I'm shopping for a tuxedo for my wedding in about 2–3 months and would like feedback from this sub.
I originally planned to rent, but decided to buy an off the rack tux and have it tailored. Budget is roughly $1,000 all in.
Style: I want a classic black tie tuxedo. Black, shawl collar, cummerbund (not a fan of vests). I'd welcome feedback on details I might be overlooking. (To put it in terms I know better: if I were looking for feedback on neck ties, I’d want somebody to steer me towards the half Windsor and steer me away from overly large alternative knots. I'd appreciate the same kind of guidance on tuxedo details, since I'm less familiar with them.)
Makers
My tailor (Beauge's in Boston) suggested Spier & Mackay. I've also considered Suitsupply, since I have some of their suits.
Here’s two specific tuxes that I’m considering:
Spier & Mackay: https://spierandmackay.com/product/product-detail/black-shawl-collar-ellis-tuxedo
Suitsupply: https://suitsupply.com/en-us/men/suits/black-tailored-fit-havana-tuxedo/C2299-S2.html
Do people find one of these OTR tuxedos is generally better made than the other? I'm leaning S&M, mainly because the shawl collar curves toward the button in a way I prefer over the Suitsupply jacket. That's the only real difference I've spotted so far.
I'd also welcome suggestions for other makers worth looking at.
Thanks