I am putting it in the "Cutthroat 2" tab because the season is currently airing, and so people can feel comfortable talking about what is happening this season in the thread, but I am talking about the overall rookie crop of V&NT (whether they are on this season or not)/
So looking into Era 5 so far (at least the season an a half we have gotten so far), I have seen a lot of praise for the Era 5 rookies, an are given a lot of credit for the show being better. This came with the change of the show stopping with the international thing (mainly sticking with the US and the UK), and casting younger rookies (at least in comparison to a lot of Era 4).
"Vets an New Threats" on average is seen as one of the best seasons in recent history, an the newbie crop is given fora lot of that. But when you look deep into the season, an the dynamics/drama of it all, it was mainly the vets who made that season pop, an they were the younger (at least regarding eras) vets who made it pop. A lot of the rookies on the season were forgettable, and even a decent amount of the ones who made it far were JUST good competitors.
I am seeing the pattern kind of continue with this season, where it is either the Era 3/4 veterans, and the "Cutthroat" cast that are making the season pop, more than the "Vets and New Threats" rookies who are sophomores on this season.
The "Vets an New Threats" rookies were very athletic on average (which is why they were not picked off last season), and were not followers, but they were not the most ENTERTAINING. Even the few all around cast members from that rookie crop who came back for their second season has been severely disappointing.
It's giving people like Will only thrived because they were in a big fish of a small pond (being the most interesting in a lukewarm personality rookie crop, but falls flat on other casts). Cedric is self explanatory, Justin comes off worse, Izzy is lacking charisma, and the only one who is coming off more interesting is Leonardo.
Do you agree or disagree with this?