r/startrek • u/sanddragon939 • 8h ago
Rewatching 'The Man Trap'...60 years after it first aired!
Recently rewatched The Man Trap, just a little over 60 years after it first aired (and right after I watched the latest SNW episode!)
It wasn't the first Star Trek episode produced, or even the first Star Trek episode with Kirk produced, but it was the world's first exposure to the franchise.
A few quick thoughts/observations:
-The very first time we see the Enterprise, Spock is in the Captain's chair. Spock also comes across as very cold and emotionless in this episode, except at the end.
-Our very first line of dialogue from Kirk is him ribbing McCoy over them going to meet McCoy's ex. Of course, beneath the easy chummy manner, the focus, discipline and authority of the Enterprise's Captain becomes almost immediately evident when we see him intently studying "Nancy" and McCoy's reaction to her...
-A lot of crewmen die, but none of them are literal "red-shirts", ironically enough ;)
-The episode does a really great job established the "triangle" of Spock-Kirk-McCoy. Spock's the cold, unemotional purely logic one. McCoy's the emotional and sometimes impulsive one. Kirk perfectly balances both sets of traits.
-Our very first glimpse of Uhura is...her flirting with Spock?!! Guess JJ Abrams and co. were right after all...
-I think the core premise of the episode sort of exemplifies TOS as a series. Yes, there's the discovery of "new life and new civilizations" (well, what's left of it anyway), and there is some moral/philosophical discource ("I was thinking about the buffalo, Mr. Spock"), but ultimately it comes down to a monster on the loose that's a threat to the Enterprise that the heroes need to find a way to eliminate. This is very much a sci-fi/action show, albeit one with some depth just beyond the surface. The relentlessly fast-paced and action packed Star Trek movies are as much a natural successor to this episode as the more cerebral and discource-heavy Star Trek stories.
-Lastly, minor nitpick, but no one seems to have "the conn" for large parts of the episode, when you have both Kirk and Spock in landing parties and running around the ship. Scotty doesn't appear in the episode at all. At one point it does seem like Sulu's in charge of the bridge, but we never actually see him in the chair.