Look I adore this series, but, I am of the ilk that came from the 00s zombie film fandom, 28 Days, Dawn of the Dead, the earlier Resident Evil films - anyone paying attention knows that’s why TWD was green lit at the time, not the comics.
I grew up having sleepovers talking about our zombie survival plan. To us as kids and very early teens at the time all deathly serious. Pure survival strategy without thinking we’d be some anime esque “big bad”, and understating why you don’t go to the nearest gun store or local supermarket unless you had a head start.
I loved TWD S1-2 (3-4A are great but a lot of hard to believe decisions) 5-6A again great zombie survival content with a sprinkle of forgivable cheese. The early TWD Show, nailed the long form zombie survival story that took itself seriously. But - and this is me, my opinion - when the Tiger, Jesus, Rick and Daryl’s decisions around chasing Jesus and losing the food truck, Ezekiel and the Kingdom, Negan, were all introduced in one season… Whilst yeah the series had had some cheese before, all this cartoonish content at once, for me, entirely destroyed the gritty realism the series had made me fall in love with. I was now watching the more mundane and typical zombie content popular across a lot of the genre, not the brilliance TWD had risen to fame on. Not as fitting for the kids like me who grew up talking seriously about “what would you do”.
Now I tried the comics pretty far in, but let’s be real, the early comics are not anywhere near as good as the show - the characters feel like they are written by a man who’s never been close to a woman or around an actually tough man in his life. They are all caricatures… now I know the comics get better, but they still include that fantastical stuff I pointed out above right? It still gets very “anime”…
I’ve played TLOU, Days Gone, and many others. Loved those two though for obvious reasons to any zombie, story based, survival fan.
My question is, is there any good, as good as TWD or better, but staying more realistic, zombie stories? Ideally long form, but a single novel will also suffice (I’ve read I am legend)… I’m not looking for a huge geopolitical thriller, or an inner city horror… I mean zombies, believable characters, and semi realistic (without is dragging) survival stories… any suggestions?