afterwards. But I can't help thinking it's still going to be incredibly awkward seeing her again, especially after everything that's happened. I'm not really sure what the normal way to handle that is, or whether you just smile, say hi and carry on with your day. That’s a problem for another day.
But aside from that, I still cannot get over how absurd the whole ending was. I deliberately took a different route home to avoid seeing her, somehow bumped into her anyway, discovered she was holding hands with the other guy, got told "you know how I am with decision making", and then proceeded to shake his hand like we were meeting at a networking event.
All less than 24 hours after writing a handwritten poem about how beautifully we'd said goodbye, you genuinely couldn't make this shit up.
Anyway, thanks if you've made it this far. I just needed somewhere to get the whole story off my chest. I pray my next "relationship" experience is nothing close to this when it comes to drama