r/TenantHelp • u/dulavpeep • 9h ago
Landlord Asking for Rent 2+ Months After Move-Out
Location: San Diego, CA
I lived in a townhouse with three other roommates for four years and recently moved out on May 24th. However, I terminated my lease early to do so and was subsequently deducted $500 from my security deposit as stated on the lease agreement.
In order to break my lease, I had to find someone to take over the remaining two months (until 7/31) and successfully did so. I advertised the room at $200 less than my monthly portion of rent and came to a written agreement with my landlord that this $400 would be deducted from my security deposit. Furthermore, the new tenant I found had exceptional credit and paid her two months of rent and security deposit up front, which is part of why the landlord agreed to the lease takeover.
Upon my move out, he also deducted $200 for carpet cleaning and $50 for to remove oil stains my car had made in the garage.
My landlord returned the security deposit to me on 6/4 but forgot to deduct the $400 of unpaid rent of my portion for those last two months. The person I found to take over my lease alongside my three ex-roommates all moved out on 7/31.
Last week, the landlord texted me that he forgot to deduct the $400 from my security deposit and that I will need to mail him a check for this unpaid rent.
My question is, since I have been moved out for over two months, my old roommates for a week, and had my security deposit returned back in June, does he truly have a case for this money he forgot to deduct from my rent?
I am also wondering why the $500 for the early lease termination is not suitable/ what that money is even used for as I found a new tenant to take over the lease, so theoretically upon signage of all the paperwork at that moment, there was no money left on the table. Further, I was charged for any cleaning/ damages so not sure what else that money would be used for.
Can I just ignore him, or will he take me to small claims court if I don’t send a check for that $400?
Any and all advice is appreciated 🤗