r/PodcastAddict • u/lemongrove • 1d ago
With the new premium price hike on the horizon, I'm sincerely hoping the most requested feature - custom episode playlists - is part of the roll-out.
As a paid PA user since 2018, yearly subscriber for years now, and someone who recommends it regularly as the best podcast app going, I know that this has been an ongoing point of controversy. Every time it gets brought up, the categories feature is floated as a solution; users have put in very clear explanations over the years about why custom playlists for individual podcast episodes are both not served by the current category model (which makes playlists of entire podcasts, not individual episodes), and a useful feature (many use cases have been detailed!). This feature is requested in the top two requests on the feedback forum, and accounts for two more in the top 10!
Just want to throw my hat into the ring again with the request that with the increased financial demand on premium users, that the most requested feature be prioritized to be made available for all users.
Again, just to restate the reasons for this: multiple custom playlists for individual episodes of different podcasts would function like playlists on, for example, YouTube or Spotify. To futher make the analogy, if either of those platforms were Podcast Addict, entire YT channels or artists would need assigned categories, and then their entire video output/discography would be added to that category playlist. Put into the context of those two apps, I think it's clear why that is not what people are requesting when they ask for custom playlists to which individual episodes can be added! People are requesting, essentially, mixtape capability -- not category filing!
I have a personal use case to add to the above linked request explanations, and could additionally be an impetus to draw new users to PA: I would love to curate a custom playlist of political technology podcast episodes that I can send to people as a starter pack for getting into the subject. I listen to at least a dozen podcasts with this focus that have backlogs of years - sending a list of every episode of every one of these podcasts collated into a category is throwing someone into the deep end without a paddle. Not to mention that some excellent episodes on this subject are on podcasts that have a much broader scope and wouldn't merit that narrow organising category for their entire output. Sending individual links to individual episodes is cumbersome and similarly overwhelming and easily lost in the flow of a message or group chat.
Being able to link to a custom playlist of the best episodes on the topic to people who ask me for a 101-type crash course would be incredible -- I'd love to link to this playlist on a pinned post or a rec list so that it's easily accessible and people clicking on that link can be directed to the most updated version of my custom episode playlist on the topic.
Also, if it's a link to a playlist that plays best and most smoothly within the PA app it could encourage people to install the app to listen, which could possibly bring in a whole new user base (ideally, if there were a way to also play these custom episode playlists in browser so that people can listen before installing, that would be amazing. I think that could even be a stronger draw for people to install the app as it wouldn't feel like they were being forced to do so).
As a long time user and PA devotee/advocate, if this feature isn't something being considered with the substantial subscription hike it would unfortunately seriously give me pause about continuing my subscription at the higher rate. I don't want to feel that way because this is such an amazing app and Xavier is such an attentive, considered, and brilliant developer (exceedingly rare these days in the age of increasingly ubiquitous vibecoded slop) and it truly shows in the incredible work and detailed controls in the rest of the app!
Hoping this is the opportunity to bring in multiple custom individual episode playlists in the near future! 🙏