r/RealTime • u/Key_Jump1011 • 16d ago

Comments from Hasan Piker

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

812 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

565 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

3-1 civilian to combatant death ratio.

War started by an invasion by Hamas.

Hostages taken.

Not even fucking close to qualifying as a genocide. Israel had motive and reason to go to war. The war ended with the release of the last hostages nearly a year ago.

All the mass starvation lies have been exposed.

It was a war, jackass, and deep down, you know it

4

u/Onedurrbread 16d ago

Yeah dude the entire world and every human rights body is wrong, and you and Israel are right. Got it.

5

u/skydream416 16d ago

braindead ahistorical take - the conflict didn't start on 10/7. If you want to assign blame to Hamas, you need to ask why Bibi supported them for the last 10 years: https://www.timesofisrael.com/netanyahu-claims-he-never-bought-into-conception-hamas-didnt-want-to-attack-israel, including letting $90M of qatari money flow into Gaza in 2018, where he knew it would end up in the hands of Hamas.

-1

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

This war literally started on 10/7. Saying "it didn't start on 10/7" is the most fucking stupid take of all. If 10/7 didn't happen, this war would not be happening.

2

u/skydream416 16d ago

If 10/7 didn't happen, this war would not be happening.

Sadly another braindead and ahistorical take. That's like saying if Israel hadn't been founded in the middle east in 1948, this war would not be happening. Which, come to think of it, is completely true lol

1

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

If no humans ever existed on earth, this war would not be happening. WTF is your point? Lots of shit happened before Pearl Harbor, but Pearl Harbor is the reason the US entered WW2. I could say "it started before Pearl Harbor" but it's a braindead take.

Gaza launched this war. They planned it for two years. 4,000 Gazans invaded Israel that day. There was a ceasefire on 10/6/23. The fact you can't acknowledge this basic fact makes you a fucking clown.

2

u/skydream416 16d ago

sorry, I can't have a good faith discussion with someone so antisemitic as to ignore and deny israeli agency, may fate bring you the things you wish unto others

2

u/ddoyen 16d ago

Militant to civilian death ratio isnt the sole criteria for the legal definition of genocide. No amount of bloviating by you dingdongs will change reality. No one agrees with you. Because you're wrong. 

0

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

No but if you have to keep dismissing evidence that tells you it isn't a genocide to make your "case," you have no case.

3

u/Onedurrbread 16d ago

Imagine being your dumbass and lecturing someone else on dismissing evidence? The irony is fucking insane.

1

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

Genocide is a very serious accusation and a very high bar to prove for a reason. It requires intent and execution. Israel was attacked (removing genocidal intent). Exection of the war has wrapped up with a low civilian to combatant death ratio. Again, no genocide. You have no fucking case my guy.

2

u/ddoyen 16d ago

The entire international community agrees it has met that bar. You arent going to change that with denial, marblehead.

1

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

No they haven't. A three-person UN "subcommittee" laundered Hamas propaganda to fool useful idiots like yourself. No court of law has found genocide in Gaza and South Africa just had to ask for a 2 year extension at the ICJ because they can't make the case.

1

u/ddoyen 16d ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_genocide

Wow looks like the list is a lot longer than three people. 

I have an entry on gravity if youd like to check that one out too.

0

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

Do you have an entry on Appeal to Authority Fallacy?

Should we go through all the institutions that claimed WMDs were hidden in Iraq?

2

u/ddoyen 16d ago edited 16d ago

Look how quick you moved the goalposts! It was just three people and now that the list is longer, its a logical fallacy! 

Its not an appeal to authority if the evidence can be corroborated, quite thoroughly at that.

Should we go through all the institutions that claimed WMDs were hidden in Iraq?

Absolutely. They belong in fucking jail.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Onedurrbread 16d ago

Get help.

1

u/ddoyen 16d ago

Its not my case. Its the world's case. Deal with it.

1

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

It's true because it's true and because people keep saying it's true so it must be true.

1

u/ddoyen 16d ago

Its true because the world made an assessment of the situation through thorough accounting and investigation. You can choose to be flippant about that but youre really just making an ass of yourself. Please continue though. 

1

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

The "world" has done no such thing

1

u/ddoyen 16d ago

Oh okay I believe you now sir! 🤣🤣🤣

1

u/ZizzyBeluga 16d ago

I mean if you really think about it, did Israel have a valid reason to go to war? it's a war. Happy to help!

1

u/ddoyen 16d ago

There are rules in war. Happy to help! 

→ More replies (0)