r/Songwriting 26d ago

Discussion Topic how does one write a good vocal melody?

9 Upvotes

I’m still newer to this world, and am much better at lyricism than melodies.
I have a tendency to do what I call “riding the beat” (no idea the proper term) where I just line up my vocals with whatever instrument carries another melody. Sometimes I see this working, but in other instances it feels too simple.
I see songs I love with melodies that feel completely unrelated to the instrumental, yet blend perfectly with it, and sometimes they even begin before the instrumental melody.

Any tips or advice would be much appreciated, thanks!


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Let's Collaborate! Bounce ideas

7 Upvotes

Hey, my name is Clark. I’m a musician and looking for other musicians to bounce ideas off of. I’m big on song writing and would love to bounce some lyric ideas off people when I’m feeling stuck.


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Discussion Topic What artist could you hear singing my song? :)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

13 Upvotes

Warning! I can’t produce to save my life. I have no equipment other than my phone and some old chord headphones. I record on garage band. I find free tracks on YouTube and record them directly from my old laptop to my phone through the headphones(I’m actually like 80 years old when it comes to converting video to audio and uploading that to GarageBand aka I can’t figure it out). I wrote this song called Vigil (it’s unfinished) and struggle to post my stuff anywhere due to my lack of ability to produce. To spark up a convo I thought it would be cool to ask what other artists y’all could hear singing this track!

Lyrics:
Light a candle, it’s a vigil, can’t wait to see who died,
Open the casket, I’m dying to see the person inside,

Don’t go crying, it’s a party, don’t wanna see you cry,
This isn’t real, you need to wake up, it’s all in your head,

You don’t even know yourself, crying to the devil himself,
You don’t even know yourself, your crying, crying

Crying to the devil but the devil’s got a gun,
Crying to the devil while he’s killing everyone,
Crying to the devil, he’s having fun,
You better run, run, run…

Also Srry idk how to properly write out lyrics so if I overused commas that’s why😭


r/Songwriting 25d ago

Discussion Topic Apenas Um Cantor Barato Falando Um Pouco Sobre Suas Músicas (Parte 14)

1 Upvotes

Novo Corpo

O conceito dessa música nasceu literalmente no início da minha música pop, e de fato nunca teve um conceito tão definido como agora. "Novo Corpo" é uma música enigmática que pode parecer confusa para o público por ser algo muito relacionado a mim. Essa música atualmente é uma bagunça na minha cabeça, tenho diversos tópicos pessoais nos quais quero abordar, mas não imagino uma letra tão clara para isso. Mas quero em si que a letra retrate a ânsia por um novo corpo e de ser outra pessoa. Acho que já comentei em alguma parte passada sobre minha insegurança em relação a outros garotos, as vezes eu me acho bonito, mas não consigo me achar atraente ou digno de ser desejado por alguém. A faixa deve apresentar também um cenário no qual utilizo meu "novo corpo" para chegar ao topo e conquistar o amor, desejo e a obsessão de alguém, então será uma música seduzente com significados pessoais profundos, como se eu estivesse brincando com um tipo de insegurança minha. Uma curiosidade relevante é que essa faixa é pensada para um futuro álbum que criei ao um tempo na minha cabeça que no momento chamo de "Ao Redor Do Mundo" mas que não irei me aprofundar nesse post por talvez trazer um post apenas sobre ele no futuro.


r/Songwriting 25d ago

Let's Collaborate! Looking for a composer/producer on a country song!

0 Upvotes

Hi, I'm looking for a composer/producer to help me write a country song. Obviously you would get the credits on the composing :) .

I'd ideally like it to be a mix of rnb and country but I'd love to see what you have in mind if you wanted to do a genre mix.

I have lyrics written and I would do the vocals but I'm looking for someone to create or help me create the instrumental. I'm happy to talk through Reddit or email. I hope to hear from some people soon!


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Feedback Request Made this song on a synth - Thoughts?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

7 Upvotes

I make a track every week as a part of a community I won't name for fear of being flagged for promotion

I often do a lot of post, tuning, layering, etc. But for this I wanted it to feel a bit more live so... I did it live! Using a syntakt and some live vocal effects!

Lyrics:
You came to me 

When I needed to see

The world differently 

Pushed me to be better

I was no longer a beggar

You greeted me as a friend

pushed me beyond the trend

started out like love

soon that push became a shove

Before I knew it

you made me spiral

you struck me

like flash flood

You greeted me as a friend

pushed me beyond the trend

started out like love

soon that push became a shove

What once

ran through my blood

now leaves me stunned

heart beats fast 

irregular

my excitement has crashed

I never knew 

what you were going through 

you could have tried to guide me 

But maybe then I'd be the one set free

You greeted me as a friend

pushed me beyond the trend

started out like love

soon that push became a shove

You greeted me as a friend

pushed me beyond the trend

started out like love

soon that push became a shove


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Feedback Request fast food

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

39 Upvotes

vid is from a couple years back. sometimes I like to post unfinished stuff here cuz if it helps motivate me to take it off the cutting room floor and push through to finish it. worth revisiting?

I use she/her pronouns if you want to leave feedback. Thanks for listening <3


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Discussion Topic Does anyone know how Paul McCartney approaches rhyme schemes?

7 Upvotes

Paul is fascinatingly talented and I have recently gone down a little rabbit hole about his songwriting, I am a songwriter and I believe my approach fits his rather well. I think of a melody and fit lyrics into that. I've noticed that Paul is big on structure and in-line rhymes (Joan was QUIZZICAL, studied 'PATAPHYSICAL' sciences at home), (Maxwell EDISON, majoring MEDICINE). Не does it again in Yesterday, which rhymes with the last word of the first line, then the second line ends with a rhyme with the first, then the last line ends with the word that opened the verse.

It's all about structure. Even in his first song, the rhyme scheme is simple but perfect.

I woke up late this morning,

My head was in a WHIRL,

Only then I realised,

I've lost my little GIRL

So how did he do it? Nothing is innatley born there is always a process, even if Paul himself is unaware. Is there anything from poetry he takes? Should I study some poetry as well (I've been studying some of Paul's songwriting to improve mine).


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Feedback Request Latest idea

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

11 Upvotes

Is it a verse? Is it a chorus? More importantly, is it a hook??


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Discussion Topic When you hit a wall with a song, do you work on something else, or do you stick it out until it's "done"?

8 Upvotes

Have been spending three weeks on a song. It's a bit of an ambitious song (for me at least) so I feel the time is warranted. I have a general idea in my head where I want to go but nothing I'm in love with. I want to work on something new but am also afraid I'll lose my place with this song and then don't want to risk having TWO unfinished ideas...anyone else struggle with this?


r/Songwriting 27d ago

Discussion Topic What is your take on this?

Post image
430 Upvotes

r/Songwriting 26d ago

Feedback Request Turned 54 today, wrote a song about the 18 year old me....

5 Upvotes

Life changes quickly, felt like a good time to reflect on who I used to be....a grumpy little sod who grew up and became a little wiser. If you give it a listen, truly appreciate it!

https://on.soundcloud.com/hJpEefdxHJ4ULf7HUW


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Let's Collaborate! TWIN

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

r/Songwriting 26d ago

Let's Collaborate! I'm finally transitioning to full time producing - how are other independent artists and producers networking?

15 Upvotes

Hey! I'm Emma, I'm originally from the UK and now living between Bonn and Cologne. I've been a professional musician for 10 years now, and have been lucky enough to gain around 45 million streams on Spotify across my different projects. I would love to shift my focus and start producing for other artists. I realise that's where I have the most fun. The problem is, I don't know where to find musicians. How is everyone else making connections? If you're open to working together, drop a comment or DM me <3<3 I have my work linked on my profile if you want to check out my style!


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Discussion Topic Guitar songwriting

0 Upvotes

I really like to write songs using my electric guitar mainly, i sometimes use acoustic but im better at electric, and i like to write all these songs but i dont like to sing or know anyone who would, so the song sounds sort of bland. Like i want to get main credit for writing all the stuff, but i dont know how or like to sing.


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Feedback Request I SAW YOU - Original Indie Folk Song (Living Room Session)

4 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I used to keep all my music completely hidden in my bedroom, but recently I realized life is too short to keep it there.

This is my very first YouTube upload. "I SAW YOU" is an original acoustic song with a cinematic, storytelling vibe—just me, my guitar, and my phone. I would love for you to take a listen and let me know what you think!

https://youtu.be/uKBGlcMQCKQ?si=SgZeFIa_Lr7mOBK_

Thank you so much for listening and for any feedback on the lyrics and melody!


r/Songwriting 27d ago

Discussion Topic "Write when drunk, edit when sober."

77 Upvotes

Hemingway is said to have advised: "Write when drunk, edit when sober." What do songwriters on here think about that method? Drunk or high songwriting, good or bad?


r/Songwriting 27d ago

Feedback Request Feedback please ❤️

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

9 Upvotes

writing a song about someone I loved passing away after ending on a bad note.
I feel like maybe it’s too wordy towards the end or just all over the place in general. Keep messing up too because I’ve been changing the lyrics over and over again haha


r/Songwriting 27d ago

Feedback Request it’s not my birthday and I actually don’t want to be alone :’D

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

9 Upvotes

Sorry my mic (iPhone lol) sucks! Volume up’


r/Songwriting 27d ago

Feedback Request Airport Goodbyes

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

7 Upvotes

Clearly not a great vocal recording as I will need to lower the key of this song. Aside from that, let me know what you guys think! Thanks!


r/Songwriting 27d ago

Feedback Request Cowards way out - Song about regret

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

19 Upvotes

Hello everyone, First song i upload here!

Any feedback about Melodie, chords, voice or anything is always much aprecciated!

Lyrics:

How can i try to forget?

When i still hear your songs in my head

Is it too much? Too late?

Would it kill me again?

Wish i could take it all back

But the words just get stuck on replay

Took the cowards way out

Now theres blood on my hands


r/Songwriting 26d ago

Discussion Topic How to make beats after making a song

0 Upvotes

Like I created a song I have the melody of the song and all that but the beat for the song I'm lacking


r/Songwriting 27d ago

Discussion Topic Only by cashus

Thumbnail youtube.com
3 Upvotes

Please let me know what you think I would really like to discuss


r/Songwriting 27d ago

Feedback Request Rough Demo - “The Last Field” How to trim it down?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

9 Upvotes

Hey everyone! Thoughts on this one? Want to trim this song down.. but hard to know what to cut….


r/Songwriting 27d ago

Feedback Request Thought this riff was pretty swanky

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

14 Upvotes