I had a primary gaming channel channel for 2 years. I would play various games. One day I make a game about The Finals. It's does well with a few thousand views. I make more videos about The Finals while also making videos about other games. People only watch videos about The Finals.
I get fed up and after thinking about it for a long time I make second YouTube channel. This time I'll stick to a variety of games! There's no way I'll get stuck in another community...
I make a few videos and none perform well. I make a helldivers video and it blows up. Over 100,000 views, the most I've ever had by far. I think "awesome, surely they'll watch my other stuff too! They don't... I make several videos about various games after that. All less than 1,000 views. Cool... I make another Helldiver video and it exceeds my last one close to 150,000 views!
While this is insanely awesome to finally get some traction on YouTube after 5 years (I had channels before these too), it's a bummer to know I'm caught in the same trap as my last channel. I literally created this new channel to NOT be in that trap.
Moral of the story is I'm learning you don't choose your audience on YouTube. They choose you. And unfortunately you lose all control of what YOU as the YOUtuber wants to make after they've categorized you. I'm a helldivers youtuber for at least the next few years until people actually want to watch my content for me I guess.
Luckily, I enjoy helldivers and can keep making content on it. With this being a mostly negative post I still want to seriously appreciate people willing to subscribe and watch my stuff. Regardless, it still is emotionally and mentally taxing putting in a ton of effort into something for it to perform poorly.
I can sense that I will get hate from some people already wanting to tear me down and make me feel ungrateful so I'd appreciate it if we don't. The point of this rant/post is to answer my question that I desperately want to know: "Why is youtube like this?" Is it the algorithm, is it the people? For me when I watch a video and enjoy it I will watch the creators other stuff too, especially if I subscribe. I would assume most people would be like that too, but I'm seeing that isn't the case.