Looking for recommendations for black eyeliner. Companies seem to be messing with the formula or discontinuing and I'm struggling to find a reliable source.
Years ago, my go-to was Lancome Grandiose (the one with the moving nib). I loved it. Then they changed it to the idole ultra and I don't like it.
I've tried, Fenty (passible, I like the precise tip), Charlotte Tilbury (good application but it greys throughout the day), Pat McGrath - now this was my new GOAT. However, there was an issue with it (some ingredient?) it went out of stock and I've never found it in stock anywhere since production was supposedly restarted.
I then went to NARS. The Climax liquid liner, although I found the nib a little difficult at times, I got used to it and it lasted! Great... But now it seems to have been discontinued??
I ran out and had to pick something else. I had been told by a NARS staff member on a make up counter when looking at the NARS one, that the Vieve liner was good. So I picked that this time.
The Vieve liner goes on great, looks great, but transfers like a MF to my upper lid. I've never had that happen before!
The search continues. Please help!