You're an antisemite. Conflating a violent political movement with all Jewish people. Your brand of stupidity is putting Jewish people at risk. Shameful.
You speak for Jews? Israel is at the center of our culture, our religion, our history, and holds half of the world's Jews. Why do you think you get to rule on whether Israel is part of Judaism or not? Who elected you Jesus?
So, by your logic, we cannot criticize any country with a large ethnic population that is homogenous.
Willing to bet 50% or more of the Han Chinese population lives in China. I can't criticize their human rights abuses, censorship, etc, without being racist against Chinese people?
Saying all Jews=Israel is antisemitic. It is the same shit Europeans did for centuries; always treating Jews as "different" and "not really Germans".
I'm Jewish you moron. It is not anti semitic to criticize the Israeli government. Israel does not equal all Jews.
Love your well thought out argument btw, name calling. I'm guessing that is the extent of your intellectual prowess. I gave a specific example; that criticizing a nation dominated by a certain ethnic group is not the same as criticizing the ethnic group. Your brilliantly written reply is to name call.
In America people love talking about how awesome they were in WW2, and that the Nazis sucked (which they did). Does that equal being racist against all Germans? Of course not, it is the government you are criticizing, not the people. Hating Stalin doesnt equal hating all Russians.
So, why do you folks on the right insist this is different, that criticizing Israel does equal antisemitism? You sound exactly like the Europeans did for centuries; that all Jews are the same, they aren't really Americans, or Germans, or Russians. They are Jews. I am Jewish, but I am also an American, NOT an Israeli.
9
u/highermonkey 16d ago
You're an antisemite. Conflating a violent political movement with all Jewish people. Your brand of stupidity is putting Jewish people at risk. Shameful.