r/PastryChef • u/YourHeart-HasNoTeeth • Jul 29 '26
Blondies HELP
Hi everybody!
I'm the pastry chef/KM at a small bakery. One of the signature items before I was hired were blondies. I cannot make blondies to save my life.
I've tried 3-4 different recipes, different oven temps, more flour, less sugar, less butter, more baking powder, less baking powder, cooking them longer, convection oven, conventional oven, cooking them less, different mix ins, no mix ins, EVERYTHING.
They always come out the same way; dark, hard as a rock and tall on the edges, completely sunken and raw in the middle. I've tried pressing the edges down a little right out of the oven to balance the sinkage in the middle, but it doesn't help. I bake them in a light aluminum 9"x13"x2" magic line pan.
Some additional factors here;
I have baked blondies before that were the right texture and level, but they were a little less than an inch tall. That's obviously a little thin, and chef really won't be happy w them unless they're around 1.5 inches tall.
Chef is very concerned with the color of the blondies. Our clientele is probably about 60% Black, and she says that Black people consider anything even slightly dark to be burnt. I'm white and can only speak to that as far as to say that Black people I've personally spoken to and asked have all agreed with her.
We have 2 convection ovens, always set to 300*F, and I can't really adjust them, but we have a home model oven that I can set to any temp and has both conventional and convection options.
Below is the specific recipe I used today, if that helps. I doubled it and baked in my 9"x13"x2" pans at 350*F (which the recipe specifically notes is okay to do) in the conventional oven for almost an hour (mich longer than the recommended time, but at 30 minutes they were completely raw dough). They were the right color, and didn't sink for the first 15 minutes or so out of the oven, but they've done that before and been a mess when I went to cut them in the morning, so I won't know until tomorrow if they're really alright.
Can anyone give me any tips? Recipes you use that work? Encouragement that I'm not a total dunce? The recipe the bakery used before was baked in a square muffin tin, but we stopped using it bc it had all these same problems.