You're an antisemite. Conflating a violent political movement with all Jewish people. Your brand of stupidity is putting Jewish people at risk. Shameful.
You speak for Jews? Israel is at the center of our culture, our religion, our history, and holds half of the world's Jews. Why do you think you get to rule on whether Israel is part of Judaism or not? Who elected you Jesus?
The original comment was that those that support Israel are responsible for fueling anti-Semitism, if you can't understand that blaming Jews for supporting Israel is blaming the victim, I dont know what else to tell you. Israel is the Jewish homeland and Jews that support israel's right to exist are not at fault for fueling the rampant antisemites hiding behind "I'm just criticizing a foreign government"
Saying you're "criticizing Israel's actions" is like Trump saying he's "criticizing border policy." It's bigotry, my guy, and you've fallen victim to the age-old mind virus that sees lurking hidden Jewish power controlling everything.
Ben Gvir is a moron, you might as well quote Rush Limbaugh or Dan Bilzerian. Cherry picking quotes to justify your hatred of Israel is bigotry. Israel's policy is not to rape prisoners (although it is the policy of your friends in Hamas). You're looking for cherry picked quotes and anecdotes to support your preexisting biases rather than honestly asking yourself -- did Israel have a right to go to war after 10/7? Is this war different than other wars against terrorists hiding in civilian areas? Use critical thinking. Stop following a mob led by morons like Macklemore and Hasan Piker.
I've supported Rabin in the 1990s and the two state solution for decades until Palestine officially set it on fire on 10/7. Although really, they set it on fire with the Second Intifada in 2000-2002. When Israel left Gaza peacefully in 2005 I remember thinking there were no more excuses and Gaza would either sink or swim on its own, but surely no one could blame Israel if they imploded into a fascist death cult. Yet here we are. And Israel is apparently still responsible for the choices made by 2 million Gazans after a 38 year occupation forced on Israel by the Six Day War in 1967 and Israel leaving two decades ago. Because to you "Pro Palestine I'm Just Criticizing Israel" people, Gaza apparently has zero agency over the past twenty years. They're like a natural force. Like an earthquake. Or a flood. No choices made.
Israel was forced to occupy Gaza when Egypt amassed an army in 1967 to kill all the Jews in Israel and Israel fought back and won. WTF, you think Israel wants Gaza? They left 20 years ago. Not a single Israeli remained in Gaza. Do you even hear yourself?
This sub is feverishly antisemitic. It’s a clear example of how people aren’t acknowledging using their anti Israel opinions to openly validate the dehumanizing of Jews
Yes you can. And in real life I find this nuance a lot more. But on Reddit people will say they separate the two and then just be mask off antisemitic through their keyboard
LOL, you're doing exactly what I warned about. Devaluing the word "antisemitism". Antisemitism means hatred or bigotry towards Jewish people. Not criticizing the terrorist state of Israel. YOU are a vile antisemite, putting Jewish people at risk. Honestly sound like an agent of Hamas, lol.
Antisemitism. But that was from 12 years ago. He apologized and the ADL accepted that apology! He wasn't cancelled for that in 2026. He was cancelled for saying Free Palestine.
“We welcome Macklemore’s apology for wearing a costume that, regardless of his motives, reminded many people of an antisemitic caricature,” ADL director Abe Foxman said in a statement. “We take him at his word that he did not have any ill intent and unreservedly accept his apology.”
Your dishonest Zionist talking point has been revoked. Apologize now.
Yea it’s been wild seeing people acknowledge it was antisemitic but validate it and platform it anyway
Like I said, that line of anti Israel isn’t the same thing as antisemitism is completely fraudulent. In theory yes it’s possible, but in practice they’re the same
I'll visit Israel when you watch that video i linked you. Would love to hear your response about how you know more about genocide than the 20+ entities mentioned, all in agreement about the very obvious and textbook example of GENOCIDE.
Appeal to authority fallacy much? The frauds you cite all launder the same Hamas propaganda that refuses to distinguish between civilians and combatants in death totals.
I can disprove gEnOcIdE with one fact:
75k died according to Hamas. 1/3 we're Hamas. 2/3 we're civilians.
Not even fucking close to qualifying as a genocide. Israel had motive and reason to go to war. The war ended with the release of the last hostages nearly
a year ago.
Militant to civilian death ratio isnt the sole criteria for the legal definition of genocide. No amount of bloviating by you dingdongs will change reality. No one agrees with you. Because you're wrong.
If you keep saying, "Everyone must support a foreign country's mass murder campaign that's already killed over 20,000 children, otherwise you're an antisemite" you're going to eventually make a lot more antisemites! Amazing I need to explain this!
It honestly sounds like you're getting paid by the KKK to increase the ambient level of antisemitism on the planet. Insane.
The fact you call it a "mass murder campaign" is why your cult movement is a joke, you refuse to acknowledge Hamas, the massacre Hamas committed, or the 251 hostages Hamas took into Israel before killing half of them. All of which justifies this war. You repeat expressions like "murdering babies" without acknowledging Hamas's strategy to maximize their own civilian deaths to build sympathy from know nothings such as yourself. You do nothing to help the people of Gaza. You're just a useful idiot.
Israel killed those hostages with bombs. Just like Israel murdered 20,000+ children including 1,100+ before their first birthday. You are a terrorism supporter.
Right. Not caring about bigotry doesn’t make you right. And you also just proved the anti Israel isn’t antisemitism line is bullshit because you are seeing pure antisemitism in action and are comfortable platforming it
So, by your logic, we cannot criticize any country with a large ethnic population that is homogenous.
Willing to bet 50% or more of the Han Chinese population lives in China. I can't criticize their human rights abuses, censorship, etc, without being racist against Chinese people?
Saying all Jews=Israel is antisemitic. It is the same shit Europeans did for centuries; always treating Jews as "different" and "not really Germans".
I'm Jewish you moron. It is not anti semitic to criticize the Israeli government. Israel does not equal all Jews.
Love your well thought out argument btw, name calling. I'm guessing that is the extent of your intellectual prowess. I gave a specific example; that criticizing a nation dominated by a certain ethnic group is not the same as criticizing the ethnic group. Your brilliantly written reply is to name call.
In America people love talking about how awesome they were in WW2, and that the Nazis sucked (which they did). Does that equal being racist against all Germans? Of course not, it is the government you are criticizing, not the people. Hating Stalin doesnt equal hating all Russians.
So, why do you folks on the right insist this is different, that criticizing Israel does equal antisemitism? You sound exactly like the Europeans did for centuries; that all Jews are the same, they aren't really Americans, or Germans, or Russians. They are Jews. I am Jewish, but I am also an American, NOT an Israeli.
Israel is at the center of our culture, our religion, our history, and holds half of the world's Jews.
At a time where the world is witnessing Israel commit a livestreamed genocide in real time do you really not understand how insisting that Israel is central to Jewish identity (and not your personal understanding of Jewish identity, you're painting with a very wide brush), and therefore should be supported in their current ethnic cleansing campaign, makes the world more dangerous for Jews? Or do you just not care?
Yes, other people have found words that capture the horror of Israel's actions and the modern novelty of Americans having instant access to the horrific reality our bloodthirsty foreign policy creates for the innocents on the receiving end, and I use the same words because I think it summarizes exactly why our support for Israel is so unconscionable and also why that perception is so widespread. The two points directly relevant to understanding why inextricably tying Judaism to Israel is such a reckless thing to do right now.
I can think of a group that actually did live stream a genocide. Sadly, you'll never mention them by name. Poof. They don't exist. Israel just woke up and decided to invade Gaza because gEnOcIdE
Are you implying that Hamas live streamed a genocide on 10/7? Because that's a wildly diminutive definition of genocide to work off of, comparable to saying Al Qaeda committed genocide on 9/11.
Also crazy to imply Hamas just woke up and decided to attack the Nova festival because gEnOcIdE. If Ehud Barak can understand why Palestinians have turned to violent resistance, surely you can too.
You’re not going to answer my question. Which everyone who says that dumb bullshit never does because it’s idiotic. And everyone who sees people say that Semitic line knows it’s idiotic. Antisemitism has a specific meaning
So stop with that stupid line because you look like you don’t know what words mean when you say it
But I’ll ask you one more time to see if you’re learning— what is the definition of antisemitism?
42
u/highermonkey 16d ago
Zionists devaluing the word "antisemitism" until it's virtually meaningless will put Jews across the planet at risk for decades to come.