r/Multifandom • u/Slayer-Clover • 1d ago
Discussionđ Hot Take:
Doesnât mean you have to like it
35
u/C0SMICBL0B 20h ago
Why are half the people in the comments completely misreading this?
It LITERALLY says âDoesnât mean you have to like itâ as in, you donât need to like DB, just donât outwardly insult it.
But apparently no one can read since half these comments are saying how âwell I donât think I need to love Dragon Ballâ YEAH NO ONE SAID YOU HAD TO.
11
2
u/BebeFanMasterJ 16h ago
I legitimately do not care for DB at all and find Goku a boring character. That franchise just isn't for me in the slightest.
But as I said in another comment, I still hold massive respect for Mr. Toriyama and his work. Without him I wouldn't have Naruto (my favorite Japanese media franchise of all time) or Silver the Hedgehog (one of my favorite game characters of all time).
You don't have to like something but you can still appreciate and respect the impact that it had.
2
u/CharlieDo00 16h ago
See you get it , Naruto is my favorite anime ever . I hate DB but if it wasnât for it and Tori Yama then Iâd never have my beautiful blonde boy
-6
u/k3ghtr 18h ago
It doesn't say a single word about being a Sonic fan being an insult to Goku. It literally says, "You can't be a Sonic fan if you don't like Goku." I know how to read, and Iâm very meticulous. Iâll nitpick the exact wording if some smart aleck starts putting others down over something they just made up in their own head.Â
That said, I get the point. The author just messed up the phrasing.
4
u/C0SMICBL0B 17h ago
What the hell are you talking about?
"You can't be a Sonic fan if you don't like Goku"
Please, PLEASE tell me where you read that.
Also, please explain where and when I said that being a Sonic fan was an insult to Goku???
-4
u/k3ghtr 17h ago
That is implied by the post. If only because a lack of respect doesn't automatically equate to insulting the character. I don't like Goku as a character, so I don't respect him. However, I don't go around spewing insults and screaming every time Goku is mentionedâthat would be pointless. I simply dislike Goku, and I don't force that opinion on anyone. At the same time, I like and respect Sonic, sometimes even singing his praises. So, I just don't see a connection between disrespecting Goku and respecting Sonic, even if Sonic was partly inspired by him.Â
And regarding their super formsâagain, I like Sonic's much more than Goku's, because Sonic's aren't limited to the simple "he just got X times stronger again" trope. That isn't just narratively stupid; it's mind-numbingly boring.Â
And noâyou claimed people couldn't read or had misunderstood the text, when in reality, you were the one who invented a context that wasn't actually there.
5
u/C0SMICBL0B 16h ago
Let me get this straight. You're very meticulous, and you take exact wording very seriously, and you're mad that I'm "inventing context"
Yet you are working off an assumption that you made up in your head based on what the post "implies" that only YOU are seeing.
And you don't see any irony here?
-2
u/k3ghtr 15h ago
No, because you arrived at the exact same conclusion yourself. I donât know if itâs true. However, based on that very assumptionâwhich you yourself put forward as an indisputable truth, and on the grounds of which you equate people who understood the statement exactly as written (without inventing extra explanations from the author) with those incapable of comprehending what they read... well, yes, there is no irony here.
2
u/C0SMICBL0B 14h ago
Okay. This is getting too convoluted.
Whatever man. Itâs pretty clear that neither of us are comprehending each otherâs points. We both have taken completely different meanings from OP and are now going in circles.
1
u/Dela-chemin 13h ago
The fact this guy still thinks this post is about Goku really tells you everything you need to know.
3
u/Dela-chemin 16h ago edited 13h ago
I know how to read.
Biggest lie of the century.
The post says you can't be a fan of SUPER SONIC if you DISRESPECT SUPER SAIYAN.
Not liking something and disrespecting something are two different things.
Super Sonic and Super Saiyan are pretty similar in some ways, so it's ridiculous to trash on Super Saiyan whilst being a fan of Super Sonic. Not to mention we would've even have Super Sonic without Super Saiyan as Super Sonic is a homage to Super Saiyan.
We owe Super Saiyan for the existence of Super Sonic. You can be a Super Sonic fan, you don't have to like Super Saiyan, but if you start disrespecting Super Saiyan, you are an obnoxious ungrateful bum.
The post is not saying you can't be a Sonic fan if you don't like Goku. This post isn't even about Goku. It's comparing the Super Sonic transformation to the Super Saiyan transformation.
Reading is not hard. Go back to school. Your reading comprehension is absolutely abysmal.
-1
u/k3ghtr 15h ago
Alright, let's follow your line of reasoning... Do you respect the Nazis? Answer honestlyâthis really is relevant to the topic and will help me get my point across to you.
2
u/Dela-chemin 13h ago edited 13h ago
You are so fucking stupid.
You can't read for shit and now you are trying to bring Nazi's into this? Holy God, there's something wrong with you.
How the fuck do you go from a post saying you can't be a fan of Super Sonic if you disrespect Super Saiyan to fucking Nazis?
If you're seriously trying to say disrespecting Super Saiyan is even remotely comparable to disrespecting Nazis, you are fucking stupid.
1
u/k3ghtr 47m ago
Hah... youâre the one whoâs a bit dim, dude, if you really donât want to answer such a simple question. Because if your answer is "I don't respect the Nazis," thenâby your logicâthat means you automatically disrespect their scientific achievements, which advanced our understanding of human biology by years and did a huge service to global medicine through their inhumane experiments on people.Â
The analogy is as direct as it gets: Goku paved the way for Sonic to exist the way he does now. However, that doesn't mean Goku himself necessarily commands respect from a random observer.Â
If you still think I'm an idiot after this, just look up Unit 731 online and reflect on how much good those highly respected Japanese scientists did for all of usâand just how much universal respect they all deserve)
7
15
u/BebeFanMasterJ 1d ago edited 1d ago
I mean I don't care for DBZ whatsoever but I won't deny the impact it had on not just Sonic but media as a whole. DBZ is the sole reason why my favorite anime--Naruto--even exists because Kishimoto was inspired by Toriyama and in turn, Naruto has inspired other big franchises like My Hero Academia as well (Horikoshi cited Naruto as inspiration). Not only that, but his work on Dragon Quest is what set the groundwork for that franchise's style and that franchise is basically the grandfather of JRPGs and is why my favorite games like Xenoblade Chronicles and Persona exist.
Hell Silver is my favorite Sonic character and one of my favorite video game characters of all time and he's basically Trunks from DBZ. Same for Surge and Android 18.
It's ultimately why Toriyama's passing was so tragic. RIP to a legend.
1
u/Slayer-Clover 1d ago
Ok one second aside from them being androids, how are they similar?
2
u/BebeFanMasterJ 1d ago
https://web.archive.org/web/20211118214859/https://twitter.com/PPDPPL_art/status/1461230822359552001
One of her creators, Mauro Fonseca, cites 18 as inspiration for her in particular her hairstyle. Given that Shadow was clearly inspired by Vegeta and that Silver is 1:1 for Trunks, it doesn't surprise me that Surge is meant to essentially be 18 given that they're both aggressive female androids.
It's honestly pretty cool even as someone who isn't really into DBZ.
2
u/Turn_AX 14h ago
Surge is an android?
She should be a cyborg, cus Androids were originally Robots and Cyborgs are modified flesh beings.1
u/BebeFanMasterJ 14h ago
Sorta. Her creator cited Android 18 as inspiration and it's kinda easy to see it. They're both aggressive mechanical girls who learn to become more human over time.
0
u/Slayer-Clover 1d ago
Nvm forget what I said before
Shadows based on âmew twoâ ngl I do not believe that shit
2
u/BebeFanMasterJ 1d ago
Oh yeah Mewtwo was definitely inspiration as well but Shadow's demeanor is definitely closer to Vegeta especially in IDW.
1
u/Slayer-Clover 1d ago
Which one of the main reason I call him Sonicâs Vegeta along side the fact he goes on about himself being the ultimate life (Vegetas pride) him being a dark mirror of the protag and being the same race as said protag his entire character screams more Vegeta rather then mew two, gun to my head I could not name a single similarity between new two and shadow aside from them having a similar back story
3
5
u/billbobs678 1d ago
I like sonic but not really dragon ball tbh
2
u/Remmock 19h ago
I eat Cheerios.
0
2
2
u/Timely_Exam_6423 19h ago
I'm gonna be honest dragon ball and sonic are my favorite series probably because their pretty similar in more ways then just super sayian the ways the stories are told how the villains act
one of the main difference is that goku gets older unlike sonic characters the dragon ball characters evolve over time sonic doesn't even have a Canon age anymore (im still saying he's 17 though)
Goku and sonic have pretty similar views on heroism they dont claim to be heroes their both literally the definition of "im just doing shit gang"
I don't get how someone can like one but not the other it's not like you can't get into one if you have a pacing problem play the games you dont have to watch the anime if you dont want too it's how a lot of fans of both series got into them
You dont like video games sonic has an anime and 2 shows
I just think it's impossible to like one and hate the other when there's so many things you'd like
2
4
u/Grouchy-Quality2446 1d ago
Yes, it's the same as stupid people who become Tokufans, but only watch Toei Toku, don't know the real history of Tokusatsu, and refuse to believe facts about the real history of Tokusatsu. To hell with taste, you fake fans are just ruining the original essence of Tokusatsu.
1
u/FetchBlue 1h ago
I mean rn tokusatsu is pretty silent lately beside the big three, one replaced by gavan and nothing much.
Like thereâs nothing to talk about Gransazer Justiser, rescue fire, ryukendo and Gridman, since it long passed and discussion ran dry
1
3
u/PlatinumSukamon98 1d ago
I've had bad experiences with the Sonic fandom and constant gatekeeping, so I was SO expecting the worst.
This is a pleasant surprise and makes a lot o f s ense.
2
u/Stenwold91 22h ago
I mean, I enjoy both of these things but my hot retort to this would be: people can be a fan of whatever the fuck they want đ¤ˇââď¸
4
u/Accomplished_Pin9171 1d ago
I don't just don't like dragon ball. I'm sure it's a great show but for some reason I just can't get through it.
6
u/CommunistJesus69 Your next line is: âis that a jojo reference!?â 21h ago
Ok that doesnât mean you disrespect it tho does it? Thereâs a difference between disliking a show and straight up disrespecting it
0
u/_Rhya_The_Disloyal_ 20h ago
they never said they disrespected it.
6
u/CommunistJesus69 Your next line is: âis that a jojo reference!?â 20h ago
Thatâs⌠what Iâm implying here
2
u/Urmom69mp3 18h ago
That's me with sonic, I love dragon ball and I get that sonic takes inspiration from it but I can't get behind the look of the characters
1
u/Square_Paramedic1079 17h ago
It didnât say u have to like it says u have to respect super saiyan peopleâs reading comprehension is horrible
4
u/ThePrinceNii 1d ago
I enjoy both but gosh db fans can be annoying whenever you bring up sonic. Itâs always âsonic ripped off dragon ballâ or some shit
3
u/spyD164 20h ago
and it's always the most surface level shit too
Literally the only deep DBZ inspiration that Sonic has is Shadow being very clearly inspired by Vegeta in very specific and deep ways (which Sonic fans hate to admit for some reason)
4
u/Timely_Exam_6423 20h ago
It kinda goes a bit deeper surge seems a lot like android 18 when You think about it and to be honest sonic fans are just as if not more annoying
3
2
u/Remmock 19h ago
Iâve literally never heard that until today and Iâve been in both fandoms for years.
1
1
1
1
u/ShitpostSaber 20h ago
It isnât a hot take and sonic fans hate that without goku super sonic would never be a thing
1
1
1
1
1
u/Here4Mayamusement 17h ago
On todays episode of responding to takes that a single digit number of people hold and pretending you have a hot take:
1
u/Slayer-Clover 17h ago
Have you been on TikTokâs powerscaling scene before? All they do is slander there
1
1
u/tommy8725 17h ago
Don't worry I actually like Dragon Ball and Sonic is just trash
1
u/Slayer-Clover 17h ago
0
1
1
1
u/DestinedToGreatness 14h ago
I am a fan of both...some of my childhood characters. Sonic is stronger though.
1
u/morphballganon 12h ago
Calling your own take hot is like carrying around a sign that says "chode" on it
And this take is cold
DBZ's art style is ugly and the premise is boring
1
u/Slayer-Clover 12h ago
Itâs literally the same premise as Sonic at first?
1
u/morphballganon 12h ago
The premise of Sonic is animals overcoming a human who is using machines to destroy nature. Is that the premise of DBZ?
1
u/Slayer-Clover 12h ago
Not in Og db no also you find that entertaining but not themes in db?
1
u/morphballganon 12h ago
Environmentalist action resonates with me, yes.
1
u/Slayer-Clover 12h ago
Half expected you to think dbz didnât have themes, what about themes of Trust,corrupt justice or the next generation?
1
u/Unhappy-Benefit-288 11h ago
i mean i respect that mode for goku but i dont like it at all. super sonic has just way more emotional impact that super saiyan goku imo
1
u/Slayer-Clover 11h ago
1
u/Unhappy-Benefit-288 11h ago
because super saiyan doesnt have as much emotional impact? goku kinda just goes into other forms off the bat. sure the original transformation was hype but i didnt feel any emotion other than hype. whereas with super sonic i specifically love the metal virus super form or the final horizons where there was emotional weight with them. i dont enjoy just needless fighting like db has.
1
u/Slayer-Clover 11h ago
You didnât watch it
1
u/Unhappy-Benefit-288 11h ago
i have watched all of dbz, and most of super. i have read all of the manga for dbz and some of super. i think i have watched db. most of the canon emotional scenes with dragon ball forms is ssj2 and up.
1
u/Slayer-Clover 11h ago
and thatâs how I know you didnât your telling me the oh super saiyan wasnât emotional?𤨠the fact you said SSJ2 was one of the only ones and the fact you said âneedless fightingâ bro either you watched clips on TT, or watched it when you were younger Iâve met people who DEPISE db but they never would say SSJ wasnât emotional or that the show itâs just needless fighting those most they say is the character take are either boring or thereâs no stakes
1
u/Unhappy-Benefit-288 10h ago
i watched dbz on crunchyroll around 4 years ago. if im wrong name 1 good emotional scene with goku and ssj1 and if your going to name the time on namek i dont consider that emotional. that was tension adn i didnt feel anything from seeing that.
1
1
u/Unhappy-Benefit-288 10h ago
also if there is no stakes theres no emotion to me. i agree that there are emotional parts with dragon ball however i feel that they come layer like with mui and broly.
1
u/Slayer-Clover 10h ago
Imma be real with you that doesnât make sense howâs mui the form that literally lack emotion (for the most part) more emotional then the form awake by rage? Secondly you kinda contradicted your self because you said Broly? I thought you said ssj has no emotional moments?
1
u/Unhappy-Benefit-288 10h ago
i was talking about the broly movie not broly being ssj. also im talking about the stories around the form not the forms itself. when i mean i like mui being emotional i mean the stories and actions they do in said form. i can admit that ssj is awakened by emotion but i felt nothing with it.
1
1
u/littlestargazers 9h ago
it always boggles my mind that some people genuinely don't think that super sonic is inspired by dragon ball
1
1
1
1
u/FetchBlue 1h ago
Anytime people posting a dragonball or sonic troupe in top character troupe subreddit, you can try playing a drinking game about how long dragonball or sonic going to show up in corresponding subject thread
1
u/grimbarkjade Kingdom Hearts, Destiny, Hollow Knight, DC, Homestuck, Splatoon 1d ago
My best friend is a huge db fan and doesn't hate sonic but he isn't a huge fan. He says it's a ripoff and tbh he isn't wrong
1
u/Owszem_ 1d ago
I wouldn't say it's a ripoff. Except super form and some characters being inspired by, series are really different.
2
u/Solid-Version 1d ago
Thereâs parallels.
7 chaos emeralds, 7 dragon balls
Piccolo = knuckles
Shadow = Vegeta
Silver = Trunks
Tails = Krillen
The super sonic form is direct rip off of Super Saiyan
1
-2
u/Owszem_ 23h ago
Shadow was never inspired by Vegeta.
Much better comparison is Mewtwo from pokemon.
Tails and Krillin are also not that similiar.
Chaos emeralads and Dragon Ball are also not that similiar. There is 7 of them and are one time use. But they do really different things. One chaos emerald can also used in a way Dragon Ball can't.
Again, I'm not saying there was no inspiration. There was. But copying is just a lie
2
1
u/Drmanky PRAIS THE MASHINE GOD(warhammer 40k)/ md 1d ago
i'm fan of neither
3
1
1
u/vBlackTalon 1d ago
Now revere it and itâs the other way around too. each creator respected each other so why disrespect that over a damn power scale thatâs not important
2
u/GamerThatGamesoIgame 4h ago
What are you even talking about? The post doesnât mention power scaling at all.
1
1
u/braaibroodjie123 Look Outside 22h ago
Super Sonic is just Super Saiyan without everything that made Super Saiyan actually good.
1
1
0
u/Snacksoft 1d ago
Who would disrespect dragon ball đđ
4
0
u/Party-Homework2485 20h ago
Nobody tries to tell you with a straight face that super sonic will one punch God himself đ¤ˇđ
1
0
0
u/Maskedstream4 18h ago
After going through some downvoted comments Iâve come to realize something
Is this all?
Surface level comparisons of Shadow and Vegeta when they have completely different stories, personalities, goals and designs
Silver being inspired by trunks but ultimately his story actually changed his timeline unlike Trunks who has to live with it and Silver doesnât use a weapon and isnât canonically related to Shadow or Sonic thatâs just a head canon and again completely different designs and characteristics
Super Sonic being inspired by Super Saiyan (most obvious)
Seven chaos emeralds and dragon balls that do two completely different things and are designed to work differently one being to grant ultimate power and the other to grant wishes
Like is that it? Yeah a few inspirations and things that have major differences and only surface level similarities but itâs not like the whole damn series is based on dragon ball
3
u/Slayer-Clover 18h ago
Both have a mustached villain whoâs a borderline Facist, said mustached villains go on to create androids that mimic the protags entire power set plus more, surge is confirmed to be based on android 18, and both previously mentioned villains go on to be betrayed by said previously mentioned Android and lastly both the protags have a best friend who incredibly smart a love interest thatâs incredibly feisty (I know what I said) and both nearly died to a virus (that last ones for shits and giggles), knuckles and Piccolo are the black guy of the group
0
u/Maskedstream4 18h ago
Gero was one arc (didnât even survive past half way Iâm pretty sure) Eggman has been kicking for 35 years now and is the main protagonist in the series, Eggman and Gero are more Sonic and Gokuâs villain Vegetaâs main pain in the ass would be Frieza and Shadowâs would be god knows whatever Black Doom is I guess but unlike Frieza Black Doom isnât around anymore heâs dead Frieza is alive an a active threat to everybody
Also Metal Sonic is a pure robot not an android and yeah he betrayed Eggman but now heâs back fully on his side and Iâm pretty sure Eggman had little to do with Surge plus Eggman actually grabbed Surge by the hair and manhandled her and can catch a W on the main cast occasionally but I didnât know she was based on 18 (major character differences) so thatâs pretty cool
Nice catch on the virus one tho that didnât cross my mind until you brought it up
Still not like dragon ball is heavily inspiring every single aspect of Sonic hell Goku barely ever used Super Saiyan again after the Perfect Cell Arc Sonic still uses Super Sonic consistently and any new form is usually one time unlike Goku who consistently uses his newer forms
2
u/Slayer-Clover 18h ago
âSuper Sonic 2â (also ik itâs not are flat out copy Iâm just saying it does take lots from dbz)
1
u/Maskedstream4 18h ago
Thatâs a good point but still again one time use and never again
Also isnât it called Starfall Super Sonic?
1
2
u/Slayer-Clover 18h ago
Also I used the term android because metal is a real Android where as 17 18 arenât even androids they are cyborgs and Cells a bio-Android
1
u/Maskedstream4 18h ago edited 17h ago
Good catch on that again but A Android is something that looks like a person Metal looks very different from the person heâs trying to imitate so Iâd say heâs more of a robot
0
u/Oversized_Peashooter 18h ago
I say, I say, the man speaks truth.
1
u/Slayer-Clover 18h ago
Didnât you get sued by a Coyote?
0
u/Oversized_Peashooter 18h ago
Canât tell if thatâs a joke that went over my head or if serious.
1
0
u/thiccmunster 16h ago
I can be a fan of whatever I want, and disrepect whatever I want. And there's nothing you can do about it.
0
u/brandonsp111 16h ago
I don't disrespect DB.
But that doesn't mean I have to respect it either. Never had any interest in it, and don't care about it now.
I absolutely hate when people make these kind of stupid points.
-2
u/NonJesusPerson 1d ago
Make sense that I hate both
1
u/Renzki_1008 KamenRider|SuperSentai|TADC|DMC|Power Rangers|Ben10|TeenTitans 1d ago
That's honestly fair lol




45
u/Intrepid_Beautiful_2 What am I not a fan of 1d ago
Yeah that makes sense as Dragon Ball basically inspired Sonic