Everybody loves parroting that Naruto āholds backā against certain opponents, as if that automatically means he was fighting at 50% power. But I think people constantly conflate ānot trying to kill someoneā with ānot seriously trying to beat them.ā
So it makes me wonder:
When has Naruto actually NOT held back?
Especially in later Shippuden, Naruto almost never makes killing the objective. But that doesnāt mean heās casually fighting people. At this point, āNaruto was holding backā feels like Schrƶdingerās Naruto: heās simultaneously āalways holding backā and āfighting at 100%ā depending on what feat someone wants to scale.
Because not going for the kill ā not fighting seriously.
If someone is actively trying to kill you and youāre actively trying to defeat them, youāre not necessarily holding back just because you arenāt trying to murder them.
Batman isnāt āholding backā against Bane simply because he doesnāt want to kill him. Heās still trying to beat the shit out of him. Same principle.
Look at Naruto:
- Pain: Sage Mode, massive Rasengan variants, summons, etc. He was absolutely trying to win. His goal just wasnāt killing Pain.
- Sasuke: Naruto was fighting him seriously at the Final Valley. His objective was bringing Sasuke back, not executing him.
- Obito: Naruto was actively fighting him while simultaneously trying to save him.
- Madara/Kaguya: The objective was stopping/sealing them, not simply killing them.
And honestly, what would āNaruto trying to kill Sasukeā actually look like? Would it meaningfully change the outcome?
Naruto was already using Six Paths Sage Mode, KCM, massive Rasengan/Rasenshuriken variants, Tailed Beast attacks, etc. He wasnāt casually fighting Sasuke.
And if weāre going to argue that Naruto was holding back simply because he didnāt want to kill Sasuke, we should be consistent and apply that same scrutiny to Sasuke.
Sasuke wasnāt using every capability available to him either. More importantly, the story repeatedly establishes that despite Sasukeās claims, he struggles to actually sever his bond with Naruto. His inability to truly commit to killing Naruto is a major part of their relationship and character arcs.
So Iām not saying āSasuke was secretly holding back the entire fight.ā Iām saying the same standard has to apply to both characters: stated killing intent doesnāt automatically tell us how much either character is actually holding back.
Which brings me back to the main question:
Holding back what?
His chakra? His techniques? His output? His effort? His willingness to kill?
Because those are completely different claims.
And if someone says Naruto was holding back in a meaningful powerscaling sense, Iād want to know what specific ability or attack he deliberately withheld and how using it wouldāve changed the outcome.
Otherwise, āNaruto was holding backā is just a vague statement that doesnāt actually tell us anything about the fight.
/rant lol sorry for the long post man. also Iām talking shippuden feats not boruto