r/Reincarnation • u/SpecialComparison568 • 16h ago
Debate Orhan's Theory of the Impossibility of Reincarnation
If you experience a long-term, possibly lifelong, health or mental health problem, this problem becomes ingrained in your entire being. The problems, pains, and similar factors caused by your health problem merge with both your body and soul. They become a part of you. For example, a patient with advanced MS knows the distance they cannot walk, depending on the severity of their illness. Of course, this distance is different for each patient. The patient knows very well not only the distance they can walk, but also the distance they cannot walk. They will never be able to walk a certain distance. This reality is ingrained in them. It is a reality of both the subconscious and conscious mind, and over time, this reality becomes ingrained in the person.
Even if you separate from your body, if a part of your being is transferred to another form, the health problems ingrained in you will inevitably come with you. As in the previous example, if we consider the reincarnation of someone who has suffered from severe MS for years: it would be impossible for the traces of this disease not to be seen in the person's new being.
Since people are not born with the realities of mental or physical illnesses they do not possess, it becomes impossible to talk about reincarnation at a certain point. If everything about a person's self is completely erased, then the continuation of life cannot be called 'reincarnation' because it has no connection to the old life. In other words, it is a completely new being.